The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Oh Jingle bells! He’s back

Malta Independent Thursday, 8 January 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Mister Power of Incumbency is back to entertain us, sporting his trademark poker-face and deploying his humour-busting verbal missiles in L-orizzont.

This time he’s decided to tell us, in densely-knitted prose over two pages, why the people who wrote Labour’s Why We Lost report were wrong and why he – of course – was right. He brought up the power of incumbency, Air Malta’s cheap flights for voters, “illegal favours”, extravagance with public funds, “illegally obtained information about private citizens” and – oh yes – contracts. He used to tell us that contracts and favours were handed out to tal-qalba, friends of friends, and il-barunijiet. Now he’s telling us that they’re being used in a form of elaborate gift exchange in return for the votes of those who wouldn’t have voted Nationalist otherwise. Make up your mind, sir.

Where have we heard all this before? It was at his resignation press conference just after his fourth consecutive hammering at the polls (three general elections and one referendum). You know the one: the resignation press conference at which he didn’t really resign, the one to which reporters turned up in force expecting to hear his valedictory only to find out that they’d been summoned to hear how right he was and how wrong the rest of us were. Let’s put it this way: John McCain he ain’t. Grace and dignity he can do without.

We heard much the same thing, too, in that infamous interview in The Sunday Times just before the country went to the polls – yes, that’s right, No regrets. He had no regrets about any decision he’d taken in the past, no regrets about the mess he’d made about the European Union and Switzerland in the Mediterranean and partnership. Frankly, my dear, he didn’t give a damn. But unlike Rhett Butler, he couldn’t quite carry it off, and made people so mad with this pig-headed refusal to adjust, budge or admit error that they hissed him all the way to another defeat.

I’m not a big fan of Joseph Muscat. You all know what I think of him by now. But you have to admire the man’s restraint in not telling this serial loser where to get off the bus instead of shouting instructions from the back-seat. Or maybe it’s just that his former poodle owes him so many favours that he feels obliged to pad his response in cotton-wool. “The country is facing new challenges and can’t waste time looking back at past mistakes and failed solutions,” he said. The rest of that sentence was left hanging in mid-air, unsaid: … “or listening to failed leaders”. And by the way, Mr Opposition Leader, sir, it’s not the country that’s exercised by the internal wrangling of the Labour Party, but the Labour Party itself. The country has other things to be getting on with.

Who takes advice from those who couldn’t run their own show when they had the chance? If Alfred Sant was such a great leader, if he knew the answers and had all the solutions, he wouldn’t have spent 22 months as prime minister and 14 years in opposition. He wouldn’t have lost three elections on the trot and one referendum for good measure. And he wouldn’t have claimed, after each of those losses – I have to remind you about this, because I’d forgotten it myself until now – that the other party’s win against him was illegitimate, and that it would all come to grief, you’ll see. After one of those defeats – let’s see, which one was it now, 1998? – he actually wrote to all the big bosses in the European Union that he didn’t want to join, telling them why the new government was illegitimate.

And here we are, a whole decade later, still listening to him rewind those old gripes, again and again and again. So this government is illegitimate too, is it? What, do you mean like the one that got in when you messed up so royally 10 years ago? My, my – now that’s what I call a coincidence. It’s funny that it should have happened to the same man, at the hands of two different opponents. I’ll put on my tin-foil hat and see if there’s any conspiracy here, possibly involving the CIA, the FBI, MI5, the Bader Meinhof and Giulio Andreotti. And maybe the Mafia was involved? I’m sure that if Sant were to give Anglu Farrugia a ring he’d have some interesting theories. Now there’s a man with a whole wardrobe of tin-foil hats. And then Joseph Muscat can write a book about it in his spare time. He is hoping for a boring year, after all, or at least, that’s what he told The Sunday Times when it asked him for his hopes for 2009.

Sant says that he’s speaking now, when the dust has settled over at the Labour Party (you tell me; maybe Anglu’s famous elephant stampeded) because he didn’t want to be seen as interfering by giving his views earlier on. Is the man spending too much time in the company of his poultry – something which I admit to understanding, given that I find animals so much easier to get along with than people? Whenever, however and wherever he speaks about party matters, it’s going to be construed as interference, for the simple reason that this is exactly what it is. Maybe he doesn’t remember what happened when he was prime minister and Mintoff gave him advice in the summer of 1998. If so, there are a few videos on YouTube which record the event. Former party leaders should fade quietly into the night and, like former spouses, maintain a dignified silence at all times. The trouble with Alfred Sant is that he is psychologically incapable of admitting defeat or coming to terms with the fact that he was wrong.

Look at him now: after all these years and all these changes, he’s still insisting that he was right about the wrongness of EU membership for Malta. “Time is proving correct Labour’s views about the effect of EU membership on families and businesses,” he wrote in L-orizzont. Labour’s views? They were his views, and he imposed them on the rest. Look how readily they’ve all come running to embrace the EU and, more to the point, what the EU can do for them.

Imagine that: despite all the changes for the better, despite the very culture change that has opened up the world for Maltese people from all social backgrounds and of all ages except the most elderly, he’s still saying that we should have stayed confined to this couple of rocks, mentally, physically and in terms of business. “It is only the elite who are benefiting from membership,” he said. Come off it, Dr Sant. It’s true that among the first to leap on the gravy-train of public office in Brussels were a gaggle of Super One journalists, one of whom is now gagging to become prime minister, but that doesn’t mean they’re the elite, nor does it mean that ordinary people from anonymous backgrounds are not hoovering up the opportunities.

Just as he has held on to his opinions and not veered from them even in the face of mounting evidence that he was wrong, so Alfred Sant demonstrates, with his most recent foray into the public arena, that he has lost none of his losing streak. His advice to Joseph Muscat is to ignore what’s said and written by those who “always want to weaken the left and Labour, like The Sunday Times and others of that sort.”

Even leaving aside the fact that Labour has long since veered to the right of the political spectrum, you would imagine that somebody who has spent the last 35 years waving his marketing and business administration degrees around, heavily disguised as “ekonomija”, would be familiar with the essential wisdom of setting a thief to catch a thief. In other words, if the Labour Party wants to understand the thinking and attitudes of those whose votes it needs for a resounding victory at the polls, then it should make keen interpretation of what’s said and published by “The Sunday Times and others of that sort” mandatory for all of its politicians.

Sant’s advice to Muscat shouldn’t be to blockheadedly ignore what The Sunday Times leader-writers and columnists like me are writing (the man can’t bring himself to mention me by name; it sticks in his throat), for the simple reason that we echo the thoughts of others. We are not odd-balls operating in a vacuum. Sant’s policy of ignoring those he doesn’t like, of pretending that we don’t exist, of refusing to answer questions at press conferences and glaring at or looking through “enemy” journalists, of not properly listening to what was being said or reading what was written, served him ill. It took his finger right off the pulse. Joseph Muscat would be making a serious mistake if he went down the same path. But I think he knows that. I think he’s realised at last – probably with that useful hindsight that allows him to see now, almost six years later, that maybe the Yes lobby won the referendum – that his old boss and poodle-master has been the problem all along. And forget the power of incumbency.

  • don't miss