After pronouncing judgement on a libel case instituted by former Malta Drydocks chairman John Cassar White and CEO Chris Bell against absent US entrepreneur Joseph Cala, Magistrate Silvio Meli had some sharp words to say on a recent decision that assigned all libel cases to just one magistrate, excluding other magistrates who used to do this work as well.
This decision, Dr Meli said, does not militate in favour of a better administration of justice. Even if legitimate, this decision is not a just one, he added, for if uniformity of decisions is required, this should be the work of a Court of Appeal, and not attained through the delegitimisation of all Magistrates’ Courts.