The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Issues In the justice sector

Malta Independent Sunday, 26 October 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Contrary to what many may have thought, this is actually the first time in his political career that Jose Herrera is shadowing the Justice Ministry. Prior to this he was shadow minister for the Financial Services sector. His new remit includes the Law Courts, the tribunals and the Office of the Attorney General. It is interesting to note that the Labour Party has kept the Justice ministry separate from the Home Affairs ministry. This is how they are in many European countries and the reason is simple, once it’s explained: occasionally there could be a conflict of interest. In Malta, previous to this administration, they were always kept apart, except when Guido de Marco was head of both ministries for a short time. Noel Grima interviewed JOSE HERRERA to find out what his thoughts

were on a wide variety of issues

Delays in court

The issue of delays in court has been an ongoing issue for many years and the Opposition is all out for anything that can help speed up proceedings. But it disagrees with the government’s, and specifically with Minister Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici’s declared policy that the way to cut the backlog is to switch cases from the courts to tribunals and authorities.

One such approach is what is being referred to as forced arbitration. This, according to Dr Herrera, is a misnomer, because arbitration by definition is a voluntary way of settling disputes. To succeed, arbitration requires acceptance by both sides.

The present government and its predecessors have given arbitration a wholly new meaning. The Malta Arbitration Centre was set up a few years ago. This was a good move, as the intention then was to promote and facilitate arbitration.

Successive laws however, have dictated those cases which, in a mandatory fashion, have to be referred to arbitration. Dr Herrera said the Opposition is against this on principle. The Malta Arbitration Centre must not usurp the functions of the courts, nor become a parallel court without the safeguards found in the Constitution to protect the judiciary. There are a number of test cases on this issue and their outcome is keenly awaited.

Legal aid

Today the system has been radically changed and especially so in criminal matters.

Before, the Magistrates’ Courts in their criminal jurisdiction prior to these current changes, a magistrate could appoint any lawyer to defend a particular accused. Many times this meant that the lawyer would be chosen by the accused himself. Thus we had a system that in essence guaranteed the accused the lawyer of his choice. This is very much the system used in Italy and the UK.

In Malta, the system has now been changed: instead there is now a list of lawyers chosen by the minister and magistrates have to appoint legal representatives from this list. Many times this means that there is and can be no trust established between the client and the lawyer chosen for him.

Besides, the retainer fee for legal aid is minimal, less than e1500 a year. This makes for rather less motivation on the part of the lawyer.

It was previously intended that this low level of retainership would be compensated by the same lawyers getting curator status, in other words being paid to represent foreign companies in the Maltese courts. But today this type of curatorship is becoming rather rare because since Malta has become a member of the EU, the foreign companies can be notified directly, without the need for them having a curator to take care of their business here.

On the civil front, ideally, people should have the lawyer of their choice too. Furthermore, the ceiling of those entitled to legal aid must be changed. Today, basically only those who are unemployed can get legal aid, but to institute a court case the entry fee is high, too high for people who do not qualify for legal aid. That is why many people who should institute court cases decide not to do so.

Legal experts

Sometime ago it was reported that legal experts are costing the Exchequer around e800,000 over a year. At first glance this may sound like a hefty sum. On the other hand however, if we were to compare this to what the government itself pays for retainerships in its agencies and departments, it is a pittance.

The title legal experts covers all kinds of fields since it is composed of doctors, lawyers, engineers, and many others and there are thousands of ongoing inquires. So the sum paid is not exorbitant at all.

The Opposition however agrees that tariffs have to be further regulated and the job description given to experts more specific to avoid wastage.

Dr Herrera feels the government is subtly planning a radical reform in this area of the administration of justice.

What the government intends to do could prove to be a very dangerous development indeed. It seems that the government means to restrict the discretion of the judiciary and instead of leaving the choice of experts in the hands of the presiding magistrate or judge, the government will impose a list of its own experts.

Magistrates and judges many times have to decide on very hot issues that have political overtures and, since the court experts are not entrenched in their function as the judiciary is, they will be subject to pressure to play up to the government of the day. This would be a serious intromission in the independence of the judiciary.

Judges’ retirement age.

Until 1979 judges got a two-thirds pension when they retired based on their remuneration as judges. After that year, they started receiving the same pension like everybody else.

Judges however have a certain lifestyle and it is quite hard for them to adjust to a very different lifestyle based on today’s pension.

So many are becoming chairmen and so on of government boards and authorities after they retire. This, Dr Herrera feels, intrudes on the independence of the judiciary, as it is quite natural that a judge nearing retirement tries to avoid handing down anti-government sentences in the last two years before retirement so that he then becomes eligible for one of these new postings, which are all at the government’s whim.

He had suggested, in various speeches he made in Parliament, that the retirement age of judges should be pushed up to 70 as it is in many European countries, including the European Court of Justice where it is 75.

