State aid in the privatisation of Malta Shipyards is acceptable to the European Commission, but by not longer than the end of the year – provided the government comes up with an alternative strategy because the one on the table at present will not result in a viable entity.
European Competition Commissioner Neelie Kroes made this statement prior to her departure from Malta yesterday after a working visit, which comprised meetings with President Edward Fenech Adami, Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi, Finance Minister Tonio Fenech and Malta Labour Party leader Joseph Muscat.
Speaking at the Malta International Airport, Minister Fenech said: “The government of Malta has explained its position on the privatisation of the shipyards and why we took the decision to do it, bearing in mind this government’s vision of wanting to be a regulator rather than an operator.”
He said that more meetings are expected to help at a technical level with the commission, specifically on the issues of competitiveness and state aid. He said that competitiveness in general was also discussed and both parties agreed that liberalisation resulted in more benefits for consumers.
Commissioner Kroes praised the government for the way it has handled the shipyards issue and termed it an “excellent” job. However, she said: “State aid is effectively tax payers’ money. Every euro spent in state aid needs to be explained to people on the streets and people who are shopping in supermarkets.”
Referring to the time frame for state aid (in reference to the e100 million in losses that the ‘yards need to make good for), Mrs Kroes categorically stated: “2008 – time is up.”
She said that the plans put forward by the government at this time were not acceptable according to EU law, but she was looking forward to receiving new proposals from the government.
“In principle it cannot be agreed to. State aid to a non-viable business is in breach of EU laws. It is not fair on companies that work like hell to make a living. It is also not fair to the taxpayer. There is no future with the plans as they are,” she said.
Asked by The Malta Independent whether she, as a Commissioner for Competition thought it was fair on taxpayers to shell out millions upon millions every year for close to a decade – to be then faced with a whopping e100 million to make good for, she said: “No. People might think I am talking like I am made of iron and steel, but no. It is not fair on them and it must stop by the end of this year. There will be no extension,” she said, stopping short of answering the question in terms of what still had to be paid off, or waived by the government prior to the sale of the companies.
Mrs Kroes said that Malta was an “excellent” EU member and reminded that size was not important, though conviction and culture was. She also pointed out that consumer authorities and associations needed to be transparent and independent for the benefit of the end customer.