Anthony Mifsud, the former prison guard whose torture was vindicated in a landmark judgment delivered on 30 October, claimed he would have earned more than the compensation he was awarded had he worked for 25 years in return for minimum wage.
In an application filed before the Constitutional Court, Mr Mifsud said the e186,349.87 was less than the e211,972 he would have earned throughout a 25-year working life at minimum wage.
This means, said Mr Mifsud, that he did not receive compensation for the illegal arrest and detention torture he was subjected to. He enquired how he will be compensated for the beatings he received and the chronic mental trauma he suffers from, as certified by psychiatrists.
The compensation, said Mr Mifsud, was not only inadequate and fitting, but plainly insignificant given that he waited for a quarter of a century for a judgement.
He added that the courts were obliged to show their repugnance to torture and any compensation awarded to victims of torture should reflect the mistreatment they received. This would also show that torturers must pay a dear price for the pain they inflict.
Originally Mr Mifsud had asked for e349,406, however, psychiatric investigation showed his mental health to be in a much worse state than thought of before. Thus, he had demanded e1.16million, the amount which Mr Mifsud asked the Constitutional Court to liquidate.
The application, signed by Dr Tonio Azzopardi, was filed against former Police Superintendents Carmelo Bonello and Joseph Psaila, the Police Commissioner and then-Commissioner Lawrence Pullicino.