The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

The MITTS Scandal – the mystery thickens

Malta Independent Tuesday, 21 October 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 19 years ago

The gatekeeping by Austin Gatt’s media friends was not enough to cover the fact that the government is simply sitting on a time bomb over the MITTS scandal.

Not only did they refrain from mentioning that the Opposition Leader made a strong call for a truly independent inquiry into the whole issue and that I personally called on the minister to offer his resignation because of the confirmed total collapse of the operational side of MITTS’s security systems, but the same media that instantly gloated on Austin Gatt’s unfounded allegation against Alfred Sant took days to mention that the day after Mr Speaker ruled that there had been an unequivocal breach of privilege by Minister Gatt due to his unfounded allegations against the former Opposition Leader.

In other countries such a scandal as the MITTS saga would have led to massive resignations.

On the contrary in this Svizzera fil-Mediterran which certain non-Labour leaning people are nowadays referring to jokingly in social circles as Zimbabwe fl-Ewropa, we had a minister who tried to lead us to believe that this was nothing but a storm in a tea cup where no one should be held politically accountable. The reason being – according to his twisted rationale – that it appeared that the shortcomings were not the result of a faulty policy that MITTS might have adopted, but due to the wrong application of procedures and systems. He even tried to almost make us feel thankful for the cronies running MITTS that the board consistently approved all investment requests by the management and which had to do with the security and operations of MITTS.

What triggered me into calling for the minister’s resignation is that while he has a penchant for being known to regularly ask for the head of various politically appointees of organisations that fall under his brief, this time round things were slightly different. We cannot for a moment forget that the MITTS chairman is none other than his former personal assistant in the ministry and now also CEO at SmartCity.

How and why he was chosen by SmartCity is none of my business. But then some might have argued that he was “the best placed” for the job since he mid-wifed the whole project and was heavily involved in negotiating “the best terms” for the Maltese government in the “hard talks” with Tecom Ltd.

Had the MITTS incident been an isolated case I would have held my horses. But the most damning part of the ministerial statement by Minister Gatt was when he admitted that it resulted that:

a) not all security systems at MITTS were being adhered to, for one reason or another, b’decizjoni tal-persuni responsabbli ghall-implimentazzjoni taghhom – as the result of a decision of all those persons responsible for their implementation.

b) These shortcomings were also the result of the fact that both policies and written security procedures were regularly ignored – a classical case in point being that there existed “a culture among workers” for which read tradition and norm, that a number of employees used to exchange personal passwords among themselves to “speed up work”. Reminds me of a pastor trying to justify wife swapping!

The minister went so much out of his way to back the board of directors, which is chaired by his former side-kick, that he praised “them” for offering their resignation because they felt that at day’s end “the buck stops there”. As I commented in the House it sounded far more like a case of passing the buck.

But what prompted me to comment that the mystery about this saga continues to thicken were the following reasons:

a) The government’s reluctance so far to come clean about this messy affair by openly embracing the Opposition Leader’s call for an independent inquiry by shifting the onus on the Commissioner of Police to “recommend” it.

b) That the government tried to play down the confirmation that over 20,000 government passwords were stolen for reasons still as yet unknown. All we were offered was the solace that nevertheless no illegal access to the e-mail accounts of MITTS users resulted from the whole saga. For solace I would rather wait for the next Bond movie “Quantum of solace” which should prove to be far more satisfying!

c) If the usernames and passwords belonging to so many thousands of users of the government IT system were copied by hackers or staffers, why did it take so long to involve the police?

d) One moment we were told that this was just a sad saga that could and should have been avoided, and the next we were told that it was so serious that to feel reassured we shall now have a National Information Security Agency set up in the coming days, which will be separate but complementary to the Malta IT Agency and the Malta Communications Authority in the sector of information security.

e) It is even more worrying that according to the minister all traces of the attack on the Maltese Embassy in Cairo showed that it was the work of an amateur. What would have happened had real and truly professional hackers been involved as is likely to have been the case when Dar Malta was recently hacked in Brussels so much so that both IT specialists and security services people were flown over urgently to the Belgian city to try and remedy matters?

f) We have been told that it was the MITTS board which had insisted on a forced password change. Pity that no one had the decency to inform us or to explain to any of us 20,000 users what had triggered such a sudden change. It was even worse that we had to learn about this whole saga from an independent media source since otherwise everything would have long been dead and buried before we even had time to say bingo!

g) For a minister to have been responsible for MITTS for so long, and in recent times having it headed by a personal confidante of his, it is indeed rich to admit that there were a number of deficiencies at MITTS which had to be addressed as soon as possible.

h) If the board is above board, who is responsible for the burdens normally carried by COOs and CEOs?

i) Why did it have to be yours truly to point out that it was shameful indeed that the MITTS CEO was reported to have gone abroad at a time when investigations into this whole saga were still underway?

j) Why did the minister not mention anything about all this and had to wait for my interjection to declare that the guy in question should be ashamed of himself to go abroad at such a sensitive time when the investigation was being held?

k) What caused the sudden change of heart with the minister first attacking the CEO publicly and then declaring that such absences are normally sanctioned by the MITTS board and that in this case they felt that his absence was justified since he had to travel for personal reasons?

l) Although the minister tried to give us the impression that usernames and passwords were swapped lightly at a lower level, it resulted that in the three cases mentioned in the statement it was found that in actual fact the user name and password of one of the MITTS team leaders who formed part of NOC – the Network Operations Centre – and who had administrator rights on the server, were used to access the server involved in the whole incident!

m) The minister failed to reply to my question as to whether MITTS regularly rely on external IT security audits as most professional security conscious companies and organisations normally do both in Malta and particularly abroad, rather than relying solely on internal in-house IT security audits. Why? Could it be that such external IT security audits are not carried out at all?

n) Are we correct in assuming that none of MITTS employees are being investigated at all or are investigations of MITTS staffers still ongoing? This was a grey area that the minister did not address.

o) Why did the minister first claim that he would be commenting only once Police investigations were formally concluded and now because he apparently could not take the heat any longer, he chose to go for an interim report since according to him the investigation at MITTS is still ongoing and that the Police who only days earlier claimed that any statement would prejudice their investigations, now conveniently gave the green light for such a political statement “without prejudicing their investigations?”

The most “reassuring” bit was that MITTS all along told the minister that hacking was “highly improbable” and that “Minister Gatt had even chosen not to inform the PM at all about this saga” simply because he himself felt so much at ease that he did not even bother to refrain from continuing to use his gov.mt account!

The mystery thickens!!!

e-mail: [email protected]

Leo Brincat is the Main Opposition Spokesperson for the Environment, Sustainable Development and Climate Change

  • don't miss