The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Court Warns that parish feuds do immense damage

Malta Independent Sunday, 21 September 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The Magistrate’s Court in Gozo has decided a civil case instituted by the former archpriest of the Gozo Cathedral parish, Mgr Joe Vella Gauci regarding comments made by the other parish of Victoria, the St George’s Parish, at that time led by Mgr Joseph Farrugia.

Originally, the case was against Andrew Formosa as editor and A&M Printing as publisher, but Mgr Farrugia subsequently informed the court that Mr Formosa was not the editor and that the publication in question was the official publication of the parish at that time run by him.

On 16 August 2006, the local radio station Radju Katidral broadcast a programme in which the president of the Leone Band Club, Dr Michael Caruana, took part and at which Mgr Vella Gauci was present.

During the programme, Dr Caruana attacked Mgr Farrugia calling him a liar and a person who discredits others by what he says.

The next day, Mgr Farrugia wrote to the Bishop of Gozo complaining that his colleague (Mgr Vella Gauci) did not stop Dr Caruana, although he may have done that privately.

Mgr Farrugia also complained to the Broadcasting Authority, which in January 2007 decided that the words expressed by Dr Caruana “do little to enhance the spirit of fraternity in a community, and that Dr Caruana was thus spreading sectarian hatred in the community.

It thus ordered Radju Katidral to read a statement saying it was sorry for the words uttered by Dr Caruana against Mgr Farrugia.

This decision seemed to have settled things, as the next issue of the St George Parish publication, at the beginning of February 2007, contained a statement by Mgr Farrugia entitled: “An apology that I accept’ ending with the statement “Issa li ghadda, ghadda” (Now what’s done is done).

But things did not quite turn out to be so. On 14 February 2007, the Broadcasting Authority informed Radju Katidral that the statement as broadcast was not in conformity with its directive and wanted the station to read out a much stronger one. Dr Caruana reacted and proved to the authority that the new statement would have been libellous in his regard, thus the authority did not insist on the reading out of the new statement.

But the St George Parish publication, in its July-August issue referred to the matter saying that the BA condemnation had not been withdrawn. It was on this article that the case was based.

In his judgement, Magistrate Dr Anthony Ellul was very forthcoming in his opinion on this intra-parish feuding and those fomenting it.

Why was it felt necessary to issue a supplement of the St George parish publication to give its own version of what happened when the issue had been addressed by the Broadcasting Authority and when the same archpriest (Mgr Farrugia) had declared ‘What’s done is done’?

Why did the Cathedral parish issue a supplement in which Dr Caruana stated that the authority had withdrawn its directive? This only served, Dr Ellul stated, to rub salt into the wounds.

Prudence and wisdom would have suggested, the magistrate continued, that the issue was closed rather that more papers be printed. Such disputes only serve to damage the Church at a time when it is facing huge challenges. Religious people must do their utmost to cut out the rivalry and the feuding, rather than kindling it. Festas are an integral part of Maltese culture and should be celebrations that promote unity and joy; fanaticism causes damage and more polarization.

Besides, members of the clergy must not tolerate or be compassionate with those who create a hostile and tense atmosphere within the parish with the excuse that by doing so they are defending the honour of the parish.

The court turned down a plea by Mgr Farrugia that this matter had already been judged by a Church tribunal, the Media Ethical Council presided by Judge Caruana Colombo, with Dr Robert Tufigno and Mgr Fortunato Mizzi as members.

Finally, the court did not find the statement in the St George Parish publication as being libellous with regard to Dr Caruana.

  • don't miss