One of the first things that the Data Protection Commissioner will have to look into once appointed will be the data sharing between the government and the Nationalist Party, said Opposition Leader Joseph Muscat yesterday.
Speaking during a press conference to announce that the Labour Party was in agreement with the Prime Minister’s nomination, Dr Muscat said that the case in question, whereby PN secretary general Paul Borg Olivier inadvertently copied his PL counterpart’s email into the mail shot, was a very serious breach of privacy of normal everyday citizens.
“We are not against political parties reaching out to help people, that is part of our mission. But we are against the state supplying a political party with people’s personal details and the complaints they have made to various ministries or departments,” said the PL leader.
Dr Muscat said that he will not divulge the name which was given to him by the Prime Minister as the person who is preferred to assume the mantle of the commissioner. In fact, the Office of the Prime Minister, later in the day, confirmed that the PL had agreed to the name submitted and this person will now be sent for and offered the post.
Dr Muscat handed out copies of the email to the press, which in essence stated that a meeting had been held at the PN’s Headquarters where customer care representatives from the PN, customer care officials within government secretariats and two high profile OPM officials, Charmaine Gerada and Alfred Mangion agreed on a legislature long sharing of personal data.
The email was copied to cabinet members, high ranking PN officials, the PM’s media man, the PN’s communications department and, most importantly, Jason Micallef, rather than Jason Azzopardi.
In the email, Dr Borg Olivier said that the meeting was called to strengthen the web of communication to be more effective in any work related to the approaching of “the party, ministers and parliamentary secretaries”.
Dr Borg Olivier also wrote that the “process in the run up to the elections can be a process spread over a whole legislature”. Dr Muscat said that the government issued a reply the next day, almost 24 hours later and it was clear that it had “been doctored and had clear trails of legal advice”. The Opposition Leader continued: “The PL offices also received phone calls from the PN, asking us to bury this story. We will not.”
He said that this country was in a state where there was no distinction between the government and the political party. “This is very serious indeed,” said Dr Muscat.
The Opposition Leader said that it was now clear that the PN and the government had collaborated in the run-up to the election in following up people’s various complaints in the hope of winning votes.
He said the most damning aspect of the whole case was that the exercise was coordinated by the OPM.
“The Prime Minister needs to be held accountable for this and the PL is asking the new commissioner to investigate the case thoroughly,” said Dr Muscat.
Taking questions from the floor, the Labour leader said that this was a clear-cut case of spying. “The PL has never done anything like this. This is not a case of sour grapes either, it is a case of safeguarding the public’s rights,” said Dr Muscat.
The PL leader also said that the party received phone calls from people saying that their gripes had miraculously been addressed in the meantime. “The people who received the requests by the PN to bury the story will testify in due course. We will not identify them at this point,” he said. He also said that he intends to raise the issue in parliament, and possibly other fora.
He said the OPM was currently conducting a damage control exercise. “We also do not exclude the possibility of there being a sacrificial lamb. This is a case of a most serious nature,” concluded Dr Muscat.