The economy is being injected with poisonous uncertainty and instability, according to Labour Party finance spokesperson Charles Mangion, who sees policies such as the government’s tariff revisions as fostering instability, and its excessively rosy pre-electoral and current picture public finances as unrealistic.
First of all, Dr Mangion points out, the government has portrayed what he considers to be an overly optimistic picture of the state of public finances.
Not only is the public deficit, at e243 million according to the latest November statistics, running at almost four times the projected 2008 estimates, the figure does not even include the e55 million to be paid to Malta Shipyard employees as part of their early retirement packages.
The state of affairs, according to Dr Mangion, means that, in order for the government to make good on its forecast, it would have to rake in an additional e80 million over the last two months of the year – no mean feat considering today’s lean economic times.
As such, Dr Mangion has “serious doubts” as to whether the government would even be able to meet its revised 2008 revenue estimate of e200 million.
He observes, “In the current situation in which people are spending less and the economy is, although not in recession, slowing, it would be a little difficult for the government to rake in that revenue – even with companies making the final tax payments during the time frame”.
For even the revised estimate to be met, the government would have to take in some e40 million over and above what normally happens, considering trends over the last two year, in the last quarter of the year.
On the expenditure side, Dr Mangion describes the government’s three per cent projected increase as “understandable” given that the estimate was in line with economic growth.
But instead of the projected three per cent expenditure growth, expenditure has actually soared by 11 per cent over the year without, he observes, increasing capital expenditure but rather through increased recurrent expenditure – much of which has been on the books for some time and which should have been budgeted for.
Dr Mangion points out that, “The government, funnily enough, attributes this rise in expenditure to the increase in the cost of fuel. The government, however, has confirmed that up to last July, since it had entered into a hedging agreement, it saved almost e55 million as a result of the hedging agreement and was in the positive.
“Therefore, the cost of the government’s energy subsidy, until July, had definitely been accounted for and the government had not lost out.
“Between July and September, the cost of fuel skyrocketed, which was costing the government e7 million a month. But after September, prices began decreasing drastically, and dropped threefold in one month.
“It is understandable that because of the hedging agreement we lost some money. The result of that can be good, and it can be bad. That is something that needs to be accepted, which is why I never criticised along these lines.
“But, on the other hand, it is inexplicable how the 11 per cent explosion in recurrent expenditure could be attributed simply to the cost of fuel.
“In actual fact, there is another e70 million in expenditure that went on things like public service wage increases, which the government had clearly been in a position to anticipate when it was working out the 2008 estimates.”
Such anomalies, Dr Mangion points out, are a recurring theme in the wider public financial picture.
e3 million in wages for Gozo, he points out, were no surprise as the increase is provided for in the public service agreement. Another extra cost was the contribution to public transport, a contractual matter decided upon well in advance and which also should have been accounted for.
“The moral of the story,” Dr Mangion comments, “is the question of whether the 2008 estimates were real, or whether there was some creative accounting to portray a solid state of public finances in the formulation of Budget 2008 in the lead up to the last general elections.
“That is what it all boils down to – before the election we are always given a positive picture of public finances, and after the election things start going haywire.
“First the government gives the impression that there have been a lot of sacrifices and then it starts giving out friendly measures such as increases in family allowances and tax cuts. Then all of a sudden the e40 million that it put into people’s pockets before the election is simply taken out again within eight months through the tariff revision.
“This does not really make sense, and makes me very much doubtful of the picture of public finances that we have today.”
The government, Dr Mangion observes, is also placing itself into growing debt. Citing recent figures, Dr Mangion points out that over the first eight months of the year the government had borrowed e285 million, e90 million of which went toward repaying matured loans. Another e180 million, however, constituted new debt.
The country’s total public debt of e3.5 billion, he points out, amounts to a e25,000 burden on each and every Maltese family.
“This is the real state of public finances and the government has to make sure that recurrent expenditure is reined in, and here we are not talking of wages and social benefits, which we know about.
