From Mr M. Grima
I refer to the news article “Pro-life seminar for teachers: Telling young people the whole truth about sexuality” (TMIS, 9 November). Bearing in mind the title of the article, I was astonished to read that Dr Anna Vella raised doubts about the effectiveness of condoms against STIs, and even in preventing pregnancy. Her remarkable claim that condoms offer zero effectiveness against the human papillomavirus is completely contradicted by the evidence (reference: New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 354, p 2645). Is this the same Dr Anna Vella who is president of the Cana Movement?
Upon further research, I discover that the guest speaker, Danielle Lussier is part of a religiously inspired movement that wants to promote abstinence education in American schools. We should all be in favour of the principle of abstinence education of course, but not from a platform that also spreads anti-contraception propaganda.
The reality is that abstinence education has been shown to be ineffective in preventing unwanted teenage pregnancies and the spread of STIs when compared to a thorough A to Z education on contraception. Anybody with a basic grasp of biology understands that abstinence education fails because human beings are a species of African ape, genetically hard-wired to copulate as frequently as possible. Happily, federal support for abstinence-only education under George W. Bush’s leadership is likely to lose out to more effective methods under the new American administration. Further good news can be expected in fields such as federal funding for embryonic stem cell research when Barack Obama is finally installed in the Oval Office.
From the photo accompanying the article, one can see, seated in the front row, Paul Vincenti of the Gift of Life Foundation, whose abhorrence of secularism and liberalism is well known. Next to him is our Prime Minister, and former head of Catholic Action, Dr Lawrence Gonzi.
Everyone is of course entitled to believe whatever they want about life and the universe, but I can’t help noticing the extreme contradiction in the whole purpose of this seminar. Surely we should be promoting proven, effective methods to achieve our goals of preventing unwanted pregnancies and the spread of STIs?
Instead, we seem to want to forge ahead with methods that have a track record of failure while sending out confusing messages about contraception. I get the impression that the education of young people in this crucial area is taking second place to satisfy our superstitions.
Mark Grima
ST JULIAN’S