The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Court: Judgment Challenges adoption law

Malta Independent Wednesday, 15 October 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

A judgment by Mr Justice Giannino Caruana Demajo decreed that the three-year period married couples had to wait to adopt was discriminatory.

The judgment came after a couple filed an application before the First Hall of Civil Courts against the Department for Standards in Social Protection and the Social Policy Minister.

They claimed that the civil code discriminated against them as single people could apply for an adoption straight away, while couples had to be married for three years, after an amendment lowered the period from five years this year.

The couple said they contacted Agenzija Appogg as they wanted to adopt a child. However, they were told that they could not apply as yet as they had not been married for three years.

They said they married after a five-year betrothal, as the husband was awaiting civil annulment of his previous marriage.

They claimed that the law both discriminatory and in violation of their right to a family life and was discriminatory.

Quoting European Court of Human Rights case law, Mr Justice Caruana Demajo said there was no such thing as a fundamental right for individuals to adopt, however, he did agree that the law discriminated against married couples.

He said that there was no justifiability, objectivity or rationale in discriminating against married couples. In fact, the law provides for a cohabiting couple to adopt without passing through the three-year moratorium. In this case, either the man or the woman can apply for adoption.

The court ordered that a copy of the judgment be sent to the Speaker of the House of Representatives.

Lawyers Edward Zammit Lewis and Michael Camilleri represented the couple.

  • don't miss