“This theory that social benefits are increasing recurrent expenditure is mistaken. The October year on year increase in social security was of 1.5 per cent, which is pretty normal and an accepted level, so the excuse being given that it is social benefits that are pushing up expenditure is simply incorrect.”
There were, he observes, increases in health costs – such as the agreed hike in doctors’ wages, which also should have been anticipated considering they had been agreed upon in January and as such should have been accounted for by September.
There was also a larger bill for medicine purchases. “But,” Dr Mangion comments, “we tend to forget that since Mater Dei was completed in 2006, and officially opened in 2007, the annual e36 million in capital expenditure on the hospital is no longer required.
“As such, any increase in the medicinal bill would have been offset by the cessation of capital expenditure on Mater Dei itself. A e12 million increase in medicines amounts to one-third of the annual capital expenditure on the hospital’s construction.”
Given that the two major areas of social benefits and health are compensated for, Dr Mangion argues, there must be other areas that are costing the government which the people are not seeing any real benefit from.
Along these lines, Dr Mangion says the government so-called Extra Budgetary Units – public authorities and bodies, need to be looked at more closely.
“We have to ask whether we are getting value for money there. Are they protecting the consumer?
“The answer is often ‘no’, because we never get any answers on any item of dispute – the costs of school uniforms and transport, the costs of medicine and food –and the people simply have to keep on paying.
“Where are the increases going, and why are certain overruns being tolerated?
“The government needs to ensure value for money and that capital expenditure is not being overrun since that comes right out of the taxpayers’ pocket. A 10 per cent overrun is normally acceptable, but we are talking of levels well over 10 per cent in several instances.
“The government definitely needs to rein in on the expenditure side. That does not mean cutting down on benefits, but rather better resource management that yields value for money and gets people to work rather than contracting out services. These are all things that need to be looked at very carefully.”
Along these lines, Dr Mangion proposes that a group of independent auditors carries out a proper audit to identify all those areas that need reining in.
Additionally, Dr Mangion insists the government must move on with a transfer from its current cash-based accounting to an accrual accounting system, a concept on the table for the last ten years.
But, Dr Mangion adds, the e40,000 allocated annually to make the monumental shift is nowhere near what is needed for an entire government to carry out such a major exercise.
“Such a shift,” Dr Mangion points out, “would mean we would get to know what we really have, and I think that is why we have been merely toying with this idea for a decade and everyone is dragging their feet.”
But despite the apparent failures in government finance, Malta, Dr Mangion says, has been lucky within the wider picture of the international financial meltdown. Malta’s banks were not affected drastically, their e8.5 billion in bank deposits are safe, they are still liquid and able to give credit.
“That is something to be proud of and exploit,” Dr Mangion says, adding that the trouble is by no means over since the European and eurozone recession has already and will have more of an impact on the local economy.
“We have already felt it in the two major economic sectors of tourism and manufacturing, while consumption in the services sector could also be expected to be affected.”
The unfortunate reality of the situation, Dr Mangion comments, is that exports were already down over the year’s first half, when the signs of an impending recession were already written on the wall but still on the horizon.
“This”, Dr Mangion notes, “is a sure indication that we need to shore up our competitiveness.”
But, at the same time, a positive element, from a competitiveness viewpoint, is that wages are not increasing and are as such very much competitive with the rest of Europe.
Malta’s wage increases were, in fact, the lowest in Europe and in 2008 were also lower than inflation – meaning that Malta, with an average hourly production cost of some e8, was one of the lowest one of the lowest in the EU and far below the eurozone average of e26-e27.
In terms of tourism, a sensitive sector and a major pillar of the economy, Malta has had a rebound in overall numbers but, Dr Mangion points out, revenue per tourist has decreased.
“Tourists are leaving less money in the country and the expenditure we attribute to each tourist in terms of infrastructure, maintenance, cost of electricity and so on rises since we have greater numbers, but the fact that they are spending less leaves us with an imbalance.
“In the other major sector of manufacturing, the result of lower exports is an increase in inventories, goods produced in factories that remain unsold, which had risen threefold over the first six months of 2008.
