Two courts last week issued judgments on two separate cases that in one way or another are connected with the still ongoing judicial fall-out following the collapse of the Bank of Industry, Commerce and Agriculture (BICAL) in 1973.
In one case, the First Hall of the Civil Court, presided over by Judge Geoffrey Valenzia, found against Cecil Pace in a case instituted by him against Italian lawyer Michele Martone and his son Massimiliano.
The case regarded shares in Malta & Europe Hotels, which owned the former Excelsior Hotel in Floriana.
Mr Pace argued that Mr Martone Jr held 9,212 shares in MEH, which had been passed on to him by his father who, in turn, had obtained one of the shares from JS Zammit and the remainder from shareholders Antonio Ghidoli and Nada delle Piane.
Mr Pace argued that the company’s Articles of Association state that “no share may be transferred to non members unless it is first offered to the shareholders who shall have the right of first option…”
Mr Martone Sr, however, argued that the same case had already been argued, and lost by Mr Pace, in the case Herbert Baldacchino (on behalf of Mr Martone) vs Cecil Pace decided by the First Hall in 1997, confirmed by the Court of Appeal in 2000 and reconfirmed in 2004.
Mr Martone also argued that Mr Pace was not a shareholder in MIDC or MEH, since the transfer of two shares from Anthony Borg to Mr Pace had never been approved or registered.
The Court held that Mr Pace, as a shareholder in MIDC, could have been authorised to act on behalf of that company but he had not obtained the necessary authorisation. It subsequently found that this case was, in legal terms, “res iudicata”.
In a second case, the First Hall of the Civil Court, presided over by Judge Lino Farrugia Sacco, halved from Lm1 million to €1.2 million two court injunctions submitted by Mr Martone and his son against BICAL controller Raymond Gatt and a whole raft of BICAL firms as cautionary proceedings in a case that is still ongoing and is due to continue being heard next January.
Mr Martone argued that the BICAL representatives had neglected to execute the obligations they assumed in an agreement dated 30 September 1991 that had been guaranteed by the Government of Malta itself.
The government, represented by the then Finance Minister George Bonello du Puis, had guaranteed “that the obligations in terms of Clause 5 will be honoured and that the government will allow the proceeds to be transferred abroad.”
BICAL controller Mr Gatt argued that the injunction was aimed at impeding his actions and that, even if he had funds, these would have been blocked by these actions.
He also argued that, in any event, the government was guaranteeing that the Martones would be paid, but Mr Martone rebutted that the government’s guarantee was limited to his eventually being allowed to take his money out of Malta. It was because of the 1991 agreement that his company had removed a previous blockage of funds so that the (Excelsior) hotel could be sold.
The Court ruled that it considered the injunctions should be reduced, given all the circumstances of the case.