It’s not always satisfying when the heavy-hitters come out with reams of facts that back you up in what you’ve been writing about for years. Sometimes, it’s demoralising. For 18 years I’ve been writing about how really, truly backward Maltese society is in the way it regards women. Even women sell themselves short, afraid to be seen or heard except as flashy singers in awful frocks or as hosts on cheap talk-shows on television – roles, in other words, which are perceived to be non-threatening to men or other women.
I’m aware of just how abnormal the situation in Malta is because I move around a bit in my line of work and one of the first things that struck me is that I have to leave the country to be treated normally, with no wise-cracks, suspicious looks, bristling, hostility or, worst and most unpleasant of all, sleazy remarks. Women and young gay men are routinely propositioned by straight men in Malta in a business context. It is beyond ghastly. To get along unscathed, women must wear invisible armour that gives off the vibes of an electric fence, and practise a basilisk stare. The downside is that the men then go off and run you down as a friza and a kiesha but it’s a whole lot better than giving them ideas.
When I leave the country and visit companies elsewhere in Europe, it strikes me immediately that many of the people in senior positions are women, that men don’t talk down to women, that women don’t flirt with men but are straightforward and businesslike, and best of all, men don’t talk over women and interrupt them, and women talk about things other than children. It feels like liberation. In the same way that when I was a child in the 1970s going to Italy felt like a whole new world of colour compared to the black, white and grey of Malta, leaving Malta now is a revelation of another kind – a social revelation. People have manners. Women are human beings.
I can talk about current affairs and social issues without having someone tell me – not as a compliment – that I am like a man, or hearing some blast from my teenage past say in the background, by way of excusing my unnatural behaviour, as though I were wearing a parrot in my hair and a feathered tail, “Daphne always had something to say for herself, even when we were kids” or, heard only last month, “She was always an individual,” (because you know, that’s a failing), or even worse, “How do you know about these things?” (because women don’t, apparently). Sometimes, I just give up and join the conversations about children, which have now become the conversations about university examinations and which university in which British city is best. I go back home and take two Syndol.
I have no doubt that much of the resentment directed towards me by those who support the Labour Party and would wish to mow me down is not primarily because of my views, but because those views are expressed in a rational manner by a woman. You can see it in their reactions. They don’t just want me silenced. That is not enough. They want me punished. It is two steps up from the primitive sentiment that had women burnt at the stake for witchcraft and still has women stoned and lashed in the public square for perceived misbehaviour.
A woman who doesn’t mince words in public is only acceptable if her views are chaotically expressed – as they are by so many women writing in the newspapers – or her arguments childish. That’s not threatening. That’s an example of how women should stick to the kitchen sink because they can’t think. Seeing that kind of writing doesn’t threaten men; it reassures them in their belief that women are inferior. But a woman who thinks, reasons and speaks in the public arena in a way deemed to be the cultural preserve of men? That’s an inversion of the natural order of things, and the woman who does it provokes outrage and immense irritation, especially in those men who are the targets of her criticism. Women get angry too, feeling threatened in a very different kind of way, or perhaps I should say challenged. To the typical Maltese boor, to be mocked in public is one thing. To be mocked in public by a woman is intolerable and the woman must be whipped. A whole parade of clowns has taken me to court not for lies or incorrect facts that I have written about them, but for having “exposed them to public ridicule” – yes, my dears, that’s our primitive law for you – and they feel their masculinity, honour and dignity to have been impugned.
Look about you next time you go out, and be observant. What do you see? Women in gaggles together, talking about children and make-up, and men in other gaggles, talking about work, sport and making disparaging jokes about women. Sharpen your eyes and you’ll see something I noticed a long time ago: that Maltese men have one way of speaking to other men and a completely different way of speaking to women. Watch a group of men having a conversation and talking about “important things”. They’re wearing serious expressions and their conversation is deep. Watch the same men in conversation with women. They adopt the body language and facial expression of somebody talking to a child. Their conversation flitters along the surface, reduced to rubbish chit-chat. If they think the woman is mildly attractive, their eyes no longer glaze over but their body signals become uncomfortably obvious (even if they themselves are impervious) and the woman ends up feeling like she’s back at a sixth-form disco, having the moves made on her by Tony from Applied Maths.
So all right, you can blame the women. Lots of Maltese women have no conversation at all, the result of never reading anything, not knowing what’s going on outside their hamster’s cage, and having been trained from toddlerhood not to seem “clever” lest a prospective mate be frightened off. Maltese women don’t talk to men. They flirt. The affliction is so widespread that when a Maltese man comes across a woman who talks about something that isn’t just gas – she’s usually foreign, but of course, not a good-time girl from an impoverished country looking for a meal ticket – he doesn’t know how to handle it. You can see the cultural confusion thundering through his subconscious: the person in front of him is a woman, but he is expected to retrench and talk to her as though she is a man.
