The government was yesterday seen downsizing the extent of its contentious proposals on upwardly revising water and electricity rates at yesterday’s meeting of the Malta Council for Economic and Social Development, according to sources close to discussions.
While the contents of yesterday’s two-hour meeting were shrouded in secrecy, with all government and social partner representatives refusing to give even an indication of the content or tone of yesterday’s proceedings, sources informed The Malta Independent that the government yesterday proposed trimming e60 million off the global annual figure of e365 million its advisors say need to be recouped by the Enemalta Corporation.
Coupled with that, the government was also said to have presented a substantial renewable energy package that it will unveil in the 3 November budget speech, now just 11 days away.
But with the surcharge capping mechanism applied to the industrial and tourism sectors due to be axed as per the government’s proposals, along with the surcharge itself, the issue remains a major bone of contention around the MCESD table, sources added.
At least two social partners around the MCESD table – the Federation of Industry and the Malta Hotels and Restaurants Association – are actively lobbying for the mechanism’s retention, or for some other compensatory measure, while the Chamber for SMEs (GRTU) has put up stiff opposition to the practice, which it deems discriminatory to other business sectors.
The MCESD reconvenes its two-day meeting this morning with the hope of reaching a concrete breakthrough in negotiations.
Emerging from yesterday morning’s meeting – attended by Finance, Economy and Investment Minister Tonio Fenech, Infrastructure, Transport and Communications Minister Austin Gatt, and Information and Public Dialogue Parliamentary Secretary Chris Said – government officials and representatives of Malta’s constituted bodies divulged absolutely no information and kept the contents of discussions strictly under wraps.
The ministers and parliamentary secretary emerged first from yesterday’s meeting, followed by social partners’ representatives some 20 minutes later – all of whom were uncharacteristically reluctant to comment on the sensitive discussions.
Some social partners, however, cited a good deal of will among all those present to strike a compromise and stressed that, come what may, a solution had to be hammered out.
MCESD chairman Sonny Portelli, meanwhile, cited a mainly “positive” meeting and that discussions were still a “work in progress”. He added there would still be a good deal of ground to cover at this morning’s session, in which participants would be treated to more presentations and figures with the hope of thrashing out a final deal.
At the beginning of the month Mr Portelli had taken a practically unprecedented step in harshly criticising the government, by way of a vehement letter to the prime minister, over the way in which it had presented its proposals to an earlier MCESD meeting as nothing more than a fait accompli without any prior consultation with Malta’s social partners.
Condemnation had been wide, with all social partners – those representing workers and employers alike – slamming the government’s proposals and its complete lack of consultation involved in their formulation.
Following the proposals, the MHRA and FOI both warned thousands of jobs could be slashed as a result of the government’s proposal to remove the surcharge, as well as the capping mechanisms applied to the sectors.
With the new tariffs’ impact on the industrial sector being estimated at anywhere between e1.5 million and e10 million per company per year, the FOI has warned the government’s proposals would not only lead to massive job cuts, but also to enterprises shelving their expansion plans and foreign direct investors pulling out of the country.
The tourism sector is also expected to be hard hit by the tariff revision, and has warned costs for the sector would rise threefold as a result of the government’s proposals. The MHRA has warned a number of hotels would have to close their doors as they would simply no longer be able to operate under the new tariff structure, and that there would also be a “substantial” consequence on many small businesses that depend on the tourism industry.
The GRTU, for one, has applauded the proposed removal of the capping mechanism, and intends ensuring that element of the government’s proposed utility rate shake-up is implemented. The mechanism, the GRTU argued this week, was “discriminatory”. Other sectors of the economy, the GRTU said at a press conference on Tuesday, also used large amounts of electricity but benefitted from no such alleviating measure and that it was simply unfair that what the GRTU estimates to be 10 per cent of consumers’ utility bills go toward subsidising the two sectors.
Government has continuously said the proposals were only proposals, and that nothing had been etched in stone, and yesterday’s e60 million downsizing of the funds to be recuperated by Enemalta every year could serve to soften the blow for households or businesses.
The government also faces potential political fallout from the proposed measures, due to the politically-sensitive nature of utility tariffs, with the opposition Malta Labour Party having declared it was ready to lead the people in protest against the proposed rates if implemented in their original format.
Discussions resume this morning in what is being considered a final bid to strike a balance between keeping the Enemalta Corporation on an even financial keel, and social partners’ concerns over the measures’ impact household and business bottom lines.