The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

This Is a democracy: so shut up

Malta Independent Sunday, 22 February 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 19 years ago

The word “democracy” keeps being bandied about quite a lot lately.

There is the banning of the controversial play Stitching by the censorship board – the case has ended up in court with director Chris Gatt describing the ban as “the end of democracy”. The producers’ argument is that a handful of people should not be allowed to decide what other adults can or cannot see. On their part, the censors have described the play as “an insult to human dignity”, and that the right to freedom of expression is not absolute.

Then, after the St John’s Cathedral extension project was dropped, MaltaToday carried a cartoon in which Richard Cachia Caruana was depicted (in what was obviously a parody of the beheading of St John), lying in a pool of blood. The Nationalist Party failed to see the humour, so they issued a press release claiming that the cartoon was “an unacceptable caricature in a democratic society”. One of the reasons the PN didn’t smile was because they claimed the cartoon evoked images of when RCC was stabbed in Mdina. The newspaper has denied any such intention and in its Wednesday edition even dedicated its editorial to patiently “explaining” the cartoon. In a democracy, the newspaper pointed out, political cartoons come with the territory.

And last but not least, we have Astrid Vella, who leads the environmental group Flimkien Ghal Ambjent Ahjar, and who has managed to galvanise the usual apathetic Maltese into something of a citizens’ lobby. She believes that the people have a right to voice their objections against national projects with which they don’t agree and, in a democratic country, their voices should be heard. On the other hand, she is being challenged by those who feel that groups such as FAA are “stopping the democratic process” because they are not allowing projects to be first discussed and debated in Parliament.

It’s quite an elastic word this “democracy” that everyone keeps talking about and I find it amusing how people use it only when it suits them.

The common theme in all the three examples quoted above is an attempt to shut people up.

I can take you down

It’s clear that the whole crux of the matter where Astrid and FAA are concerned is that they have tapped into the well of current national dissatisfaction with the high-handed way the country is being run. More significantly, for once, people are standing up to be counted irrespective of their political beliefs.

Aha, therein lies the crunch.

You see, as long as Nationalist supporters demonstrated and marched and made loud noises against a Labour government then everyone was happy and democracy was “safe”.

But don’t you dare step outside that box I put you in. Don’t you dare be a Nationalist voter and have the temerity to object to something which a Nationalist government wants to do, because then it’s – off with your head!

What Astrid has done is pretty remarkable really. It has nothing to do with getting some signatures on a petition either because, let’s face it, 1,500 names is chicken feed. By now, it is also common knowledge that Gonzi (and more significantly, RCC) did not back down on the St John’s project simply because of this one woman. (Frankly, if her influence is as great as it’s being made out to be, then she should be running the country. Now that would really cause some hackles to rise.)

No, what Astrid has done is to make it OK for people to refuse to be pushed around by politicians. It has been a long time in coming, but we are finally seeing it happening. For too long, if you voted Blue or Red then God help you, you had to stick to your party come hell or high water. You might mutter your disgruntlement as long as it wasn’t within earshot of too many people, but basically you just knew you had to grin and bear it. It has now finally dawned on people (thanks to activists like Astrid Vella), that they do not have to accept everything from a government just because they were the ones who voted it into power.

Life is often rich with ironies. Who would have thought that a Nationalist government would slam into a wall of protests led mostly by traditional PN supporters? Of course, there are those who argue that these were the same Nationalists who refused to vote last March – which well may be true. However, to prove that, someone would have to have access to the election data and compare the names and I D card numbers of those who didn’t show up to vote with those who signed the FAA petition. Of course this just won’t happen because we know how much this government cherishes the Data Protection Act.

What this whole episode has shown is that we should not just sit there for four-and-a-half years like limp lettuce, virtually comatose, until we stir ourselves out of our stupor long enough to cast our vote when a general election comes round. Electing a party for five years does not mean that it has a mandate to do anything and everything it wants (“you voted for us, so we’d better not hear a peep out of you”). If the votes from the people in an election reign supreme, you cannot then turn around and tell those same voters that their opinion is no longer required, thank you very much.