“This meant four-day weeks and people being laid off, and the same thing is gradually happening in the tourism sector. People are seeing their bookings dropping because of the international situation, and as such it was definitely a bad move to increase electricity tariffs at the present point in time.
“The way the whole tariff revision issue has been handled is a complete mess that is creating uncertainty and instability. Nobody knows what they are going to be paying.
“This boils down to a monopolistic situation and the role of the regulators – one does what it likes and the other does not exist... and we are paying for it. We very clearly cannot continue in this way, which is why we say that, politically, what we need is a clear direction.
“The government’s role is to instil stability in an uncertain situation, not to aggravate a situation that wasn’t all that bad locally in the first place.
“The tariffs issue is still very much uncertain, the issue started in October and no one knows where they stand yet. The government is conceding to the unions, the tourism sector is saying it is getting some rebate, the manufacturing sector does not know how much it is going to pay, except for the major firms that were capped, and so on and so forth.
“All this amounts to great uncertainty – and the government cannot be the instrument of uncertainty, it has to be the instrument of certainty. What we need is not the strong hand of government in the negative sense, but to lead the way forward.”
Malta’s competitiveness, Dr Mangion observes, is also being eroded by the skill levels of its workers where, he argues, “we need to once again really look ahead at what we will be needing in terms of skills over the next five to 10 years”.
“We need to do something else. The ETC has taken some positive initiatives in training, but more has to be done. What needs to be infused into the psychology of all workers is that they need training throughout their lives.
“Young people are getting hold of this but older people need to understand they need to be trained, have their current skills sharpened and learn new skills. A lot of Drydocks workers that had skills have already found new employment, but others with more rudimentary skills are finding it difficult.”
Coupled with that is the opposition’s finding that close to half of our students are leaving the system practically illiterate and unskilled.
“How can that be explained?” Dr Mangion questions, “When the country has been carrying out education reforms practically every five years. In my opinion, all parties concerned have to put their heads together, start from the basics and see what really needs to be done over the next 10 to 15 years – and whoever is in government would continue doing it.
“We had reforms under (former education minister) Louis Galea first, and practically annual reforms under Dolores Cristina. This lack of synchronisation cannot go on.
“The real situation of having 42 to 43 per cent of people leaving the system unskilled and practically illiterate and only qualifying for low wage jobs needs to be addressed. What we need is a long term plan, a flexible plan but one that maintains the same structure.”
“The government is not addressing the issues with a clear direction. By increasing the tariffs, the government is also increasing the cost of our products. They will increase more over the coming years with the cost of gas, where a 200 to 300 per cent increase is a big issue, but the government has not stated how much those increases will amount to. Now we are speaking another new sewage tax, creating additional uncertainty, while all employees were given through the budget was a e4 cost of living increase despite an exploding cost of living.
“In my opinion, what the government needs to do is postpone the tariffs, with the price of oil on the decline, and address the problems at Enemalta to cut down on waste, theft and leakages and to ensure electricity is produced at the lowest price possible.
“I fail to comprehend how you can have a monopoly, with the government also subsidising the price of electricity, and still end up with losses.
“We do not even have audited accounts for Enemalta for the last five years. With all that taxpayer money flowing in and no one accounting it and seeing what is happening to that money is truly an unbelievable and unacceptable situation. That is a joke that has not been stressed enough.”
From a social point of view, Dr Mangion argues, people are feeling things are getting out of hand and he adds, “the government cannot attribute the situation to cost of oil or cereals – costs are changing, but in Malta things seem not to change”.
“That”, he adds, “affects the economy as well. People are uncertain and afraid. They do not know what is going to happen next, and that is having a ripple effect on the economy in terms of lowered consumption. Ask shopkeepers and they will tell you prospects for this Christmas are not good at all.
“This ripple effect of this uncertainty that the government is creating by the way in which it is handling the tariffs, gas, now the sewage and other issues are creating uncertainty and instability, which are poison to every economy.”