The Malta Tourism Authority report backing the application for a permit to develop a disco in Mistra was a determining factor in the sitting that granted the permit, said former Development Control Commission members yesterday.
Two former members, Architect Chris Spiteri and Carmel Portelli, in particular singled out the favourable report and MTA’s application for an embellishment project at Mistra to have influenced the vote on 12 November 2007.
The former DCC members took the witness stand yesterday during the compilation of evidence against Philip Azzopardi, 57, and Anthony Mifsud, 59, respectively former chairman and board member of the commission within the Malta Environment and Planning Authority.
Architect Spiteri said he did not vote during the hearing as he left the meeting to buy a birthday present for his father, while Mr Portelli recalled how he voted in favour of the project.
He pointed out that the project was granted the go-ahead subject to the approval of MTA’s application. He told the court, presided over by magistrate Edwina Grima, that he did not see the report prior to the vote and knew only that it was penned by an MTA expert.
Mr Portelli told the court that he voted in favour of the permit and based his opinion on the strong backing MTA showed for the Mistra Project and its pending application to upgrade the site. He also took into consideration that there were commercial buildings in the area; namely a recording studio and a restaurant.
The MTA report, he said, was mentioned very often by the applicant’s architect Paul Camilleri, who made “a lengthy presentation” on the benefits of the project to the DCC. Mr Portelli said Architect Camilleri gave the DCC the impression that MTA’s proposed project envisaged the upgrading of Mistra on a holistic approach. However, upon seeing it for the first time when interrogated by the police some months later, he found “there was nothing special about the application”.
He told the court that he was never pressured into taking decisions by Architect Azzopardi, adding that he was in the habit of keeping a free discussion without influencing decisions.
Former members Charles Calleja and Mark Azzopardi told the court why they opposed the Mistra project and voted against it.
Mr Calleja said he was told that the disco would attract “coachfuls of young people” to the Mistra disco.
“The road leading down to the site is big enough for a coach to go down, but not big enough for a coach to manoeuvre and drive back without upsetting the traffic flow,” he said. Mr Calleja also took into consideration that the development would create a lot of noises in an otherwise tranquil and serene bay.
Architect Azzopardi said he voted against the project as he felt that it was not fit for the site.
Police Inspector Ian Abdilla prosecuted while lawyers Joseph Giglio, Stephen Tonna Lowell and Peter Fenech represented the accused.