The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Trial By jury: Victims’ memory on rape charges hazy

Malta Independent Tuesday, 21 October 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

A jury yesterday heard the statements of two Swedish students, Sandra Vikstrom and Teresia Williams, who claimed they were raped but admitted they were too drunk to remember what happened exactly or who raped them.

The statements were read out in court in a trial by jury that started yesterday against two Libyan men over an incident that allegedly took place on 14 May 2006.

Nader Abdulaziz Elgerian, 29, from Libya, is pleading not guilty to raping Sandra Vikstrom on 14 May 2006 at Shingles Bay in St Julian’s. He is also pleaded not guilty to the charges of violent indecent assault and threatening Zakarija Abdisamed Abukar with his life, at the police headquarters on 14 May 2006. Mr Abukar was an eyewitness who helped the police in their investigation.

Hasan Mohamed Ahmed, 28, from Libya, is pleading not guilty to the charges of acting as an accomplice while Mr Elgerian raped Ms Vikstrom. He is also pleading not guilty to acting as an accomplice while Mr Elgerian committed violent indecent assault. Both men are pleading not guilty to slightly injuring Ms Vikstrom and holding her against her will.

During the trial, presided over by Mr Justice Joseph Galea Debono, the prosecution read out the statement of the alleged victim Sandra Vikstrom, a Swedish student. Ms Vikstrom and Teresia Williams were not present.

In her statement, Ms Vikstrom said her “memory was not that good” because she was drunk. She said that, together with Teresa Williams, they left the hotel at around 11pm and went to several clubs and met two men, one of whom was Mr Elgerian, at around 4am. She said she could not remember the road they took to return to the hotel and said that she had drank too much and was not capable of taking care of herself.

Ms Vikstrom said that they ended up at a beach. She said that while she was sitting down, a man came next to her. However, she said she could not remember his face. “I remember he started touching me, but I could not remember exactly where.” Ms Vikstrom said she could not remember what happened as she blacked out and the next thing she remembered was seeing more men.

“One man (whom she recognised as Mr Ahmed) sat on my chest and held my hands down. I don’t remember him speaking to me,” her statement said. She said that another person took off her trousers and raped her. “I am sure that Ahmed was the person sitting on my chest while I was being raped.”

However, she admitted that she could not see who raped her because Mr Ahmed was blocking her view. “I confirm that my memory is not good – I cannot remember everything as I was drunk.” Ms Vikstrom said she found her clothes, put them on and found her friend Williams and started walking away from the beach.

“When I was being raped, I screamed a lot but no one came to help me. Ms Williams screamed a lot too,” she said.

When they arrived on the road, they met a policeman who called for an ambulance.

The court also heard the statement issued by Ms Williams. She had told the police that she could not remember what happened exactly as she was too drunk.

“At one point I remember being on the beach. I saw a man on my friend Sandra, the same man who walked with her from the club.”

Ms Williams told the police that another guy threw her on the rocks, lifted up her skirt, covering her mouth and nose. She said she tried to fight him but also said that she could not remember if she was raped. “At that time they were raping Sandra – I cannot recognise them but I think one of them was Mr Ahmed who was sitting on her chest. The man who raped me went to rape Sandra, but someone held me – I don’t remember.”

However, she also said that she could not remember if they spoke about having sex. “I was drunk – I was drunk also on the beach. It was very dark on the beach but I could see the faces of the guys on the beach.”

In his testimony, Police Inspector Paul Vassallo, who led the investigation, explained that the incident took place on 14 May 2006 at around 4am.

The inspector said that the two girls came to Malta for a holiday on 9 May and were due to leave on 16 May. The girls told the police that they left their hotel, which was in Paceville, at around 11pm and went to a club.

He added that when he spoke to Mr Ahmed at the police station, Mr Ahmed said that he was next to the car park looking for his friend and saw two girls who looked upset. He ran away when he saw the police because he did not want to be considered a suspect.

Insp. Vassallo went to on say that Mr Elgerian told the police that he went to the beach with one of the girls because she had consented to have sex with him. However, while they were having sex, he saw another three men and ran off because he was afraid.

Insp. Vassallo said that Mr Ahmed told the police that on 14 May 2006, he was with his friend Karim at a nightclub. Since he did not drink alcohol, he left the bar and went for a coffee. Half an hour later, he went back to the club to look for his friend Karim.

Mr Ahmed told the police that Karim had left but went to look for him next to the sea because he looked drunk. He remained there for a short time and heard screams. As he was leaving, he was stopped by the police and tried to get away.

The court also heard the testimony of Zakarija Abdisamed Abukar. He said that on 14 may he was in Paceville where he met some friends. When he tried to enter a club, he was refused entry because he did not have a membership.

He said he went to the beach to drink alcohol with his friend. “I saw two Libyans coming with two girls.”

He said that he recognised Mr Elgerian who tried to talk one of the girls to have sex with him but she was not interested. Mr Abukar said that he saw Mr Elgerian attempt to remove the girl’s trousers but she tried to stop him. However, he then saw Mr Hassan hold her down and her hands. However, he said that she did not scream but seemed to be enjoying it.

On hearing this, Dr Barbara asked Mr Abukar if he remembered his testimony during the compilation of evidence and if he said the same thing two years ago. He also asked him if his life was ever threatened. Mr Abukar replied yes and pointed to Mr Elgerian.

Dr Barbara also read out Mr Abukar’s statement during the compilation of evidence two years ago where he said that he saw a girl being held by two men and she was trying to escape. Mr Justice Galea Debono asked Mr Abukar if what he had said under oath two years ago was true, to which he replied yes.

The prosecution was led by Senior Counsel to the Republic Anthony Barbara while Dr Joe Brincat appeared for the two men.

  • don't miss