The European Union can only be successful in as much as it reflects the needs of its people. That it is far from doing so as yet is not only evidenced by the normally low European turnout for the Union’s Parliamentary elections, but even by some of the changes proposed by the Lisbon Reform Treaty itself, where some effort has been made to bridge the gap between the institution and the citizen.
Institutions matter, of course. How the EU member states take decisions in the Council of Ministers, and the way in which the council interacts with the European Commission, Parliament and Court of Justice determine whether the EU is effective. The EU’s institutions and decision-making procedures will never be perfect. But they need to function well for the EU to achieve its objectives, be it liberalising energy markets, fighting cross-border crime or negotiating with Russia, China or the US. Up to now, the member states have tried to manage change by unanimously agreed grand Treaties. The experience of a second “no”, this time from Ireland, is encouraging the EU to modify this practice so that the nations that shout “not for me” do not stop the proceedings. It is hardly the way to create confidence in the EU’s institutions.
The EU needs to resist the tendency to legislate on the basis of one size fits all, for this means that it is up to the dissenting state to argue its case. This is almost like being judged guilty and having to prove yourself innocent. A case in point is including abortion under the theme of reproductive health, when countries like Malta, Ireland and Poland have strong objections to the procedure.
After all, what the recent financial crises witnessed was each state guarding its own interests since each government at same stage will be answerable to its electorate. A few days ago we read that Italy is insisting that all immigrants picked up in Malta’s search and rescue area must be brought here. Italy has been, on the whole, a friend of Malta, but charity always begins at home for it is not Maltese votes that count for Berlusconi.
Since our joining the EU, Malta has gained in some spheres and in my opinion lost in others. We seem to be putting up a weak defence on vital matters that affect our very existence, culture and values simply to gain financially on matters which, while important, are philistine by comparison. When our main political parties agreed in Parliament to a new European Constitution (for that is what the Treaty of Lisbon amounts to) without explaining to the people certain proposals it contained like, one foreign policy, one president, one police force and a European Court of Justice that will increasingly overrule our own laws, they were massively supporting the democratic deficit that exists in the EU.
In view of all this, Malta must return to the European Parliament representatives who are ready to serve the citizens of Malta and not just the party they belong to. There is an important difference here. Loyalty to a party cannot be equated to loyalty to one’s country nor to loyalty towards its citizens. That is why it is vital that our people learn how the EU operates. They must be kept informed about what is being discussed in Brussels and due weight and importance must be given to their suggestions and ideas, for only in this way can the EU really become a home to us.
Azzjoni Nazzjonali has been consistent in defending Malta’s traditional values, its independence and territorial integrity. This is what it will defend in the European Parliament.
Dr Josie Muscat is Azzjoni Nazzjonali leader and a
candidate for EP elections