The Foreign Minister has said that irregular migration is Malta’s biggest problem of the moment, and that it is stretching the islands’ resources to the limit. I’m afraid he overstates his case. Migration – irregular, illegal or whatever you choose to call it – is far from being Malta’s biggest problem. It may be the Foreign Minister’s biggest problem, because he has become immersed in it and cannot see the wider picture, but to the rest of us who are not posting racist and bigoted comments on the Internet, the country’s biggest problem is immediately apparent: making sure that Malta does not slip so far into recession that chaos and disruption ensue.
Whether there are 2,000, 3,000, 4,000 or 5,000 illegal immigrants locked up in pens called detention centres makes no difference to my life. If you’re honest with yourself, it makes no difference to your life, either. The only ones who believe that it makes a difference to their lives are the obsessed, who have fixed ideas about culture and identity and who feel threatened by those who are different, however tiny the minority. On the other hand, when the economy contracts all of us suffer, and the Foreign Minister should have it spelled out to him gently that Malta’s biggest problem is not his immigration bugbear but the very real possibility of a further contraction of the economy as we begin to feel the fall-out of what is happening in other markets.
Eurostat has released figures which show that Malta has had the worst decline in tourism figures in the European Union during the final four months of last year. Is that less of a problem than illegal immigration? I hardly think so. Nor do the hotel operators. The thing that the Foreign Minister seems not to understand is that illegal immigration is largely an irrelevance to all but those who make it their business to get uptight about it, and to behave as though it affects their lives when the reality is that it does not. To those who are struggling to keep a business going, to fight for new contracts, to look for new markets, to keep the revenue coming in and to keep thinking positive against the odds, the fact that the Foreign Minister and his troops have to contend with illegal immigrants is by the by, neither here nor there. There are more pressing matters on their minds.
Unfortunately, government spokesmen, certain MEPS and members of the Opposition are listening to ‘the people’ and forgetting that, most of the time, ‘the people’ think out of the seat of their pants and lack direction. The honest-to-god truth is that if you give ‘the people’ the choice between having the country over-run by illegal immigrants and keeping their job or having no illegal immigrants and losing their job, most of those people would choose the former option. What this means is that on the scale of what is most important to us, keeping our jobs and our income is far, far more crucial than not having illegal immigrants around. It follows, therefore, that any risk posed to our livelihood is a far bigger problem that the influx of immigrants from African States.
I can understand that Tonio Borg and Simon Busuttil are repetitively overstating their case in an attempt at getting action and attention from other member States of the European Union. What I can’t understand is the way they put their suit: that Malta is entitled to help from fellow member States because our geographical position puts us on the immigration front-line. The logic, unfortunately, is none too brilliant. If we are going to argue from the perspective of geography rather than, say, the perspective of relative poverty, then we are opening the way for some pretty impressive arguments from those countries whose borders are wide open and cannot be patrolled or policed, and which are so large that illegal immigrants can sneak in and just disappear.
Even if we plead special status, then we are opening ourselves up to scathing response from, say, the United Kingdom, where most of the immigrants are headed as the Promised Land. On the coast of France immediately opposite Britain, there are huge camps of illegal immigrants doing their damnedest to get across the water to a perceived heaven. Every night, hundreds of them leave the camps and try to break into the backs of lorries, strap themselves to the undercarriage of heavy vehicles, or find increasingly ingenious means of stowing away. Faced with this massive problem, the British are unlikely to be sympathetic to Malta. Nor will the French be sympathetic, given the problems they must contend with, caused by those hordes of illegal immigrants passing through their territory in the hope of reaching Britain.
The immigration debate has highlighted the fact that we still think of ourselves as a special case, a mentality inculcated into us by the administration of Dom Mintoff. We are not a special case. We are now a grown-up, fully-fledged State and a member of the European Union, and like all grown-ups, we have to face up to our own problems and deal with them without crying in the streets and asking for pity and sympathy. Thirty-four years after becoming a republic, we haven’t realised yet that there is no such thing as a free ride.
* * *
Edward Scicluna is a decent sort of chap and nice to speak to, but when you’ve wrapped a political banner around your head and are standing for election as a party candidate, you have to stop pretending that you’re an unbiased observer. When the news broke that Malta is edging towards recession, The Times asked Professor Scicluna for his views and quoted him without pointing out that he is a Labour candidate. Is that important, you might ask? Well, of course it is: when you’re campaigning for election under the banner of a political party, everything you say has to be framed in that context. It didn’t help that the other economist The Times chose to quote was another Labour man called Karm Farrugia. Neither of these two chaps could conceal a frisson of pleasure that things are not looking all that rosy. They came across as being more concerned with being proved right than with this country’s immediate destiny.
Daphne Caruana Galizia’s blog is at www.daphnecaruanagalizia.com