The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Interview: Cautiously Optimistic about the future

Malta Independent Monday, 10 November 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi is optimistic for the country’s future, but says we have to be extremely careful. Whatever the country earns from people’s taxes will be invested productively in the country’s best interest, he said. On the new energy tariff system, the prime minister said all the social partners agreed that subsidies to Enemalta had to stop and that everyone should pay for what they consume. Francesca Vella spoke to Dr Gonzi in his office at Auberge de Castille after the presentation of the budget speech last week.

People have been wondering where the prime minister has been over these past three months or so, particularly with regard to the privatisation of Malta Shipyards and the new energy tariff system. And Opposition Leader Joseph Muscat has said it seems like Malta currently has two prime ministers, yourself and Austin Gatt. What is your reaction to this?

Politics is about taking the right decisions at the right time, in a responsible manner. Malta continues to be strong, but there are troubling waters surrounding us.

I do not give any importance to the type of criticism that gets us nowhere. The reality is that this is one government with a clear political agenda, with specific targets that had been specified just after the PN won the 8 March general election. I was certainly there over these past three months, this is a Cabinet of ministers and we share responsibility for every decision taken.

We have addressed major reforms, from the rent reform, to the reform of the Malta Environment and Planning Authority (Mepa), the local council reform, the privatisation of Malta Shipyards, and the reform of the transport authority.

Over these eight months we also had to respond to the world crisis, starting in July with the price of oil reaching an all-time peak and then the financial crisis.

So we are hard at work, all of us, every single minister, focusing on what needs to be done in the best interest of the country.

I would love to have the Opposition cooperate, but I believe they have decided to continue using theatrics as their means of contributing towards the country’s good. I will leave it up to the people to decide on which is the best way forward for this country.

You recently made public the government’s decision to develop an offshore, shallow-water wind farm at a site off Rdum tal-Madonna in Mellieha – Sikka l-Bajda. Which other sites were taken into consideration? How confident are you that the project will happen, considering that the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) has not yet been carried out yet?

I think this issue needs to be guided by the advice given by experts. The issue of wind farms has been on our agenda for a number of years now, but we had to make a choice. We could either have gone for a deep-water offshore wind farm, an onshore wind farm, or a wind farm in shallow water.

Having a full blown onshore wind farm is difficult considering limited land space. We will experiment with pilot projects, but they will not make the big difference that we require. So the most feasible option that emerged from experts’ studies, including studies by German experts commissioned for this purpose, is to go for an offshore wind farm in shallow water.

There are only two sites that seem to be potentially interesting to be able to do this, at least this is what the experts are saying, and these are Sikka l-Bajda and possibly Hurds Bank, off the north-eastern coast, but that is too far out, so there is a challenge there that still needs to be addressed. So right now, Sikka l-Bajda seems to be the best solution. Two very important studies still need to be finalised. I will wait for the EIA before taking a final decision, but the second study will identify the wind speeds and wind in the project.

So let’s wait and see. The political decision has been taken, but it is subject to these studies, which will guide us on the best way forward. Malta cannot continue to depend exclusively on fossil fuels; we need to go down the route of alternative energy.

The government’s focus on investment in the country’s economy in Budget 2009 seems to have put the interests of the lower and middle class groups aside. And yet you refer to the solidarity aspect of the budget. The same goes for the new energy tariffs. Can you explain this?

First of all, I have to remind everybody that even in the energy issue, the solidarity aspect is extremely important. There are 30,000 families gaining from the energy benefit scheme. These are specific groups among the weakest people in our society, and this is what solidarity is all about.

One out of every six families will benefit from this scheme. Most of these people are elderly, receiving the minimum pension, while others face enormous difficulties due to unemployment and sickness, for example. So the solidarity aspect in energy package is very pronounced.

In addition to that, this year’s budget dedicates close to e12 million towards income tax cuts. Add that to income tax reductions last year and the year before, the tax burden has been reduced extensively.

Of course there’s more to be done, but everything depends on whether we’ll be able to have a strong economic performance. There are forecasts of economic downturn across Europe for next year. Malta will continue to grow, but growth is forecasted to be much slower.

We’ll remain optimistic for the future, but we have to be extremely careful. Whatever the government earns from people’s taxes will be invested productively.

What about the electoral commitments, particularly those regarding income tax reductions?

