The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

The Battle Of the Leaks

Malta Independent Thursday, 20 November 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 19 years ago

“That was as nothing compared to a couple of general elections

back, when my husband the early bird went off to vote and get on

with his errands, while I took the view that the polling-station

wasn’t going to run away, so I could stick to my Saturday routine

and go after dark. One of the Nosy Nancies called at lunchtime:

“Your husband has voted and you haven’t. Why not?”

First we had Alfred Sant rising like a phoenix to pounce on the naughty government because he thought somebody was prying into his emails (they weren’t). Then it turned out that the government is investigating a couple of people who are employed with the state’s IT agency and who appear to have been trying to obtain information through the IT system by illicit means. These people are being processed, so to speak. But what strikes me as odd is the way the Labour Party, busy berating the government for its assumed security shortcomings, hasn’t bothered to ask the question – why?

One assumes that it is lack of common sense, as with so many other difficulties that have beset the Opposition over the last several decades. But when the former and present leaders of the Labour Party suggest that the government is using illicit means to pry into, say, Alfred Sant’s emails, they are missing the point that the government, should it wish to do something so dastardly, illegal and invasive, does not need to hack into its own system or use amateurish spying devices because, to put it bluntly, it runs the show. So – ding, dong – anyone trying to obtain personal information about politicians through the government’s IT system must have an agenda of a different nature. One assumes that it is not Alfred Sant’s emails they want to look at, but those of a politician in government. When all is revealed, if it ever is, I rather suspect that the people doing the hacking and prying will be voting Labour in the next election. That’s an assumption, but it’s a fairly safe one.

Now we have Joseph Muscat playing the Victorian maiden who has just seen some 19th-century porn and has to be revived with smelling-salts. This is because the green (as in new, not ahdar) secretary-general of the Nationalist Party foolishly failed to keep to the time-honoured advice of never putting down in writing anything you don’t want others to read. If that held when writing meant pen and paper which could be put in a drawer and locked, then it is far more important with emails that are not secure and which can be forwarded repeatedly or sent to the wrong person when a similar name comes up automatically in Outlook. That’s what happened to Paul Borg Olivier. It’s also what happened to one of the elves in Sant’s grotto, who were mass mailing the correspondence columns of the newspapers with “I am Nationalist but will be voting Labour” letters in the run-up to the general election. One of them sent a private email to the wrong person, and the private email ended up in this newspaper editor’s in-box. And that’s how we found out that the elves whose existence we suspected really did exist, and that the letters they were writing were fake and generated in the grotto.

So, to get back to the secretary-general of the Nationalist Party: what worries me is not that he asked for the contact details of unhappy people who are turning against the government because of some real or perceived problem. That’s customer relationship management. Private companies do it (or should); state-owned monopolies should do it but rarely bother, and the political parties who do it win elections, while those who don’t stay in opposition and grouch. Alfred Sant did it in 1996, meeting all the grumblers one by one and promising them the earth. The difference is that he couldn’t deliver and he didn’t really care. All he wanted was to get into government.

Yes, there are privacy issues which bother me, but privacy issues of this nature have bothered me for a long time. I can’t stand the way the political parties know whether you’ve voted or not on polling day, for example, and spend the entire day hassling you if you decide to avoid the queues and go at night.

Every general election I get a phone call, even last time, when I gave the poor woman at the other end of the line a telling-off. What did she imagine, for heaven’s sake? That I wasn’t going to vote? That I was going to vote for Harry Vassallo or Alfred Sant? It’s not like the whole country didn’t know what my views were. Half the country was reading my blog that day. It got 120,000 hits despite a denial of service attack. “I know,” she said. “I feel so silly. But you’re on my list and I have to cross you off.”

That was as nothing compared to a couple of general elections back, when my husband the early bird went off to vote and get on with his errands, while I took the view that the polling-station wasn’t going to run away, so I could stick to my Saturday routine and go after dark. One of the Nosy Nancies called at lunchtime: “Your husband has voted and you haven’t. Why not?” You should have seen me bounce off the walls. I received a letter of apology from the Nationalist Party’s then secretary-general, but it was the underlying principle that upset me so much and not the fact that they had called me. I am just as upset that others are called and hassled in the same way, made to feel that they are being spied upon and that their privacy is being invaded by crass persons who make assumptions about their voting preferences.

So no, the really worrying thing about Paul Borg Olivier is not that he has carried on in the grand tradition of trying to keep people happy by sorting out their problems even if it means invading their privacy. And that’s what it’s all about, rather than a case of “give me their names so that I can exact revenge”, which is how some fools are trying to depict it. The worrying thing is that he is so cavalier with emails and with putting things down in writing without considering whether they might cause embarrassment if they fall into the wrong hands. That’s not a clever thing to do at all, and the secretary-general of a political party, as amply proved by Jason Micallef, must be very, very clever indeed.

The cleverest non-elected politician in this country famously never puts down anything in writing at all, except the barest and most obvious facts. Others need not go to that extreme, but it is basic good sense when you are secretary-general of a political party to think, before you write something and press the send button, what it will seem like if read by somebody other than the intended recipient. Most of us have made one or several embarrassing mistakes of this nature, but when you are one of a political party’s main men, things take on a different slant.

That doesn’t mean to say that Joseph Muscat isn’t over-egging the drama by striking horrified poses and describing Paul Borg Olivier’s stupid mistake as “scandalous and shameful”. I can think of several things that are scandalous and shameful, and none of them have anything to do with Borg Olivier, who is basically a decent man from a good family. For example, scandalous and shameful would be an apt description of an Opposition Leader who claims that his fictitious foreign policy has won the referendum on Europe when it hasn’t, following this up with a tantrum on a lorry while encouraging his bewildered supporters to celebrate, while the present Opposition Leader, then in a previous incarnation as a Super One journalist, misinterprets the referendum result via the party media, to bolster his boss.

Oh, there’s more to this story of the Battle of the Leaks. Austin Gatt stood up in parliament and said that independent investigation into the “leaks and hacking” accusations show that no unauthorised persons have gained access to data from the government’s IT system. The stories which the opposition orchestrated, and which were reported in the media, were just a pack of lies. Somebody was trying to get information, but nobody did. Then Gatt made an interesting accusation, which dropped right into a news-reporting vacuum as usual. He said that “the Labour Party traffics every day in data leaked and stolen from government departments”.

Please, sir, may we have some more? I think we’re owed a more detailed explanation.

www.daphnecaruana

galizia.com

  • don't miss