Or else the judges’ pensions must be increased to avoid this downward shift in lifestyle.

Administrative Court

Malta badly needs an Administrative Court, he feels. These exist all over Europe except the UK where the ordinary courts have assumed broad jurisdiction over administrative matters.

In Malta, theoretically, we follow UK norms. In practice however, our courts have proved too reluctant in handing down rulings against the State and its agencies over the years. Thus our courts have restricted their jurisdiction in such matters and have practically moved in the opposite direction of those in the UK.

The government has legislated for the creation of a permanent tribunal embracing general jurisdiction on administrative issues. This was hurriedly passed at the end of the last legislature but has not become operational yet.

Dr Herrera however has reservation on the set up of this tribunal. He asks “what is the scope of having a tribunal, which according to law would be presided over by a judge and not go one step further and introduce a proper administrative court as elsewhere?” Administrative cases are perhaps the most politically sensitive and they are best left to the judicial organ of State and not to an ad hoc tribunal.

Past experience with such tribunals, such as the Commission for the Investigation of Injustices and later the tribunal for the investigation of injustices are now time-barred. We have also witnessed the government’s reluctance time and again to implement the recommendations made by these tribunals.

Judicial scrutiny of the government and its agencies

Soon after the Nationalist Party took over the government, a tribunal, “The Commission for the Investigation of Corruption”, was created. Dr Herrera feels that this particular tribunal has given a poor show all along. In fact, in this regard, the Labour Party’s reservations on the set up of this particular Commission have been vindicated. As a matter of fact, over the last 10-12 years hardly a single pronouncement has been issued declaring maladministration or corruption with regard to the government or any of its agencies and this is unbelievable. This has gradually led to the general public losing faith in it and poor patronisation by the public at large. One great fault is that the chairmen of this particular tribunal are appointed by the government and are eligible for reappointment.

Thus Malta definitely does not have a strong enough mechanism that can undertake ex-officio investigations regarding public abuse and corruption. In practice, we have witnessed that to countermand allegations of corruption within a given ministry, the practice is for the Minister himself to appoint an ad hoc board of inquiry from among chosen persons and all is kept in the family. Sure enough it is nearly always the same persons who are appointed. Dr Herrera is four square behind the ongoing suggestion that a system of an inquiring magistrate or a pool of the judiciary to be endowed with special powers to be able to be in a position to investigate allegations of corruption ex officio.

Presidential pardons

So far, Malta has never had a parole system, except for a short time at the beginning of the last century. The problem thus is: how can sentences be reduced?

There is the normal remission of sentence, which is one third of the total prison term imposed. This remission is practically automatic and has no motivation to encourage the prisoner to behave and rehabilitate himself.

On the other hand a person can get a reduction in sentence by making a plea to the President. There have been cases, however, where a presidential pardon has been accorded on very dubious grounds. Sometimes, unbelievably, a pardon was even granted to a co-accused and not to the other co-accused. A presidential pardon cannot be investigated and no reasons are given when a pardon is given.

A parole system would be recommended in the issue of a White Paper shortly. Dr Herrera feels that such a parole system will decrease the executive discretion and allow more transparency in such matters.

Indeed our President should still retain the power to grant pardons but only in extremis, mostly in general and not in particular cases, and there should always be an explanation given as to why a particular pardon was granted or otherwise since undue discretion could surely open the door to abuse and intromission in the judgements of the judiciary.

Assignment of work

More transparency is called for regarding the way that court business is assigned to particular judges and magistrates, Dr Herrera feels.

The system where judges were reassigned duties because of certain rulings they might have given against the government’s interests is now thankfully over. It is also fitting that the assignment of cases should be left in the hands of the Chief Justice, as it is nowadays. Previously, the reshuffling of judicial duties was the prerogative of the Minister of Justice who could and did shift members of the judiciary from one court to another and actually play musical chairs with them if this suited his purposes. Dr Herrera however feels that this system has to be further refined to increase transparency. He holds that the discretion of the Chief Justice to omit certain type of cases from the general jurisdiction of a particular judge could seem to be too intrusive especially in the superior courts. He argues for example against the removal from the competence of certain judges the right to hear and try, for example, Constitutional cases. The matter can be taken further whereby certain judges could be arbitrarily removed from trying certain politically charged sensitive cases and this is incorrect. In this regard Dr Herrera feels that more transparency is needed

Seniority

Seniority, Dr Herrera feels, is being totally ignored.

He is not saying that all promotions should be based on strict seniority, because competence too must be a factor in the decision. The law of seniority however should not be blithely skipped or ignored. It is certainly not in the interest of the independence of the judiciary if one were to appoint the most junior magistrate to a judgeship for no apparent reasons.

Such a system has and still is creating frustrations among the judiciary.

  • don't miss