About 26 out of 355 electoral commitments have been implemented in this Budget alone. That’s quite good, considering the electoral manifesto lasts five years. I have no intention of holding an early election, so I have all the time in the world to introduce the changes as and when it is in the best interest of the country.

At the end of the day, we need to take the right decisions to be able to stimulate the economy in a proper manner. We need to do this very, very carefully.

At this stage, experts indicated that we could take this step as regards income tax cuts. And it is not marginal at all. e12 million is a substantial amount of money and this is going to remain in people’s pockets and generate more activity in the economy. I am optimistic that if the country continues to remain successful, even in the face of severe competition, then I’m sure that we’ll be strong enough to implement the second phase of the income tax proposals as indicated in our electoral manifesto.

Why were the new energy tariffs implemented now, rather than staggered over the past two years or so?

There was a time when we believed we could cope with the impact of energy, because the price of oil was in the region of between $70 and $90 a barrel. The surcharge was a temporary measure and I had long been saying that we hoped to reach a stage where the surcharge would be removed.

When everyone realised that the price of oil was never going to go down to the $30 to $40 a barrel and would remain in the region of $100, we started studying the system, seeing if we could remove the surcharge and integrate it into a tariff based system that would be flexible.

This is different to what the Labour government wanted to introduce some 10 to 11 years ago; they wanted to introduce a fixed system. The system we have introduced will adapt itself to the international price of oil and will be revised every so many months.

We were coping with the situation, so we could take our time and in the meantime we cushioned industry with the capping system, but suddenly there was the drastic increase in the price of oil, and this happened only last July.

Everybody seems to forget that between April and July the price of oil sky-rocketed. Suddenly, out of budget, we had to fork out e55 million to finance Enemalta. We were spending e7 million a month, out of budget. This was simply unsustainable.

So we have been moving in the direction of changing the system into a tariff based system for a number of years now, but the suddenly it became urgent, particularly in the middle of this year when the price of oil hit unimaginable levels.

Perhaps there were two principles everybody agreed to in the Malta Council for Economic and Social Development (MCESD). The first is that subsidies to Enemalta have to stop, and the second is that everyone has to pay for what they consume.

The final decision was based on these two principles. Of course, the debate was on the process of implementation, but with the outlook for 2009 being what it is, it would have been irresponsible for us to postpone the decision till March. So the solution was for us to take the decision and phase-in the new tariffs in a manner that everybody would be able to absorb as time goes by. Let’s hope the price of oil will remain as low as possible in the meantime.

Was there a reason why Enemalta feed-in tariffs were not increased as an incentive for people to invest in alternative energy systems and sell the excess electricity generated to the national grid?

There’s a reason for that. We’re not quite sure yet how to control the danger of abuse of the system. In other words we need to have an upgraded metering system to be able to go down that route. We currently have a net compensation system. Some countries have very good feed-in tariffs. We need to have a system that is not abused of.

What about the rebate on solar water heaters and photovoltaic (PV) cells. Will the government be ready to extend the rebate scheme?

I suspect there will be many families who will apply for the rebate on solar water heaters. PV cells are still an expensive proposition for many families. I have no difficulty in reviewing the situation, even half way through the year, to see whether funds can be found to extend the scheme.

In this sense, the revised tariffs make a lot of sense. The subsidies to Enemalta created a lopsided situation as there was no incentive to invest in PV cells and solar water heaters.

The reality is sometimes harsh and not popular, but we have to go down that route. Anyone who wants to push perceptions, rather than reality, is doing a disservice to the country. I believe in reality and I believe it should be addressed head-on.

What are your predictions for the elections of the European Parliament (EP), particularly considering the disappointment for the PN four years ago?

Every election is a story of its own. We will work hard to persuade the people to make the right choice. I have always had full faith in whatever decision the electorate takes and when we had the first round of EP elections five years ago, I respected the electorate’s decision.

It was, of course, a disappointment, considering we worked so hard for the country to join the EU and after five years time has proven us right again. Thank goodness, Malta is now an EU member and thank goodness the electorate chose the direction that my party was proposing.

We were proved right, the other party was proved wrong.

Let’s all learn from our mistakes. I hope next time round we’ll be able to persuade the Maltese electorate that we genuinely want the best for this country, we genuinely believe in the potential of this country, we genuinely believe that we have the potential to grow even more and we speak with a track record that proves that we believe in what we say and we say what we believe in. I will not comment on what the other party does. The difference between substance and superficiality is coming out every single day.

  • don't miss