The Labour Party has taken exception to an allegation by Infrastructure Minister Austin Gatt that figures the MLP cited in a critical analysis of the energy tariffs were “an invention”.
The government had at first ignored the figures in a statement it issued to counter the analysis, but when the MLP argued that this confirmed its readings, the minister came out to say the figures were an invention.
The MLP is now asking Dr Gatt to publish his calculations showing the Labour Party’s figures were invented. If the minister were to read the analysis, the MLP said, he would see that the figures were gleaned from the government’s presentation to the social partners.
Dr Gatt’s statement had no credibility for at least two reasons, the MLP said. First, in Dr Gatt’s first statement on Monday to rebut the critical analysis, not one single figure in the analysis was contradicted. It was only when the MLP commented on this that the minister said the figures were invented.
Second, the minister’s second statement begged credibility because it gave no indication at all as to how the government had concluded the figures were an invention.
However, in a counter-statement issued yesterday evening, the ministry challenged the Malta Labour Party to reveal who were the consultants who helped the MLP reach its conclusions on the matter.
The ministry said the MLP is quoting anonymous consultants whose conclusions are false and therefore these consultants should be revealed so that they will have to bear their “professional responsibilities”. If not, this secrecy will be considered as proof that the Labour Party invented the numbers it is quoting.
The ministry added that if the MLP wanted to be taken seriously, it should not be afraid of saying who had worked on the reaction which was given by Opposition Leader Joseph Muscat.
This irresponsible behaviour was in stark contrast with the ministry’s attitude, which had been transparent and provided detailed presentations to the social partners and the media as well.
The ministry said the government had not refrained from stating who had worked on the exercise which led to the tariffs which were proposed as a basis for discussion with the MCESD.
Therefore, the ministry insisted that the picture being portrayed by the MLP is completely erroneous, adding that despite all this criticism, Dr Muscat has not yet come forward with any alternative proposals to those being made by the government.