European Union governments may seek to keep the European Commission in office beyond the end of its five-year term next year so that each member State can retain its own commissioner, EU diplomats said on Friday.
But if the Lisbon Treaty is not in place by June 2009, member States should keep their word on slimming down the European Commission, centre-right MEPs have argued, warning that parliamentarians would be reluctant to support a prolonged mandate for the current team of Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso.
Peter Mandelson, the EU’s British trade commissioner, became the third member of the bloc’s executive body this year to give up his job for a ministerial post in his home country.
The aim of the new plan – still in its early stages – is to reassure the EU’s smaller countries, such as the three Baltic states, Cyprus, Malta and, in particular, Ireland – that they will not lose their national representative on the Commission when its successor is appointed.
Fears that Ireland would lose its automatic right to a commissioner and exert less influence in the EU was one factor in Irish voters’ rejection in June of the EU’s Lisbon Treaty on institutional reform, an Irish government study concluded last month.
Even before the Irish referendum, governments that favour a smaller, more efficient Commission were coming round to the view that it might be politically unwise to abandon the principle of “one country, one commissioner”.
Four months after the referendum, many EU politicians and officials see this as a price that must be paid to secure Irish approval of the treaty.
The present Commission, led by José Manuel Barroso, its Portuguese president, is due to complete its term on 31 October 2009.
It has 27 members – one per State – but under the EU’s Nice Treaty, which remains in force unless all governments ratify the Lisbon Treaty, that number must be reduced when the next Commission takes office.
Some governments hope to persuade Ireland to hold a second referendum on Lisbon in October 2009 and then, if the Irish vote Yes, to call the treaty into effect in January 2010.
By letting Mr Barroso’s team stay in place for a few months until the treaty came into force, the EU would ensure that the next Commission would be chosen under Lisbon’s rules rather than those of Nice.
Under the Lisbon Treaty, every country will be able to keep its own commissioner until at least 2014.
Over the next five years, however, the EU may even drop its plans to slim down the Commission after 2014.
Diplomats acknowledged the proposal to extend the term of Mr Barroso’s commission would come to nothing if Ireland voted No again.
“Time is against us,” Spanish conservative deputy Inigo Mendez de Vigo from the constitutional affairs committee in the European Parliament told journalists on Thursday, following last week’s visit by the Irish foreign minister Michael Martin in Brussels.
Ireland was originally supposed to indicate what it wants to do about the Lisbon Treaty, a reform of the 27-strong Union that was rejected in June by Irish voters, to the Heads of States and governments set to gather for a two-day summit on Wednesday.
But Mr Martin confirmed to MEPs on Monday that Dublin needs time for “comprehensive research” and only by December does the country “expect to be able... to outline the necessary steps to achieve our objective of continued full engagement in the Union.”
Mr de Vigo thinks, however, that it would be too late for the new institutional set-up to come into effect before the European elections in June, meaning that the pre-vote campaign would be again focused on the treaty rather than on other issues of concern for EU citizens.
Moreover, it would mean that the bloc’s assembly would be elected under the current Nice Treaty with a different distribution of seats – 736 instead of 751 MEPs with fewer seats for 12 member States – and less power than envisaged by the reform document.
If that is the case, argued Mr de Vigo, the centre-right European People’s Party (EPP-ED), the biggest parliamentary group in the 785-member legislature, would press for the rules on the composition of the EU executive also to be respected.
Under the Nice Treaty, “the European Council (Heads of States and governments) will have to take a unanimous decision to reduce the number of commissioners. Are they ready to do that?” the Spanish deputy asked rhetorically.
“The EPP will be against any prolongation of the mandate of the current commission. We will not accept having the Nice Treaty on the number of seats in the parliament, and the European Council not taking a decision on the reduction of the number of commissioners that is also in the Nice Treaty.”