The University lecturing staff were yesterday directed to go on general strike for one day today in response to the government’s dragging of feet and refusal to meet their pay demands.
The staff, addressed by Victor Buttigieg, president of UMASA, the University of Malta Academic Staff Association, and John Bencini, president of the Malta Union of Teachers, feel that they are bound by the government’s 2015 learning centre of excellence vision, but want better salaries for what they consider to be heavier responsibilities and workload in what they believe is already a much underpaid sector in Maltese society.
During this meeting, the unions divulged the lecturers’ gross home take pay and increases offered by the government. Meanwhile, in a statement issued yesterday afternoon by the Finance Ministry, the government spoke of the actual gross financial package, the gross package on offer for the year 2009 and the unions’ demands. The figures provided by the unions and the government do not tally.
Mr Bencini said the University lecturing staff’s collective agreement had expired in 2003 and the one being discussed at present had been on the table since May 2007. He said that the government was dragging its feet on the matter and that the Finance Ministry had tried to blackmail the unions into accepting the pay deal by telling them that “we will put the salary offers on display for all to see in the four corners of Malta if you do not accept them”.
Mr Bencini said: “Well, we decided to play the government at its own game and we are going to divulge these offers ourselves. For starters, to compare like with like, a professor at a University in Cyprus can expect to take home a gross salary of e81,000.”
This was some e50,000 more than what a professor working at the University of Malta gets. When asked to comment about this while visiting stands at Freshers’ Week held on campus, Education Minister Dolores Cristina did not speak on the actual difference since there were other matters which had to be taken into consideration, she said, adding that what the unions were expecting was definitely much higher than what the government had offered.
She also expressed her hope for a sustainable solution to be found in a timely manner for the benefit of all concerned.
Speaking on the work for lecturing staff, Mr Bencini said that this had increased dramatically over the past few years with bigger student:lecturer ratios, more research programmes, EU programmes, publications and general productivity.
He said that the unions had agreed to the draft agreement text, but were shocked when they were shown the pay packages increases on offer. He said that the government had poured money into certain sectors – particularly the medical profession. “A consultant, who is traditionally the equivalent of a senior lecturer used to take home e30,281 in 2007. After the collective agreement, he will take home e58,141 in 2008, e61,774 in 2009 and e65,408 in 2010,” said Mr Bencini.
“We pointed this out to the Finance Ministry and they agreed with us, but said they simply could not afford it. The government wants a centre of excellence, but then tells us they can’t afford it. It is time for lecturing staff at university to decide what they want to do with their careers,” said Mr Buttigieg.
Mr Bencini said that a university professor can expect to take home some e31,881 with a proposed increase to e33,505 in 2009 and e39,733 in 2014. He said that the agreement ran out in 2014, adding that people could guess why – obviously hinting that it would be general election time.
Senior lecturers, on the other hand, take home e26,465 and this is proposed to increase to e27,769 in 2009. An assistant lecturer is to get e20,300 by end 2008 to go up to e21,247 in 2009. “The government basically wants to buy a Jaguar for the price of a Mini Minor,” said Mr Bencini.
He said that the unions and the staff wanted to give students the very best and to show them that they were serious lecturers. “We do not want things to stay as they are, we do want to become a centre of excellence, but that comes at a price,” said Mr Bencini.
He said the unions felt that they wanted decent salaries and were not going overboard. “We are, after all, training the next generation of Malta’s professionals. The mediator yesterday told me there was no way that the government was going to budge. So I will tell the government that if it’s no way for us, then it’s no way for them,” said Mr Bencini.
He said that the unions were directing teaching staff to go on a one-day general strike today. People on probation are exempt from the directive and if no progress is registered, industrial action may be stepped up.
Government’s reaction
In its statement, the government said that it was offering a financial package which would considerably improve the actual one but this was not accepted by the unions.
The government described the unions’ expectations as non-realistic and which would put enormous weight on the country, estimated to reach e140 million on a period of six years if this were to be accepted. The Finance Ministry thus decided to publish the amounts being demanded “after the unions decided to quote an insignificant part from what the government is actually offering,” the official statement said.
This explained that the actual package for a professor was e37,806. The government offered a rise to e41,560 for the year 2009 and this was to increase to e64,800 by the year 2014. The unions asked for a rise to e69,285 for the year 2008 and e85,993 by the year 2012.
Meanwhile, a senior lecturer is currently being paid e31,118. The offered salary for 2009 was e32,311 which would rise to e44,156 by 2014. The unions were demanding an increase to e57,677 for the year 2008 which should increase to e70,514 by 2012.
The package mentioned by the government for the grade of assistant lecturer for this year ran to e22,635. This was to increase to e23,584 for the year 2009 and to e29,263 by the year 2014 but the unions were asking for e31,249 for the year 2008 and a raise to e37,672 by the year 2012.
“The figures which the unions are asking for,” the statement said, “would lead to a percentual increase of around 80 per cent for the top four grades of academic staff being those of professor, associate professor, senior lecturer and lecturer.” These grades have seen an 11 per cent increase after an interim agreement was reached in December 2007, it added.
The additional investment in connection with this offer was estimated to exceed e55 million on a period of six years and includes a reform to strengthen university.
The government said that it was not in a position to increase the financial package offered and was not ready to re-open discussions on the matter. If this was not accepted, new discussions will take place on the present collective agreement.
UMASA and MUT replied to the government’s statement calling upon academic staff at the University to study the offered remuneration carefully.
The unions said that they “were surprised and disappointed that after two years of intense negotiations over a comprehensive package intended to reform the University, government is now threatening to withdraw the whole package and decline to support its investment in Malta’s most valuable asset – its human resources and future generations”.