Art and Medicine are two disciplines that, at first glance, seem as different as chalk and cheese. However, a closer look shows that there are several parallels between them. For one thing, both the artist and the doctor have to be keen observers: the conclusions of their observations, whether a painting or other work of art in the case of the artist, or a clinical diagnosis in the case of the clinician, are the result of a careful analysis of the information gained from their respective observations. It is a process that is very much like looking for clues and trying to find where they best fit in a more general picture. This sounds very much like detective work – since the detective also has to develop a keen sense of observation not to miss any potential clues. It is not at all surprising to note that a medical doctor, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, created Sherlock Holmes, the greatest detective of all times. In turn, Conan Doyle was greatly influenced by one of his teachers at the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh, D. Joseph Bell, who was renowned for his analytical methods. Conan Doyle himself gave credit to Bell: he dedicated one of the Sherlock Holmes books to him, and he also wrote to him telling him “You are yourself Sherlock Holmes and well you know it.” Great physicians of the past – Sir William Osler, Sir Stanley Davidson, Tinsley Harrison among several others – developed clinical observation into a real art. The medical pendulum is fast swinging in medicine from the art to the science side. However, the best clinician is the one who, armed with his scientific knowledge, practises by using excellent clinical judgement, which, of course, is his art. In the case of the artist, van Gogh summed it up by saying “Art demands constant observation”. It is only through observation that the artist can register the feeling that he wishes his painting to give. Thus, the end results of the doctor’s and the artist’s works are both subjective interpretations, both based on personal observation and, in the case of the doctor, confirmed by objective criteria that can be provided by various investigations – such as blood tests or imaging studies.
There are various areas where medicine and art, in particular the visual arts, overlap. A particular work of art may depict the physician’s role in sickness and his relationship with the patient. We have fine examples of this in Malta of the Hospitaller Knights of St. John ministering to the sick in the Sacra Infermeria. Picasso’s early work, “Science and Charity”, which he painted in 1897– when he was only 16 years old – before he originated the Cubist movement is another work of this nature. There are many other examples of this type of art; several of them have been collected by Professor Alan Emery and his wife Marcia in a wonderful book called Medicine and Art, published in 2003 by the Royal Society of Medicine in association with the Royal College of Physicians of London.
Another area of overlap between art and medicine is the depiction of deformities or diseases in paintings. Some of these may be quite obvious – such as a squint, blindness, dwarfism and various hand and foot disorders like crowding of the toes, bunions and so on. Other abnormalities may be more subtle and may indicate disease. In such instances, the clinician must use his powers of observation and deduction to his best possible ability. In the case of the clinical analysis of a work of art the doctor does not have the luxury of ordering blood tests, X-rays or other investigations to prove his hypothesis. It is obvious, therefore, that the degree of clarity of the clues as depicted by the artist, as well as the number of clues that are provided or that can be picked up, will make a stronger case for the doctor’s diagnosis. In many instances a firm diagnosis cannot be established – and this, of course is a matter that generates a lot of interesting controversy and argument – did Caravaggio’s ‘Sleeping Cupid’ suffer from rickets, did he suffer from arthritis – or was he just a normal boy? Did Leonardo’s ‘Mona Lisa’ have some abnormality in her cholesterol level? The old man in Ghirlandaio’s ‘Old Man and Child’ shows an obvious abnormality in his nose – but does the child have an abnormal hand? And what about Botticelli’s ‘Venus’ and the young man in his ‘Portrait of a Youth’? Did the subject whose hands are depicted in Durer’s ‘Praying Hands’ suffer from diabetes mellitus – or was it rheumatoid arthritis? And what is the cause of the swelling in the neck of the young lady in Remmerseaele’s ‘The Money Changer and His Wife’? Some of the most fascinating examples depicting features of disease in art are found in the work of Flemish painters.
Rheumatology is a discipline within medicine. It deals with the diagnosis and the treatment of about 200 different diseases, collectively referred to as arthritis or rheumatic disorders. Rheumatology attained an identity of its own over the past 60 years or so, but we know from different sources that mankind has suffered from various rheumatic afflictions for thousands of years. Because of lack of knowledge about the nature of disease, such conditions were all included in a single word, “gout” – which included gout itself, as well as many other rheumatic and other diseases. The depiction of certain abnormalities in old paintings suggests that several diseases were present even before they were first officially described and recorded in medical literature.
Finally, artists may themselves suffer from disease: some of the recorded ones including visual deterioration, tuberculosis, mental disease, scleroderma, and rheumatoid arthritis. In some cases illness had a significant effect on the quality of the artist’s work, and in other instances, the actual content of the work was influenced by the artist’s illness.
Professor Mallia will deliver a public lecture discussing the relationship between art and medicine, with particular reference to rheumatology, on Thursday 5 February at 7:30pm at the Auberge d’Aragon. The lecture, entitled “Art, Artists and Arthritis”, is being held under the auspices of the Ministry of Justice and Home Affairs.
Professor Mallia is a consultant rheumatologist and Professor of Medicine at the University of Malta. He has been working as a consultant in clinical medicine and rheumatology for over 30 years.