The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

There’s No substitute for merit

Malta Independent Thursday, 12 February 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 19 years ago

The government has been criticised by various people and organisations – and by the Labour Party, too, of course – for failing to include a woman among its nominees for the position of judge at the European Court of Human Rights. When the list of three nominees was sent back with instructions to include a woman or else, the government defended its decision on the basis that “where a contracting party has taken all necessary and appropriate steps with a view to ensuring that the list contains a candidate of the under-represented sex, but without success, and especially where it has followed the Assembly’s recommendations advocating an open and transparent procedure involving a call for candidatures, the Assembly may not reject the list in question on the sole ground that no such candidate features on it.” This was accepted.

My first reaction to this failure to include a woman in the list was one of immense irritation. It has been my experience of the working world over the last couple of decades and more is that any fool of a man is all right, but a woman must be exceptional. I am not predisposed to arguments based on emotion, rather than on rationality, information and common sense, and so I thought about it some more. If I hated it so much in the past when I was bypassed by men with far fewer skills, how on earth can I now advocate a situation in which women candidates with fewer qualifications than the men get the job purely on the basis of gender?

How would I feel if I and some other women, all of us eminently qualified in our field, were to be short-listed for an important post, only to be told that a man with a fraction of our experience and expertise is to be shoved onto that short-list so that the organisation in question might meet its gender-allocation requirements? I would be mightily annoyed, especially if the post is likely to go to the far less qualified man, on the grounds that men are under-represented and balance must be struck. What’s sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander. I don’t think men should be exposed to unfair competition from inadequately qualified women, by third parties who are seeking to address some gender issue or other. That’s what has been happening to women for generations. You don’t redress a wrong by creating another wrong.

Candidates either make the grade or don’t make the grade, and gender has nothing to do with it. In my working life, I’ve had to play second fiddle to men who knew a fraction of what I did and who had half my skills, which meant that I ended up making up for their shortcomings like a sort of glorified workplace bridesmaid. Having experienced this, there is no way on earth that I am going to wish the same experience, but in reverse, on a man, just out of some kind of ‘now it’s our turn’ attempt at balancing the scales.

I wouldn’t like it at all if my son or my husband were bumped out of the equation by a woman half as qualified, and so I wouldn’t like it if the same thing were to happen to somebody else’s son or husband. It’s just plain wrong.

The three names that Malta submitted are those of Chief Justice Vincent Degaetano, Judge Joseph Camilleri and Judge Joseph Filletti, all of whom sit in the Court of Appeal. Is there any woman in Malta who is at par with that kind of experience? No. Including a woman of lesser merit just for the sake of including a woman would not be an insult only to the three men on this list, but also to the woman herself, who is effectively being told “You don’t make the grade, but we’re going to include you anyway in the role of token woman.” The attendant risk with this course of action is the obvious one that the woman of lesser merit will be selected in preference to one of those three highly qualified judges, on the basis of some distorted view of gender balance. I can’t possibly approve of such silliness. We need to dispatch to the European Court of Human Rights the best available candidate, regardless of what that person’s gender might be.

Our problem with this candidature is invariably going to be that Malta’s first appointee to the ECHR set the bar rather high – beyond the reach of most of the available competition, in fact. Giovanni Bonello, though he was neither a magistrate nor a judge but a practising lawyer until his ECHR appointment, made his name in human rights law. I think it is safe to say that in this particular field no other Maltese person is as well respected as he is. He was always going to be an impossible act to follow.

The shortfall in suitably qualified women is temporary, the result of social history so far. We cannot make up for lost time by trying to compress it. These matters must take their natural course.

For decades, women lawyers were the exception in Malta, and this, coupled with excessive paternalism in our society, led to there being no appointments of women to the bench. Gradually and very recently, a few women magistrates were appointed and now, we have our first woman judge. Meanwhile, the number of women lawyers has exploded. Over the past few years, there have been more women reading law than there are men.

This means that among the youngest generation of lawyers, the gender balance is going to swing towards women. Law is increasingly a woman’s career, and within 20 years, it’s likely that we’re going to have our European Court of Human Rights nominee list sent back because there’s no man on it.

But first we’ve got to start by increasing the number of women judges. It was a disappointment that the most recent appointment to the bench was a man – not because of who he is, not at all, but because I am certain there are one or two women lawyers as qualified as he is, perhaps even more so. In a situation like that, where the candidates are of equal merit but the situation is screaming out for a woman, it’s best to go for the woman. One woman judge is not enough. It is quite ridiculous.

  • don't miss