The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Second Jury turns down insanity plea

Malta Independent Thursday, 18 September 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

A panel of jurors yesterday decided, with seven votes in favour and two against, that Anthony Schembri was not insane when he stabbed his wife Doris several times and killed her while she was a patient at St Luke’s Hospital.

The trial by jury, presided over by Mr Chief Justice Vincent De Gaetano, was held after Anthony Schembri, 61, from Sliema, pleaded that he was not in a state of sanity when he murdered his wife in September 2005.

The trial, known as a trial by jury to determine a plea of insanity, was held because Mr Schembri had pleaded insanity during the criminal proceedings being brought against him.

The jurors were not asked to decide if Mr Schembri was guilty of killing his wife, but rather whether or not he was in the right mental state to know what he was doing that afternoon.

The jurors took their decision after hearing the testimony of three court appointed psychiatrists, who stated on Tuesday, that Mr Schembri was not sane when he killed his wife.

The three psychiatrists had said that Mr Schembri suffered from delusional paranoia and schizophrenia – two mental conditions that fuelled his actions and which had “flared up before the incident took place.”

This is the second time that a trial by jury is held to determine a plea of insanity after Mr Schembri had pleaded insanity during the criminal proceedings brought against him.

The first trial was held on 21 May 2007 when a panel of jurors had decided, with six votes in favour and three against, that Mr Schembri was not in a state of insanity when he murdered his wife in September.

In handing down his judgement, Mr Chief Justice De Gaetano said that since the jurors decided that Mr Schembri was not insane when he killed his wife, the case will be sent back to the magistrates’ court where the compilation of evidence will continue.

He ordered that Mr Schembri will be remanded in custody at Mount Carmel Hospital and added that if another appeal is filed, the judicial proceedings will continue until the appeal is decided.

In fact, just after the Chief Justice handed down his judgement, Mr Schembri’s defence counsel Dr David Gatt presented an appeal.

Senior Counsel to the Republic Anthony Barbara and Dr Nadine Sant from the office of the Attorney General prosecuted while Dr Anglu Farrugia and Dr David Gatt appeared for Mr Schembri.

  • don't miss