The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

The Petition on the Ramla development

Malta Independent Sunday, 23 November 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 18 years ago

From Dr S. Busuttil MEP

Three weeks ago The Malta Independent on Sunday levelled defamatory charges at me regarding a petition on the Ramla development that was closed by the Petitions Committee of the European Parliament. I categorically denied these charges.

Last week, The Malta Independent on Sunday went one further by rebutting my reaction using a “source” whose identity was incredibly left anonymous. This means that whereas readers know what I said, they do not have the benefit of knowing the identity of the “source”, who is claiming that I am wrong.

Differing opinions are the essence of democracy and that is fine. But this is the first time in my experience in public office that someone who thinks that I am wrong hides behind anonymity. So I leave it to the readers of The Malta Independent on Sunday to assess my credibility against that of a “source” who is afraid to reveal his identity.

The underlying insinuation in The Malta Independent on Sunday’s inexplicable tirade against me in recent weeks is that I do not oppose the Ramla development because I agreed to close a petition submitted by Alternattiva Demokratika against this development and later opposed its reopening.

Nothing could be further from the truth since the petition was closed simply because there is no authorised development in Ramla to object to in the first place. Moreover, I have already publicly expressed my agreement with the revocation of this permit by the Maltese authorities.

Allow me, however, to provide my version of the recent facts since these do not emerge clearly from the report published in The Malta Independent on Sunday.

During a meeting of the Petitions Committee on 6 November, MEPs were informed by the chairman that, on the request of the Green group, the co-ordinators meeting to prepare the work of the committee decided to re-open a Maltese petition. It was not clear at that stage whether this announcement related to the petition on the Ramla l-Hamra development or the Sant Antnin plant, both of which were closed last month by the Petitions Committee.

On a point of order I enquired about this matter and insisted that it was inappropriate to overturn a Committee decision to close a petition in this manner. I argued that once the Committee closed a petition then it should only be re-opened by the Committee itself and not through the back door, as the Greens sought to do.

My intervention was supported by another MEP from my group who insisted that the petition in question remain closed until proper evidence was brought on why it should be re-opened. On this basis the petition remained closed.

It appears that the Greens want to reopen this petition because an appeal on the Ramla development is pending.

I do not agree. The petition was closed for the simple reason that no permit for this development exists. The fact that an appeal by the developer appears to be underway does not change the fact that no development is currently authorised.

Moreover, the permit was revoked by the authorities themselves and the appeal was lodged by the developer, not the authorities. So keeping the petition open just to apply pressure on the authorities – as The Malta Independent on Sunday’s anonymous source seems to suggest – does not make sense at all in this case. Still less does it make sense to keep it open in order to apply pressure on a judicial process that is underway.

As I already stated in my first reaction, if the development is indeed re-authorised by the appeal, then the petition can always be reopened or resubmitted afresh. I would have no difficulty with that. But as long as no development is authorised I see no reason why we should re-open this petition.

Except for one. Alternattiva would no doubt like to keep its petition open for its own political ends. But in my book this is not a good enough reason.

In the final analysis what matters is not whether Alternattiva’s petition is closed or re-opened but whether the Ramla development goes ahead. To date, there is no permit for it to go ahead.

I hope that, from the above, it is clear to one and all that my conduct on this issue was appropriate, contrary to the wrong impression given by The Malta Independent on Sunday.

Simon Busuttil

STRASBOURG

  • don't miss