The record of Maltese MEPs in key European Parliament votes on energy and climate issues has been in the spotlight since an article appeared in The Malta Independent on Sunday (5 April) and a response by PN MEP Simon Busuttil (12 April). Both pieces refer to a new vote comparison tool on the website www.stopclimatechange.net, which allows members of the public to see how MEPs voted on key votes on energy and climate change issues.
The tool was created by the Greens/EFA group to try and shed some light on the complicated and sometimes nontransparent proceedings of the European Parliament. It uses voting records from the European Parliament on important votes, so the information is therefore objective – it comes from the European Parliament.
The purpose of the tool is to show that, despite the fact that most political parties have now embraced rhetoric on the importance of environmental, climate and energy issues, their deeds do not match their words. In short, they “talk the talk” but do not “walk the walk”.
Dr Busuttil claims that it is a “manipulated exercise” and that only a Green MEP can “pass the test”. This is simply not true and does not stand up to even a cursory examination of the vote comparison. The votes selected cover a number of important issues and MEPs from all political groups “pass the test” of supporting the necessary action on climate change and sustainable energy.
In fact, on a majority of selected votes at least three main European political groups in the European Parliament “pass the test”. That Dr Busuttil’s group (EPP) fails to pass any test on climate and energy votes is clearly more a reflection of the priority his group attaches to those issues.
Dr Busuttil goes on to react to specific votes dealt with by the tool but his article seems to misunderstand the issues at stake. As follows:
Greenhouse gas emissions targets
Take the vote on greenhouse gas emissions targets for 2050. While Dr Busuttil may claim that “PN MEPs voted for more realistic and achievable targets”, in fact they voted to disregard the recommendations of the UN IPCC on emissions reductions.
The UN IPCC fourth assessment report provides the scientific consensus on necessary emissions reductions. It does not go as far as many peer-reviewed scientific studies believe is necessary but it is a consensus position. So, by voting against the emissions reductions recommended by the UN IPCC, the PN was voting to disregard this recommendation. Even the US administration under Barack Obama supports emissions reductions along the lines of those proposed in the vote in question. The PN however does not.
Global warming
The PN MEPs (along with other MEPs) voted against an amendment seeking to ensure that EU policy is consistent with limiting warming to 2°C. This means limiting the role of so-called ‘offsetting’ to EU emissions reductions efforts.
Again, here we should refer to the UN IPCC – the scientific consensus. It recommends that industrialised countries reduce their greenhouse gas emissions by up to 40 per cent by 2020. It does not recommend that these countries should buy cheap credits in emissions reduction projects in developing countries, instead of reducing emissions domestically.
On the contrary, the scientists have confirmed that if industrialised countries do not deliver the recommended domestic reductions, developing countries will have to bear responsibility for much deeper reductions if we are to have a fighting chance of averting dangerous climate change. This is both unfair and unfeasible.
PN MEPs may believe that it makes more sense to shell out millions of euro buying up these offsets. However, the Greens believe that it makes more economic sense to invest in technologies (like renewable energy or green transport or sustainable agriculture) to deliver emissions reductions at home, thereby also creating economic and employment opportunities domestically, instead of investing to modernise Indian and Chinese industries and make them more competitive.
CO² emissions from cars
Dr Busuttil claims that while PN MEPs opposed an amendment to introduce the necessary emissions limits from cars, by voting in favour of the entire report with much lower emissions limits, it helped deliver “substantial improvements on emission standards from cars”. This is simply not true.
The limits proposed in the report in question, which have since been reflected in legislation adopted by the EU and supported by the EPP, would in effect allow car manufacturers to maintain the status quo and not have to make any improvements in their car fleets for years to come.
It is grossly misleading to rehash the line of some of the more polluting German car makers that more ambitious emissions standards would lead to job losses. The car industry is moving away from polluting gas-guzzlers. There are clear growth prospects for more fuel-efficient and less polluting cars.
European manufacturers are now at risk of missing the boat on this opportunity. As we have seen in the US, the new administration is helping to modernise the car industry with carrots and sticks, to ensure it can meet the demands of tomorrow’s motorists i.e. to produce fuel-efficient and cleaner cars.
Rather than protecting jobs, the regressive policies pursued by the PN MEPs and their friends in the EPP group risk holding Europe back. This will ultimately cost jobs in Maltese factories that produce car parts, as well as other factories.
For the Greens, at such a critical moment for our economy, jobs are perhaps the most paramount consideration. This is why we want to support industries to modernise and adapt, and to retrain workers. The PN, by contrast, seems to want to keep us shackled to a failed economic model and failed industries.
To paraphrase Dr Busuttil, the pattern is there.
Namely that for the PN (and their buddies in the EPP group), the only concern is maximising the short-term profits of outdated industries that refuse to adapt to the new economic (and social and environmental) realities.
We are already experiencing the enormous damage caused by the failed economic policies pursued by parties like those in the centre-right EPP group in which PN sits. They are now trying to bury their heads in the sand and tie us to the failed model they have created. They are trying to prolong the demise of failed industries, rather than supporting and encouraging those indigenous industries (and their workers) to adapt and take advantage of the new economic reality.
This is the top priority for the Greens: actively promoting a Green New Deal that will deliver millions of jobs in Europe. We want to transform our economies away from their wasteful model, which rewarded reckless speculation and the maximisation of short-term profits for a few privileged firms, towards a new more sustainable economy. This is why we – and other MEPs and groups but not the PN – voted and will continue to vote in a manner that aims to achieve this.
Please go and see for yourself and make up your own mind though.
Dr Turmes is a Green MEP
and climate and energy spokesman