The Labour Party has filed a judicial protest – not the same as a civil suit, dear readers – on behalf of 17,600 “consumers” who are demanding the return of VAT paid on their car registration tax. So now we are no longer cittadini. We have become konsumaturi.
On 1 May at that Valletta rally, the Labour leader told us that the economy is going bust and that people are starving in the streets. Then on 2 May he issued a press release to all media telling us that 17,600 have bought cars. Hang on a minute. Those are just the ones who flocked behind his flag – in other words, a fraction of the total number.
That doesn’t sound much like a population on its uppers to me. While in the United States people are living in their cars because they’ve lost their homes, in Malta they’re buying cars and queuing up behind l-avukati tal-partit, Toni Abela and Spettur Farrugia, to get some tax back. You almost wish those people would be hit with a real economic crisis so that they might find out what it means, instead of living the Disney life they do. But then the trouble is that we would all go down with the rest of them.
You know, this might sound perverse but if the brilliant legal minds at Mile End have found a way to fight this, with their 17,600 documents and their 17,600 witnesses, then I hope they win it. By that time, Joseph Muscat will be Prime Minister and Charles Mangion will be Chancellor of the Exchequer and they’re the ones who will have to find that e50 million plus interest. But then again, the trouble is that they’ll have to wrench it off the rest of us, robbing Peter to pay Paul – because the government, as we know, doesn’t make money. It can only take it.
The bishop teaches economics
The Bishop of Gozo has taken to his pulpit once more with some well meant but misguided advice, telling people not to spend money and to prepare for the worst, so that jobs would be safeguarded.
Oh dear. The Curia has a lot of money and no doubt it also has financial consultants. Perhaps one of them could take the bishop aside and gently explain to him that it is precisely when people stop spending that crisis ensues.
If the bishop wants to do this country a good turn and help alleviate disaster, he should be telling us to carry on spending, to carry on eating out in restaurants, to go right on drinking in bars and buying new cars so that we can queue up behind Joseph Muscat and demand our VAT back, which we can then use to buy a nice outfit for the upcoming spate of 1,000-guest weddings.
Imagine what would happen if we were to follow the bishop’s advice. Hundreds of businesses would go bust within months, leaving thousands unemployed. The only way to keep businesses ticking over and people in employment is to spend, spend and spend some more. If you’re thinking of pulling in your horns and tightening those purse strings, just stop and think. That’s the quickest way to bring about the very result you’re trying to avoid. Your income depends on other people spending money, and other people’s income depends on you spending money.
While it’s a natural reaction to conserve your resources when you’re frightened and unsure, there’s a word to describe what happens when large numbers of people start doing the same thing as you are: recession. You stop spending because you want to, not because you have to, and before you know it, others have had to stop spending because they’ve lost their job and they have no money. And the dark downward spiral continues.
‘Mein liebe Schulz’
When the Labour leader finds himself in a bit of a tight spot, he calls in the Big Gun, mein liebe Martin Schulz. When he wanted Labour delegates to see how important he was in the big scheme of European things, so that they would vote him in to the party leadership, he flew in Schulz to sit by his side at a press conference and tell everyone what a clever boy he is.
Now he’s at it again. Last Friday at that May Day rally, he waved a piece of A4 paper about and announced with pride that it was a letter from mein liebe Schulz, leader of the European Socialists. He didn’t read it out and he didn’t fax it to the media, so for all we know it was just something that Toni Abela cobbled together for fun, like his letter from Barack Obama, which he read out at another Labour rally some months back (Obama is fluent in the idiom of working-class Maltese, apparently).
So mein liebe Schulz told Muscat – and here I have no choice but to quote Muscat because I can’t quote Schulz – that he is pledging his support to Malta “as a country with a unique problem of illegal immigration”. Schulz, too, speaks the idiom of working-class Maltese. “Malta cannot wait for the EU anymore,” Muscat told us he told him. Malta needs to be treated as a special case because the issue has become “too sensitive and urgent”.
Yes, and? Presumably, if the leader of the European Socialists has pledged his support on the matter of illegal immigration, then he has pledged that support to Malta and not to the Labour Party. It is not a fine distinction. It is a large and bright one, with bells on.