The ideal model of Maltese womanhood is somebody very short (not threatening, because the average height of Maltese men is 5’3”), obsessed with her appearance to a distressing degree (evidence of frivolity and so indicative of inferiority to men’s non-frivolous superiority), hides her light under a bushel and plays at being humble, dresses in an extremely conservative way when in a relationship and like a Broadway tart when not, and never, ever talks about her work. Even though she might have a high-flying career, she pretends she doesn’t. Just like those housewives of the 1950s who whipped away all the buckets and brooms before their husband came home, so that he wouldn’t see evidence of housework, so today’s women – the very, very few who have good jobs – make like they don’t.
When I pop down to supermarket, I can’t help noticing that most of the men touring the aisles are foreign, and that almost all the Maltese customers are women. If you see a Maltese man, then he is inevitably “helping” his wife, presumably because he is unable to do the shopping on his own, even though he is the one with the car and the wallet, as is generally the case in these situations. Shopping is a woman’s job, but then I wonder – have women appropriated it for themselves, to have power and control over this one area and something to complain about (my god, the shopping...)? Men are natural product-aholics, and even if they are stingy in every other area of life, give them a shopping-trolley and aisle upon aisle of food products that are the equivalent of gadgets and they’re in heaven. Then they go home with a dozen gimmicky things they’ve seen advertised on TV and the wife hits the roof because they’ve blown the budget and are not allowed to go shopping again.
It’s interesting though – my husband is forever being accosted at the supermarket check-out by vague acquaintances who make a point of telling him how lucky I am because I have a husband who goes to the supermarket on Saturday while I am working. Of course, most of them are just mischief-makers, but some of them must actually believe it. Funnily enough, the men who tell him how lucky I am because he shops don’t see how lucky he is because, unlike them, he doesn’t have a financially dependent wife wrapped like an albatross round his neck and he doesn’t have to pay all the bills himself.
This attitude speaks volumes about how we see things: a lucky spouse in Malta is a woman whose husband goes to the supermarket, and not a man whose wife works and shares the financial burden. But that might be because of another cultural problem which is far more widespread than we think, and largely invisible because people have pride and are determined to keep up appearances: the wife who is treated like a child in her own home, given a few euros of pocket money and no pocket money at all if she is naughty. To many Maltese men, a wife who doesn’t earn money is not a financial liability but an asset. She costs him nothing except the food she eats because he doesn’t give her money for anything else, and in return he gets free housework and childcare. So many women live in these appalling conditions, begging for everything from the only earner in the house, only to have him get a kick out of refusing, that I am beginning to think it is an unspoken national disease.
So what are the figures that prove my worst suspicions to be true? The World Economic Forum has just released an update of its gender-gap ranking of 130 countries, and Malta ranks 83rd. That’s right, 83rd. Norway is at the top, and Nordic countries generally head the rankings. Not only have we made a dire showing, but we have actually slipped seven places, down from 76th the last time the World Economic Forum released its list.
We are further behind Greece, Cyprus, Armenia, Suriname, Bolivia and even Malawi. Some of you may find yourselves provoked to disbelief, but think clearly: beneath the mask of affluence, of cars, houses, boats, jewellery, clothes and all the trappings of a sophisticated lifestyle, our culture is misogynistic to the point of violence. Indeed, that misogyny frequently does manifest itself in violence and hatred towards women, either individual women or women in general. Often, when I overhear conversations between men, I am appalled at the tone of contempt they reserve for discussing their wives, girlfriends and women colleagues. It’s disgraceful.
The World Economic Forum index assessed inequalities between men and women in four areas: economics (relative salaries, labour force participation rates, access to high-skilled and senior employment), education (relative literacy rates, enrollment in primary, secondary and tertiary schools), politics (relative female representation in parliament, in ministerial posts, as heads of state), and health (relative life expectancies, sex ratios at birth). Malta performed best in the areas of educational attainment and health and worst in political empowerment, although men also fared better than women in the area of economic participation and opportunity.
The abysmal attitude of Maltese men towards women is summed up in one comment posted beneath the news report on the World Economic Forum figures, on an on-line newspaper. I’m quoting it verbatim: “We dont care what Norway tops up. We only know the high amount of suicides that exist in Norway and other nordic countries. It’s better for Malta to be as last as possible in this matter. We can teach them something which they cant.” In other words, if women stay home, don’t get above their station, do their duty in the kitchen and bedroom and don’t start getting ideas about careers and public life, their sons and husbands won’t top themselves.
www.daphnecaruanagalizia.com