The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Proposed Energy tariffs: Government must start consultation process from scratch – MLP

Malta Independent Tuesday, 21 October 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The government has no choice but to take back its proposed energy tariffs and start a proper consultation process from scratch, since the tariffs would affect the country’s competitiveness at the worst time possible, Labour leader Joseph Muscat insisted yesterday.

Addressing a press conference on the MLP’s critical analysis of the proposed energy tariffs, Dr Muscat said it was not the right time to introduce increased tariffs on water and electricity.

Dr Muscat said that while the government may adjust the tariffs marginally, they have, unfortunately, already damaged the country’s economy.

It is certainly a bad decision to backdate them to 1 October since this would undermine the concept of economic stability and the country’s credibility with foreign investors, he said, adding that the proposed tariffs have created a lot of uncertainty that had an impact on expenditure.

“This is a time when there needs to be more money in people’s pockets, rather than in the government’s pocket. Other countries are seeking ways of stimulating the economy at this difficult moment of financial turmoil. The Maltese government, on the other hand, wants to create a crisis,” said Dr Muscat.

He put forward detailed workings of the proposed tariffs, saying there were discrepancies in the government’s calculations when compared with data from the 2005 Census.

In trying to mitigate the effect of the statistical increases, the government included garages and summer residences in the number of households upon which it based its calculations, said Dr Muscat.

Moreover, the government’s eco-reduction scheme (for households consuming less than 1,300 units per person, per year) is not realistic since, according to the MLP’s calculations, a three-person household consumes at least 1,500 units per person, per year.

The Labour leader said there was also inconsistency in the government’s argumentation before and after the election.

“Last year, the government said the economy was doing well, but could not afford the burden of an 83 per cent surcharge, so together with Enemalta Corporation, it carried part of the burden.

“As soon as the election was over, however, the government introduced a 95 per cent surcharge. Now that things aren’t going too well, the government wants to introduce energy tariffs equivalent to a 245 per cent surcharge.”

Asked what he would have done had he been in the government’s shoes, Dr Muscat said he certainly would not have proposed tariffs that leave such a big shock, he would not have decided to have them backdated to 1 October, and he would have consulted with the social partners in a proper manner.

And asked about EU deadlines regarding state aid to Enemalta, Dr Muscat said the government had to be tough in its negotiations with the EU, especially when families’ well-being and the country’s competitiveness were at stake.

He insisted on the need for long-term macro-economic leadership that would take into consideration wider aims rather than simply short-term measures.

A copy of the Labour Party’s critical analysis has been sent to all the social partners sitting on the Malta Council for Economic and Social Development (MCESD).

Dr Muscat said the party would also be coming up with a whole strategy on energy, and he added that the MLP has commissioned a study regarding ways of tackling inefficiencies in the generation of energy.

  • don't miss