The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

That Woman should get a job

Malta Independent Thursday, 23 April 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

“Reading – when described as a pastime – does not mean the occasional newspaper or even a daily newspaper. It does not mean magazines or The Economist. It does not mean online journals, blogs or news sites. It involves that dreaded word beginning with ‘b’ – real, actual books. Nor does it mean one book every three months, still less a book a year, which appears to be the norm among those who claim to enjoy reading. It means never being without

a book...”

I’m aware that I’m probably in a very tiny minority, but when I watched Stefania Carabott on Bondiplus last Monday, I felt overcome not with compassion but with immense irritation. Somebody should tell that woman to give herself a good shake and to stop parading herself in public as a professional widow.

She is not suffering from clinical depression and so has no excuse for not standing on her own two feet. Yet she has spent the last 10 months creating a tragic profile for herself as the “Simshar widow”, while everyone forgets that she isn’t the only Simshar widow and that one woman suffered a worse fate than losing her husband, because she lost her young child. Mrs Carabott clearly cannot identify with this particular fate because she has neither children of her own nor the imagination necessary for empathy.

Not once in that 90-minute show did she demonstrate any feeling for the child who died after suffering for days the torture of being exposed to the elements without food, water or rest, and in constant terror. On the contrary, she made a point of saying that “her Noel” gave the boy his clothes to protect him from the sun, and her face lit up as she described him as a hero for doing it. There wasn’t the slightest inkling of compassion for the boy himself. All I can say is that “her Noel” would have had to take his clothes off whether there was a boy to protect from the sun or not. Clothes are worse than useless in the water. They are a dead weight and restrict your ability to keep afloat. The alternative to draping them over the boy would have been letting them float off.

She didn’t impress me either when she claimed that she didn’t alert the authorities when she wanted to because the wife of the other fisherman warned her not to do so, that the boat would be confiscated if they were found to be up to something. In her next breath, she undermined herself by revealing that money was a factor in her decision not to raise the alarm, too. “I was afraid that if I raised the alarm and they had to pay something, then I would have to pay something too, and I can’t afford it.”

Maybe I’m strange, or maybe it’s because my family has been through something similar and so I have direct experience of it, but I can say with certainty that if my son or husband were out at sea long past the day they were due back and with all attempts at making contact failing repeatedly, then I would have the search and rescue services out there whatever it took and whatever the consequences, within hours not days, and given half a chance also within minutes. These two women don’t seem to have made a proper assessment of the risks inherent in either course of action – to raise the alarm or not to raise the alarm – and they do not seem to have compared the consequences of taking one course of action against the other. I just don’t get it.

But that’s by the by. What really annoys me about this woman – and it started when she made all that fuss in the newspapers about losing the roof over her head – is that she is only 29 years old, has no children, and yet she fully expects to live as a widow for the rest of her life, on a widow’s pension handed out by the state and with the Joint Office pulling out all the stops to make sure that she can hang on to the house in which she lives even if she might not have the right to do so.

Nobody has the guts to utter the magic sentence: “Pull your socks up, woman, and get a job.” Once she has a job, the problem of where to live solves itself, because with money you can pay rent. The islands are teeming with single, childless women of 29. Are they sitting on sofas bemoaning their fate and demanding that others hand them the living they think they are owed? No, they are out there, working. They are saving money to get on the property ladder. They are paying rent. At the age of 29 and with no children to look after, Mrs Carabott should head right back into the workforce, where she belongs. But I suspect that she is one of those women who thought that getting married meant she would never have to work again.

Well, tough – life doesn’t necessarily work out the way we planned it. I just find it absolutely horrific that people are jumping through hoops trying to find ways of ensuring that a perfectly healthy, childless woman of 29 will never have to pay her own way or put a roof over her own head.

If I were her, I wouldn’t go round claiming to have spent tens of thousands on restoring a piece of property that isn’t hers, either. She doesn’t work and her husband was a part-time fisherman. That aside, people with tens of thousands to splash out don’t spend them on doing up a house owned by someone else. They spend them on buying something of their own.

I might have had more sympathy had she not come across as somebody entirely wrapped up in herself and in her own problems, and worse, with that awful sense of entitlement. Is she the first woman to lose her husband in an accident? No. She should at least thank her lucky stars she doesn’t have small children for whom she now has to provide single-handedly. Is she the first woman of 29 who has to get a job to pay the bills? No. Is she the first woman of 29 who has to rent a flat or save up for a deposit on a small home? No. The sooner somebody tells her this, the better.

I steamed off to make a cup of tea when I heard her moan: “I never thought I would be living off a widow’s pension at 29.” Damn right, woman: you shouldn’t be living off a widow’s pension at 29. Go and get a job. You’re 29, not 59 – so unless you plan to live your life as a professional Simshar widow for the next 60 years, just get a grip and get on with it. And remember, other people died on that boat, too. One of them was just 10 years old.

There’s something so incredibly tasteless and attention-seeking about people who parade their grief on television. It never fails to ring my alarm bells.

Reading the

cornflakes packet

The National Statistics Office has told us that reading is the favourite hobby of 38 per cent of Maltese. You could have fooled me. I never see anyone reading. The clue as to whether a particular society is given to reading or not is the number of people seen reading in public places. In Malta, the only people seen reading in public are tourists. Maltese people do not read in cafes, on buses, on park benches, at the hairdresser’s, on the beach or even in waiting-rooms. Several times, I sat in a hospital waiting-room for up to three hours and I was the only person reading. Everyone else was staring and fidgeting.

So no, whatever the National Statistics Office may say – or rather, whatever people may have told the data-gatherers – I don’t think that reading can possibly be the preferred hobby of 38 per cent of Maltese people. If it were, there would be some evidence other than what they tell a researcher. Maltese homes are notoriously devoid of books and bookshelves. The islands are not exactly teeming with bookshops and libraries. The vast majority of people have great difficulty reading English and have little or nothing to read in Maltese. Sales of books, magazines and newspapers are falling. Membership of the public library is declining. And above all, you never see people reading.

Perhaps it all hinges on the definition of reading, and the clue is in the National Statistics Office’s conclusion that the fall in sales of newspapers, periodicals and books “could indicate a shift in reading habits from printed-book material to online journals and magazines.” The NSO hasn’t a clue what it is talking about. Gathering information online is just that: gathering information online. Technically, it involves reading – because you have to read the words on the screen to acquire the information you need. But reading the news or a couple of blogs on your computer screen no more constitutes “reading” – in the way it is normally understood – than does reading the ingredients off a cornflakes packet.

Our understanding of what constitutes reading as a pastime is not what it should be. Reading – when described as a pastime – does not mean the occasional newspaper or even a daily newspaper. It does not mean magazines or The Economist. It does not mean online journals, blogs or news sites. It involves that dreaded word beginning with “b” – real, actual books. Nor does it mean one book every three months, still less a book a year, which appears to be the norm among those who claim to enjoy reading. It means never being without a book, reading whenever you have a dead hour or are waiting around, making time to read, and not being able to go to sleep without reading at least a few pages. It means having shelves full of books, buying books as you do clothes, browsing the shelves of every bookshop you come across, and knowing which writers you prefer while occasionally trying out new ones.

That’s somebody who reads. Everyone else is somebody who knows how to read and occasionally does so, which is entirely different.

Daphne Caruana Galizia’s blog is at www.

daphnecaruanagalizia.com

  • don't miss