The PN might have some 77 electoral promises in their manifesto and some 87 recommendations in their climate change consultation document but when we put hype and spin apart we will soon find that their environmental record so far since re-assuming office has been dismal, to say the least.
Apart from the fact that the PM seems to be dragging his feet on Mepa reform, many are anticipating a watered down and limp document, all under the pretext of not hindering “progress”.
I have never argued that development should be halted but as a party we are statutorily committed to ensure that any projects and initiatives must be linked to the basic tenets of sustainable development.
We shall wait and see if the PM is going to really surprise us.
If it comes to EU Directives on the environment our record is dismal to say the least, and infringements abound in most areas, particularly when it comes to air quality.
Noise pollution issues do not seem to bother government at all.
Documents continue to abound.
In various cases environmental data is either not provided or else not submitted in time.
We have no national energy document. The alternative energy document remains in draft form since 2006 while no progress reports were ever provided about the 2001 solid waste strategy since then. All we are told is that we have been on track throughout this period.
The government has even mishandled two issues which could have really remained minor issues:
a) the plastic bags issue; and
b) the budgetary incentives for purchasers of solar water heaters and PVs.
Modesty apart, I personally think that the government reached it’s nadir when it tried to botch our attempt to get a resolution through the House for all political forces and stakeholders to set up a team of experts to draw up a holistic climate bill that could receive unanimous support the way the 1994 financial services legislation did then and continues to do up to the present day whenever any amendments or new bits of legislation are brought up for discussion and approval in the House.
Without wanting to the PN not only dented it’s green credentials seriously but it also went against the grain of all the NGOs that had publicly supported the bill I was promoting.
Since then EUREKA... the PN published it’s consultation document on the same day we were meant to discuss the private member’s bill, obviously to try and take the wind out of our sails!
Everybody saw through this. The Malta Independent claimed that through our pro-activity we had urged government to energise itself, while on the other hand The Times columnist CANDIDUS II stated in no uncertain terms that the minister concerned – when choosing to publish his consultation document on the same day as the discussion of the bill – showed that one can fool some people sometimes, but one cannot try to fool all the people at the same time.
As if the consultation document was not enough, we then had a hurriedly put together focus group (which if one examines what the remit and composition of a focus group is) looks to many independent outsiders as more of a think tank than anything else. Then we heard that within four weeks they will be reporting on the government document through a first draft. You can rest assured that by another six weeks we will have had:
c) the consultation document;
d) the first draft of the focus group;
e) the final draft of the focus group;
f) the final version of the consultation document.
Since our private member’s bill, climate has become the newly discovered in-thing in the PN media – articles, columnists, and even editorials. Just look at last Thursday’s In-Nazzjon.
One must admit that nobody beats the PN for glossy documents.
The pity is that past ones – particularly on the environment – tend to fall into these categories:
a) those which remain shelved;
b) those which remain ignored;
c) those where government does the right opposite to what they propose;
d) those which government drags it’s feet in publishing.
The minister concerned last week announced in the House that the government will be announcing it’s wind farm policies shortly.
Once wind farms are a source of alternative energy how can we have a wind farm policy without a holistic alternative energy policy?
Is it true or not that government did not even sign the founding treaty of IRENA the International Renewable Energy Agency which was established a few days ago – something which well over 70 other countries did already? At what level was Malta represented during this founding ceremony?
The PN made much noise about the fact that its focus group was headed by an environmentalist who is also actively engaged in Nature Trust. No harm in that and no slur on him.
But compare having a focus group headed by a media prominent environmentalist and the fact that the positive respondents we had were all NGOs including Nature Trust, supporting an original Friends of the Earth initiative to back our climate bill proposal.
We could have easily behaved like spoilt brats, sulked and shredded our copies of the government climate consultation document just because we did not have it our way on the climate bill.
On the contrary we are currently analysing at a purely technical level both the climate consultation document and the waste strategy consultation document.
As far as the climate document is concerned – one thing is certain.
Once we had originally insisted that there should be a climate bill to ensure full transparency in the House, ideally annually, on all climate related matters and targets – our technical response to the climate document will be delivered in the House.
If government will not even choose to commit itself to discuss this report in Parliament and have it approved there as well as commit itself to future similar discussions to monitor progress, then we will have really hit rock bottom!
In the coming days I will write at length about how the wind farm saga went haywire in the Nationalist government’s camp. I am already sure that one article will not suffice.
e-mail: brincat.leo@gmail. com
Leo Brincat is the Main Opposition Spokesperson for the Environment, Sustainable Development & Climate Change.