From Mr G.G. Debono
Professor Mallia’s description of government’s excruciating indecision and conflicting pronouncements and changes of plans in relation to wind energy in Malta (Changing direction on wind energy, TMIS, 5 October) richly deserves a follow-up.
Malta’s renewable energy saga started with a proposal for the installation of a 12-turbine wind farm on the large uninhabited area of Marfa Ridge. The projected output was equivalent to the annual consumption of 6,000 homes or five per cent of Malta’s energy needs at the time.
This project was summarily turned down for reasons that were not clear at the time but it gradually emerged over the ensuing months and years that the dominant reason for the reluctance to build a wind farm on land was “visual intrusion” and an irrational fear that it would affect our tourist industry.
This was the outcome of unprofessional, off-the-cuff speculation on the part of a few people who really had very little idea on the matter. In particular, the decision was not based on scientific data from opinion surveys. Years later, nobody seems to have become any wiser; on the contrary, the misinformation has gone around and around and the obsession with visual intrusion has assumed such diabolical proportions that it continues to hold up Malta’s first step towards large scale exploitation of renewable energy.
At the same time, investment in wind energy is increasing in leaps and bounds in other countries such as Spain, Germany, the USA and Denmark, while Malta remains steadfastly committed to burning oil.
Had the Marfa project not been turned down, this wind farm would now have been into its fifth year of electricity generation. It would have given us a clear notion of the potential and acceptability of generating energy from land-based wind farms in Malta. Local technicians would have gained hands-on experience in the servicing and maintenance of wind energy generators and we would have tested the logistics of adding a major (intermittent) source of electricity to our grid.
As of now, all Malta can boast about is a tiny pilot project at Marfa with a miniature three kilowatt wind turbine, the energy output of which is about enough to boil four kettles of water.
While it is perfectly appropriate to consider an offshore wind farm such as the one on Sikka l-Bajda that is currently under evaluation, it would be logical to start on land for a number of reasons.
Land-based turbines are infinitely less logistically complicated to build. They cost much less and are cheaper to maintain, to the extent that electricity from land-based turbines is now cheaper than fossil fuel-derived electricity. They can be built much more quickly and damage to the terrain is minimal, so that the turbines can be removed after they have served their useful life, leaving barely a trace.
Besides helping us to better evaluate the potential of wind energy in Malta, investing in one or two land-based wind farms will give us valuable hands-on experience in handling wind energy before we commit ourselves to go out to sea. Starting at sea with a high capacity wind farm may, in any event, pose problems owing to the lack of buffering capacity of our grid.
The results of numerous surveys on public attitudes to (land-based) wind farms are very consistent. They show, in general, that about 80 per cent of people have no objection to wind turbines, about 15 per cent are neutral and a small percentage oppose them. “Before and after” surveys show that acceptance of wind farms increases, once the wind farm is in place.
As to the irrational fear that it will affect our tourist industry, none of the surveys on the effect of wind farms on tourism have suggested a detrimental effect on local tourism. In fact, tourists visiting Malta have been known to express amazement at the remarkable absence of renewable energy installations in the country.
Another major objection is that of “limited land resources”. This seems to be based on the misconception that huge tracts of land have to be taken over by wind farms. This is not so at all. If we take the 12-turbine wind farm that was proposed in 2002 as an example, this would have occupied less than a square mile. Malta has many exposed areas that are virtually uninhabited in the south and west of the island. These sites are mostly far from the densely inhabited areas that are concentrated in one third of the northeast of the island. This situation easily allows for the establishment of at least one land-based wind farm.
The situation in Malta is best described by the amusing cartoon of a distressed man with lots of acupuncture needles stuck into his scalp whose wife is saying to him: “Wouldn’t it be easier if you just took a couple of aspirins for that headache?”
The obvious best option is staring us in the face, but Malta has chosen to ignore it and go straight for a more expensive and complicated solution which, although also sustainable, should not be the first option. Of course there will be “visual intrusion”, but the results of surveys suggest that people will grow to love the wind turbines and that tourists won’t mind them at all.
G.G. Debono
ST JULIAN’S
The author will be pleased to supply a summary of the surveys referred to above. Requests should be addressed to [email protected]