The Malta Independent 19 November 2026, Thursday
View E-Paper

Parents In the dark on Eden-Razzett collaboration

Malta Independent Sunday, 14 December 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 13 years ago

Some time this week the final decision will be taken on how close the relationship will be between the Eden Foundation and the Razzet tal-Hbiberija.

Up to a few days ago, the talk was about a merger, then the pending relationship was called a “joint venture”.

So far, calls by a parents’ association asking to be kept informed seem to have fallen on deaf ears, and various other issues have come up – all require clear answers.

Repeated calls to Philip Rizzo yesterday, one of the remaining members on Eden’s board of directors, remained unanswered.

Two of the six-strong board of directors, Brother Martin Borg and Dr Joe Bugeja, a parent, have resigned, apparently due to disagreement with the other directors. The Eden Foundation’s statute, seen by this paper, says the board should be composed of not less than six and not more than 10 members. The question this newspaper wanted to ask Mr Rizzo (the other directors are chairman Joe Grioli and Dennis Zammit Cutajar) is whether a board of four (about the fourth more anon) could take the important merger decision or whether a board of three effective members could independently appoint a further three or even six other board members.

The fourth member of the board, Fr Charles Abela, is the representative of the archbishop. Fr Abela has not attended board meetings in a long time. When approached lately he said he was not receiving any agendas.

At the 2 December meeting, Fr Abela hesitated about casting his vote, which would have effectively meant a tie, and said he wanted to sound out the archbishop. The board consented. The next day, Fr Abela said he had spoken to Fr Anthony Gouder and came up with an addition to the proposal that effectively voted in favour of the merger.

Many close to the foundation are linking this decision by Fr Gouder to a speech made in Parliament by Evarist Bartolo on 15 November in which he spoke in favour of the merger, adding that he hoped the Church would not block such a merger.

Outvoted in the 3 December board meeting, Br Martin and Dr Bugeja resigned.

Apart from these internal board issues, one substantial question regards the different nature of the two organisations. One, Eden, is a Maltese organisation, sustained by public funds. It focuses mainly on intellectual disability. And, through sustained fund-raising it will have a healthy e300,000 profit this year. (Even so, however, it has cut down on a number of its initiatives in recent years and today lacks people with an educational background).

Its statute also says that were it to cease operations, its assets are to pass to the Kummissjoni Nies b’Disabbilta.

On the other hand, Razzett is a private organisation, part of the Janatha Stubbs Foundation, which is registered in the UK. It focuses mainly on physical disability and offers activities such as horse riding, swimming in the pool, wheelchair dancing and the like.

On the financial side, Eden’s salaries are lower while it appears that Razzett’s, has far fewer human resources, with three full-time and three part-time in the disability services section while Eden has 76 full timers and 60 part-timers. Even so, while the share of Eden human resources devoted to management and fund-raising averages around 14 per cent of total payroll cost, many ask what the percentage of the administrative side of Razzett amounts to compared to the disability services it offers, whether Razzett will be making a profit or a loss this year, and whether its CEO, Nathan Farrugia, who owns and runs a consultancy business, charges Razzett for his services and advice.

The man most people associate with Eden, Josie Muscat, left the foundation when he ventured into politics. On 2 December he asked Fr Abela, on behalf of a parents association he had set up, to organise a meeting for the parents with the archbishop. Fr Abela came back saying there was no problem but the meeting had to be held with Fr Gouder. However, no meeting has taken place.

Essentially, it could perhaps be argued that deciding on the future direction of an organisation does not necessarily depend on the approval of the parents of the clients of that organisation, but does that make sense?

In a way, what happens at ground level often makes any talk of mergers or similar appear out of place. For years, for instance, Eden has had a shop at the Embassy Complex. Now, when the two organizations are contemplating a merger, Razzett has opened another shop in the same complex.

Overall, it makes sense for the two organisations to act with more synergy and complement each other, which may be why it could make more sense for a joint venture to be created than an outright merger.

Other people who may be interested in what is happening could be the 90 people, some of very high calibre, who applied for a recent call for applications for a CEO at Eden. They have been left completely in the dark have not even received an acknowledgement of their application.

  • don't miss