Especially at Budget time, the media are packed with interviews with Professor Edward Scicluna and his comments.
Taking a look at some of his prognostications made over the years could prove instructive.
Interview with Business Today 15 March 2006
The GDP figures for 2005 published by the National Office of Statistics are “challenging if not defying the universal laws of macro-economics... One cannot have the combined major sectors of a small open economy, manufacturing and tourism, falling by three and a half per cent in real terms in any one year and the economy growing by two and a half per cent during the same period”.
The Malta Independent 19 August 2006
“Professor Edward Scicluna said that since the test for the adoption of the euro will not take place now, there is still time to adjust. However, he admitted that the current inflation levels are rather worrying.”
Editorial – MaltaToday 22 October 2006
The question facing the country now is simply will we qualify to join (the euro)? The interview published in this Sunday’s edition with Professor Edward Scicluna highlights the magnitude of the task. He adds that the budget aims at soothing the electoral core rather than addressing the criteria for adopting the euro.”
Interview
MaltaToday: So it seems you are not entirely sure of Malta’s chances of joining the euro in 2008?
Scicluna: I’m afraid so... it looks more like one who is trying one’s luck at passing an exam... I’d say Malta is pushing its luck. My cold-blooded assessment would be that the examiner would say that overall there are too many risks and uncertainties suggesting to us to give it another year.
MaltaToday: What would the implications of postponing be?
Scicluna: Well, it depends on how we take it. It’s like failing an exam for just a couple of marks. Psychologically, some students respond by sending education to hell and go out and get drunk, or else they eat humble pie, try harder and pass the exam the next time round. There could of course be some slackening in the process of trying harder, but that’s a political scenario now depending on whether there’s an election now or not. As for the effect on the outside world I would say that for most observers, including the IMF and the rating agencies the result won’t be a surprise, they have already factored it in and the event won’t be seen as a disaster for Malta if it is seen to remain on the track.
MaltaToday: So has Malta been too ambitious on its target for the euro after all?
Scicluna: With hindsight, for the population at large the answer is yes. For the experts, including the EU and IMF themselves, the programme was already termed ‘very ambitious’.
Comment: Only a few months later, the European Commission not only accepted Malta’s bid to enter the euro zone but also defined our finances as “credible and sustainable”.
MaltaToday 17 October 2007
Saviour Balzan: Some economists, and one of them is Edward Scicluna, state that the government is far too optimistic about its economic growth expectations. He says that to generate the money to compensate for the reduced changes in tax bands, the government is expecting an economic growth rate that is far, far higher than expected. Higher even that the rate stipulated by international agencies and organizations, which is 2.8 per cent.
Comment: Malta’s growth rates last year were higher – 3%.
MaltaToday 21 May 2008
Leader
Last October Professor Edward Scicluna warned that Budget 2008 was based on an unrealistic projection that the economic growth would continue at the same rate as the previous year, despite numerous indications to the contrary.
The Times 31 August 2008
Mark Micallef
The government could end with a shortfall of up to €185 million – some €117 million off projections, according to economist Edward Scicluna.
Figures released by the National Office of Statistics last Friday show that the structural deficit is again ballooning. Statistics for the first seven months of the year indicate a 36 per cent jump on the figures registered in the same period last year.
The gap grew from €209 million between January and July in 2007 to around €283 million during the same period this year.
When contacted yesterday, Prof. Scicluna said the “outcome is not surprising” but rather predictable, and the root cause could be found in the expenditure programme set in the last Budget.
Comment: According to the Budget Speech, the shortfall this year will amount to €200 million, but €56 million was the cost of the early retirement scheme at the dockyard and a further €55 million were spent to sustain the low electricity prices charged due to the spike in oil prices.