Muscat, like Alfred Sant, Karmenu Mifsud Bonnici and Dom Mintoff before him, trades on the ignorance of those who crowd up to listen to his words of wisdom. He knows that those people will be impressed if they are allowed to think that when the leader of the European Socialists pledges his support to the country, then he is pledging it to the Opposition party rather than to the government.
I must say, meaning absolutely no disparagement to the large numbers of highly educated people who support the Labour Party, that when the bulk of your support comes from people with the thinking skills of a cunning native and nothing else, then you have a really massive advantage over the competition, whose supporters are more critical and less easily hoodwinked and talked down to. That’s the main reason why – the secondary reason being the national predisposition toward hdura – that the two parties run neck and neck despite one being a bunch of people who couldn’t organise their way out of a paper-bag, and the other being – well, the people who revamped this place and took us into the euro zone.
So if mein liebe Schulz wishes to pledge his support to Malta in the ongoing illegal immigration debacle, then as a seasoned politician and not a Super One reporter promoted beyond his abilities he knows what to do: ring the Prime Minister, and not write to the leader of the Labour Party.
This is not just any old backbencher
When Alfred Sant wrote an “I told you so, VAT is wrong for Malta and we shouldn’t have joined the euro zone” piece for It-Torca last Sunday, reporters asked Joseph Muscat whether he agreed with him and whether this is the Labour Party’s official line.
Muscat dodged the question by saying that when the Prime Minister is asked about the dissenting views of Nationalist MPs, he claims they are part of the rainbow of opinions that is his party. So why can’t he do the same, Muscat wanted to know? I’d say the answer to that is simple: the Prime Minister doesn’t have any former prime ministers or former party leaders sitting on his backbench.
Alfred Sant is not just any old MP. He was party leader for 16 years and Prime Minister for 22 months. Muscat has the same problem with him that Sant in turn had with Mintoff: the belief that they are still the boss because they ran the show for so long. And just as Sant couldn’t corral Mintoff, shut him up or bring him on his side, so Muscat now has to contend with Sant carping against VAT, against the European Union, and especially against the euro zone, which kind of undermines the Europhile message he is trying so hard to transmit.
It is not so much a rainbow of views as a bunch of ferrets in a sack.
Diversity be damned
When the planning authority sealed off a Sliema flat used by Muslims as a mosque, the Muslims took to the Ghar id-Dud promenade just outside and began to pray there. People might have seen it as an entertaining respite from the relentless monotony of non-events on that stretch of seafront, but apparently not.
One newspaper dispatched a reporter to cover the proceedings, and he interviewed passers-by. “If this happens again, there’ll be trouble,” said one. “Malta is a Catholic country. They have no right to come here and pray in front of us,” said another, with a keen understanding of human rights, freedom of worship, and European Union membership, which she believes allow us to persecute Muslims and discriminate against them. “I don’t care what they do in the privacy of their own home, but not here. We’ve had enough. If you were to do the same in their country they would stone you.” Ah, an eye for an eye, and no understanding that Malta, unlike the countries one imagines she has in mind, respects human rights.
There was more. “I can’t understand how they could have been given a permit for this, including police presence and all,” said a man who the reporter described as being “visibly disturbed by what he saw”. If a group of men quietly praying in public disturbs him, then I strongly suggest he avoids the upcoming cocaine-fuelled paedophile orgy planned for Ta’ Qali. The visibly disturbed man continued: “They should go to a mosque. That is where they belong. Or in some hole somewhere. But not here where I bring my children to eat and have a good time.”
Clearly, he can’t have his children shocked, scandalised and corrupted by the sight of Muslims at prayer. “I would have had no problem if they were Catholics praying… in Malta we are all Catholics so it’s not a problem, but not them. Even the tourists were disgusted.” Yes, I’m sure they were. We have no Muslim tourists, but only tourists who have never met any Muslims.
When I hear these things, I am no longer surprised that 2,000 Africans penned behind a chain-link fence are considered to be an imminent threat to our health, wealth and happiness. Give me strength.
Daphne Caruana Galizia’s blog is at www.
daphnecaruanagalizia.com