The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Shotgun Diplomacy

Malta Independent Thursday, 19 March 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

A couple of weeks ago, Joseph Muscat stood up in parliament and demanded an urgent debate on immigration. Malta has a crisis on its hands, he said, and it couldn’t wait.

Would that the prime minister had taken him at his word, and put all other parliamentary business on hold. It would have been such fun to watch Muscat go, casting about for inspiration and talking off the top of his head and out of the seat of his pants. He’s had all this time to prepare – though granted that he hasn’t many resources on which to draw – and the best he could come up with is an “action plan” (his words, not mine) that reads like a hysterical exercise in shotgun diplomacy.

You know what, Muscat? I had enough of shotgun diplomacy when I was growing up. It made Malta the pariah state of Europe. It made the Maltese feel like a joke on the rare occasions we could leave the borders of our island and get out and about. Muscat made it clear when he was chosen to be party leader that he would embrace that element of his party which has lingering Mintoffian beliefs and sentiments, but really, there are limits.

Ignoring our obligations under international law or using our vote to sabotage projects of common interest in European forums if we don’t get what we want on immigration are not options, even if Muscat is so politically illiterate that he thinks they are. What a shame the prime minister didn’t slam down hard on his opposite number when he said this, but that’s not his style. He tends to prefer the succinct remark, but the literal population out here just doesn’t get those.

I’ve said it before, but it’s worth saying again. What gets me most about the Opposition Leader is his apparent lack of intelligence. He can think a matter through only so far and no further. So let’s say Malta is prepared to suspend its international obligations, and to sabotage projects in European forums, which Muscat thinks is just dandy. It’s obvious that he is looking at this course of action in an absolute vacuum. He hasn’t thought far enough about it to understand that international obligations are a two-way street. If you suspend yours and dump on others, others will suspend theirs and dump on you. Even if they don’t go quite so far, there is bound to be some form of retaliation.

Some days ago, an Italian frigate picked up migrants whose boat was sinking. The captain wanted to put them ashore at Malta. Malta refused, saying that the nearest landfall was Lampedusa. Let’s say the Italian government had adopted Joseph Muscat’s outlook on things, and radioed instructions to its frigate to ignore Malta’s instructions and head here anyway, throwing the migrants overboard within swimming distance of Pretty Bay. What then? If we do that to Italy or Libya, Italy and Libya can send out their full military might. But if Italy does that to Malta, what can we do to stop it? We can send out an AFM patrol boat with a couple of soldiers on board who have never seen active service, to take on a fully equipped naval frigate. We needn’t ask what our reaction would be if Libya had to do that, because we’re there already, and we’re doing it.

International obligations favour tiny, weak players like Malta. And tiny, weak players like Malta are those with the most to lose when politicians begin suspending international obligations. It is those who are not particularly bright who are unable to see the bigger picture but only part of the detail. Unfortunately, Joseph Muscat’s ability to grasp the bigger picture was summed up by his prolonged and relentless hostility to EU membership, a hostility that lasted until he became a member of the European Parliament and was able, like St Thomas, to touch and believe. In his own words, it took him five years of hindsight to realise that the Yes vote won the referendum, though he couldn’t bring himself to wrench out through gritted teeth the words: “I was wrong”.

He likes the idea of a referendum now. He has said that if the prime minister doesn’t wish to adopt his plan for shotgun diplomacy, then the prime minister should put the matter to “the people” – the latest buzz-phrases for Joseph Muscat, his Labour Party, their elves, Astrid Vella, her FAA and various populist demagogues of the newspaper letters pages and on-line comments-boards being “the people have spoken” and “let the people decide”. It makes you wonder what they imagine parliamentary democracy is, or why MPs meet in something called the House of Representatives. Forty years after the rest of Europe, Malta has discovered the notion of People Power. Too bad that platform shoes and flares are out of style again, though you can still get away with love-beads.

So Muscat wants his “action plan” to be put to the vote in a referendum. Can you imagine anything more ridiculous? It’s frightening to think that a jackass like this could be running the country in four years’ time. Well, if he wants immediate action on immigration, he’s not going to get it with a protracted referendum, and certainly not when he needs at least five years of hindsight to come to terms with the result.

The government, Muscat said, should set down the number of migrants it could host and not deviate from that figure. What did I tell you about thinking so far and no further? He didn’t think himself to the point of what happens when the giant sign above Malta lights up fluorescently like those tabs on the doors of airplane lavatories, except in our case it won’t say “occupied” but “full up”. He must imagine that once he’s got those big signs up all round the coast, the occupants of leaky boats will turn right back and carry on towards Lampedusa. “It says there that they’re full up.” “Oh, OK then. Let’s go somewhere else.”

And as the Home Affairs Minister remarked scathingly, Muscat left out the most important bit: what happens when we have “no vacancies” and there are people out there drowning. Do we let them drown, on the basis that we have reached our quota? Muscat failed to answer, but his elves and acolytes did so on his behalf, on the comments-board of timesofmalta.com, where the racists and far-right-wingers are now congregating because their previous internet forum, vivamalta.org, has been shut down. “Give them food and water and send them on their way.” “Transfer them to a safer boat and head them off.” “Tow them out of our waters.” The real comments are ungrammatical, hysterical and ill-spelled, and they usually address government ministers and other senior personages by their first name, like Carm for the Home Affairs Minister, the only exception being the prime minister, who is GonziPN. The thing that strikes me about these comments is not so much their base inhumanity, but the fact that the people making them have spent their entire lives on a tiny island in the middle of the Mediterranean, and have absolutely no idea at all of the savagery and danger of the sea that surrounds them. They persist in thinking of it as a large and benign pool that stretches a short and uneventful distance to the North African shore, completely oblivious to its immeasurable perils.

Muscat cannot make a public appearance without referencing Barack Obama, and he brought him up again now. Barack Obama is deploying a heavy military presence on the Mexican border to control immigration. Again, Muscat thinks thus far and no further. Let me spell out the not-so-fine distinction, Mr Opposition Leader. Where there is a land-based border, a country can and will repel illegal immigrants, because it is a simple and entirely legal matter of keeping them on the other side of the “fence”. But when you don’t have a land-based border, and those illegal immigrants are coming in off the sea and are in your maritime area already, you can’t repel them. Not only are they within your sphere of responsibility, having entered your maritime area, but there are serious consequences to repelling a person on the sea that do not apply when repelling a person on land, drowning being foremost among them.

There’s more, but it will have to wait until Sunday.

Daphne Caruana Galizia’s blog is at www.daphnecaruanagalizia.com

  • don't miss