The debate on the Social Policy Ministry financial estimates was dominated by the issue of sustainability through planning, cost control and the maximisation of resources and characterised by consensus over a good number of issues.
The spirit of goodwill was ever present as members of both sides of the House gave their condolences to Health Parliamentary Secretary Joe Cassar for the recent demise of his father-in-law. Furthermore, MPs fondly reminded themselves that an untimely death kept late Karl Chircop away from taking part in yesterday’s debate.
Social Policy Minister John Dalli blamed the slow intake of needed professionals in the health sector on the government’s “exaggerated bureaucratic machinery”. He criticised the Malta Union of Midwives and Nurses (MUMN) for ordering industrial action due to low intake of nurses.
Mr Dalli also criticised the fact that nurses are only promoted by leaving their nursing duties. He said he agreed with MUMN in criticising the nursing course at university which takes four years locally while the same at the UK takes three years.
He said there was a marked difference between the competencies of nurses at St Vincent de Paul Residence and Mater Dei, as nurses working at the home for the elderly went through a specialised course while those working at Mater Dei did not. The result is evident when comparing the number of patients with bedsores in the two institutions.
The minister admitted his ignorance in matters medical, but knew a thing or two about management. He told the House he employed an accountant to establish how much each patient cost the state and explained that new and costlier medicine was commercialised, which should be available for Maltese patients. In this context, he questioned whether cheap medicine such as paracetamol should be still provided for free given that a list of expensive medicines such as Herceptin should make it in the national inventory.
Mr Dalli also spoke about cost controllers which he will be introducing. He assured the opposition that such controllers will not be policing around the hospital. The minister was of the opinion of letting consultants spend their budget as they pleased, thus effectively eliminating bureaucratic procedures.
He also illustrated the benefits of prevention in both a budgetary and an emotional sense. Prevention spares patients and their families anguish, while the government is spared the cost of buying expensive medicines. Mr Dalli was pleased with the consensus on the importance of primary health care.
The minister also spoke about the Employment and Training Corporation and the curbing of abuse. To this end, he said, the invalidity pension system was amended, yet further changes were needed.
He said flexibility was the reason why more people depended on part-time employment as their primary employment.
He also said that the worst part of his job is to sign stacks of care orders for children.
Dr Cassar thanked all MPs for their support. It was no coincidence, he said, that Malta was the country with second highest healthy life expectancy. Figures showed that Maltese are expected to live healthily for 70 years, while the EU average stood at 65 years. This, he said, was achieved by the high quality health care given in Malta. Dr Cassar reminded the house that since Mater Dei Hospital started operating it speeded up operations and cut waiting lists, thanks also to agreements which saw clinics open also in the afternoon. The long waiting lists for ophthalmic and orthopedic departments will be addressed through plans to open three new operating theatres.
The decrease of 2,400 emergency cases, he said, was took place thanks to an education campaign. He also condemned sections of the media which alarmed alarm people against doctors and nurses in the emergency department.
In reference to the new oncology centre which will be built at Mater Dei, Dr Cassar said hospitals abroad functioned normally even during construction within its precincts. He said it made a lot of sense to build the centre near the general hospital.
Elderly Care Parliamentary Secretary Mario Galea was happy with the consensus over night shelters for the elderly. He also assured the opposition that spot checks were carried out whenever his office received complaints on food served in homes for the elderly.
Mr Galea announced that his office was exploring the possibility of having laundry at SVPR done by the Mt Carmel Laundry Cooperative. He highlighted community mental health as a top priority for the government.
Nationalist MPs Stephen Spiteri, Jean Pierre Farrugia and Frans Agius spoke about Housing Authority schemes, ETC schemes, health tourism, forms of cancer which should arise concern and the Occupational Health and Safety Organisation.
Opposition Employment Spokesman Anglu Farrugia quoted a report by the Auditor General which accused the ETC of mismanagement.
He attacked a number of employment indicators and questioned their accuracy, especially given that the government employed a considerable amount of people in the run up to the general election, that indicators did not exclude seasonal employment during summer and did not state how many foreigners were included in the figures for gainfully occupied.
The Malta Labour Party Deputy Leader said the government should have stated that the rise in employment was due to the rise in part-time jobs as primary employment. he said the budget did not really address economic and employment problems, and gave the impression that the government’s funds have dried up after the electoral campaign, without it realising the negative effects this fact had on the economy.
Dr Farrugia criticised Finance Minister Tonio Fenech for removing BOV’s worker-director and accused the government of using the Malta Council for Economic and Social Development as a teashop “in the most of despotic ways”.
Opposition Family and Equality spokeswoman Justyne Caruana said the government undermined families due to the decrease in disposable income. She accused it of applying bad practices in managing human resources and praised the tax exemption on women returning to world of employment, however, she said most women would fall in low income groups, thus being tax exempt by default.
She called on the government to encourage more teleworking, invest in the children’s commission, called for more children’s advocates and more children-friendly courts
Social Policy Shadow Minister Michael Farrugia said pointed out at the injustices suffered by people stricken off from the ETC registry without having the right to appeal its decision.
He called for more coordination between State, Church and NGOs so as to duplicate efforts to fight problems such as drug and alcohol abuse, usury and gambling.
Dr Farrugia pointed out at the pressure Mater Dei Hospital staff was exposed to, problems in recruitment, limitations on taking leave, while security guards flourished. He said physiotherapists, speech therapists and podologists were stretched, while the X-ray department at SVPR gave services to illegal immigrants while residents had to have their X-rays taken at Mater Dei. While acknowledging the importance of concentrating efforts onto fighting breast cancer, he advised the government to concentrate its efforts on Alzheimer’s Disease, Osteoporosis and Prostate inflammation.
Surgeon Anthony Zammit gave an impassioned speech about the difficulties faced by himself and Mater Dei staff due to staff and bed shortage; after “the government built a magnificent cathedral without buying seats and investing in priests.” He called for more operations to be carried out in Gozo in order to stimulate the island’s economy and dreamt of the day the health budget be made by both sides of the House.
Adrian Vassallo called for a declaration of patients’ rights while Anthony Agius Decelis decried the global phenomenon of discrimination against the elderly.