A 26-year-old carpenter was jailed for three months after he was acquitted of the attempted murder of two men and causing grievous injuries on another man during a brawl in Paceville on 10 October 2004, however was found guilty of illegally possessing a penknife.
The panel of jurors, after six hours of deliberation, returned with a non guilty verdict of eight votes to one on the two charges, yet, unanimously found him guilty of illegally possessing a penknife.
The jury said Anthony Bartolo grievously injured the three men during the brawl at Bamboo Bar in order to defend himself, his brother and a friend.
In handing down his judgment, Mr Justice Joseph Galea Debono said Mr Bartolo armed himself with a penknife with the intent of using it if involved in a brawl. Mr Bartolo had told the police in a statement he released soon after the incident, that he had been carrying a penknife for six years after being badly beaten by twenty people.
Mr Bartolo’s vice, said Mr Justice Galea Debono, given that none of the other people involved in the fight was armed, served only increase the gravity of the situation. This should be reflected in the penalty given that three men ended with grievous injuries, he said, as he jailed him for three months. This is the harshest penalty prescribed by law.
The 26-year-old Qormi carpenter was charged with the attempted murder by stabbing of Darryl Luke Borg and Clint Mangion and hitting them in their neck, grievously injuring Pierre Micallef in the hand and possessing a penknife without a police licence.
The three men took the witness stand on Tuesday and told the court they felt being stabbed but could not identify the aggressor.
In his submissions on penalty, defence counsel Joseph Giglio told the court that the verdict was very clear and his client had a clean police record. He reminded the court that the penalty for illegally possessing a penknife varied between a fine of e116.46 and three months imprisonment. Thus he asked the court to inflict a suspended sentence should it consider a jail term.
After the verdict was read out, Mr Barbara’s family members who were present in the hall rushed in the court’s corridor to inform their loved ones who greeted the news with an applause and cries of joy. It was evident as they broke down in tears that they were relieved of the stress they had accumulated during the three-day trial.
Defence lawyers Joseph and Robert Abela were also involved in the scene of joy. Bartolo family members hugged the two lawyers, with Dr Abela, who was at his first trial by jury, openly venting satisfaction while his veteran colleague was more composed.
Head of the Prosecution Unit at the Attorney General’s Office Anthony Barbara prosecuted.