If that were the case there would not be any need for making any potential project public – that kind of government would just steamroll ahead, irrespective of any objections or protests and do what the hell it wanted.

And we know that a Nationalist administration – whose clarion call has always been democracy – just wouldn’t do that.

Welcome to my lobby

I don’t know why people get so hot under the collar in this country with the existence of lobby or pressure groups. (Actually, I do know why – it’s because their plans are being thwarted).

But lobbying exists everywhere and it is a way of ensuring that the voice of the common citizen is heard. If they are to be effective these groups have to make their presence felt by putting pressure on politicians at every turn and using the media to their full advantage.

In this respect the FAA has succeeded and Astrid Vella has become a household name.

In fact, you can tell Astrid has been successful by the extent to which she is being ripped to shreds, figuratively speaking of course.

The amount of ripping is usually in direct proportion to the achievements of the “ripee”.

Karma

And, of course, it is has not been lost on anyone that stirring the pot not too far behind the scenes in the whole St John’s project saga was the one and only Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando. It really is poetic justice that the one person whom the Nationalist Party defended to the hilt for political expediency turned out to be their Brutus.

No for no’s sake?

There seems to be the mistaken perception that the public is shooting down each new mega project being announced by the government just to be difficult.

The truth is that people are consciously tightening their own belts, so when they see this administration willing to squander funds on what it views as low priority projects, they are speaking up. We elect representatives to lead the country, and we count on them to use the taxes we pay to be spent well – but when there is a suspicion that our euros are going to be flushed down the drain by being used on something unfeasible, unwieldy and unattainable within the time frame originally projected, then we get upset.

It is only when we feel that our complaints are being listened to that we can say, OK, that’s great – you have our support.

Personally, the best news I’ve heard all week came from Austin Gatt, who has finally acknowledged that the “roads” we are forced to drive on are unacceptable and that the constant digging up, and haphazard patching of roads will become a thing of the past. A new better co-ordinated unit has been set up and he has promised us results.

Our fingers are crossed, and our car suspensions will thank him.

Feels like summer

… or that’s what Net News would have us believe. In a feature on how much business and commerce there was on Valentine’s Day, they showed footage of restaurants jam-packed with couples. Then I did a double take…were those people dining at outdoor cafes actually wearing short sleeves and halter-neck tops? Not in these temperatures surely.

I may be wrong, but to me that footage looked suspiciously like something taken in the height of summer.

I realise that the Nationalist Party would like to have us believe that all is well and Malta is not feeling the pinch, but I am going to give them the benefit of the doubt and assume that the summertime footage was used by mistake.

I just know that it would not resort to that kind of deception.

Just how bad is it?

No one in his right mind (or who works in the private sector) wants Malta to go to the dogs.

It would be masochistic to take pleasure in seeing people out of work merely to gloat that the Nationalist Party got its economic policies all wrong. (Let’s leave aside for the moment that had it been the Labour Party in government, that’s exactly what would happen.)

But most of us are rational human beings who can make the connection between a recession, empty shops and restaurants and less money all around. If the butcher around the corner has seen a sharp drop in his customers, he won’t exactly be splurging on an evening out with his wife come Saturday night.

What we don’t want, however, is to be lied to. We want to be told exactly like it is, because we know how it is. Anyone who is somehow connected to private enterprise is fully aware that people are reluctant to part with their cash because the uncertainty brought about by the global crisis might hit them next. So the last thing we want is a whitewash, or an artificial “feel good” factor.

Those in power have a duty, and even a moral obligation, to talk straight with the nation. This is no time for clever marketing that promises the moon but lacks any real substance.

There is no shame in being honest – in fact, in the long run, that’s what most people prefer.

[email protected]

  • don't miss