A week ago Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi may have lost the first half of the immigration tie between Malta and Italy when he had to eat humble pie and accept into an Italian port a Turkish ship laden with immigrants spotted off Lampedusa, despite initial bullishness. Lawrence Gonzi stood his ground on the premise that immigrants in distress should be taken to the safest port of call whoever is responsible for the safety and rescue region (SAR) which, in this case, is Malta.
With their eyes firmly fixed on the European Parliament elections, the nationalists fully exploited the event in order to transmit the feel that they too can flex their muscles before any Euro demigod. Recently the Government has been feeling political pressure from the Opposition over immigration, has been harshly criticised for accepting a voluntary burden sharing mechanism in the EU that is worth tuppence, and has become very sensitive to public opinion which is evidently against reception-friendly policies for migrants.
When the dispute seemed to be over both the Maltese and Italian governments pretended to act like love birds – despite the fact that the cauldron of relations between Malta and Italy was boiling like never before. I, for one, was very suspicious that the Italians seemed to capitulate very quickly. The Italians are a very proud people and characteristically courteous – but with teeth as solid as steel behind their smiles. Their favorite tactic is to operate through counter-attacks (gioco di rimessa) – in other words they will be at your own goalmouth before you know it.
The Maltese Government was still patting itself on the back on the Pinar episode when most unexpectedly the wily Italians pulled a fast one on Malta. They turned back a Maltese patrol boat laden with immigrants fished off Lampedusa. According to the EU Commission and Malta these new arrivals should have been landed on Lampedusa, being the closest port of call, as happened in the Pinar case. But then the Italians too had stood their own ground on the premise that they are not responsible for the SAR, a position it would not relinquish this time.
The determining factor between the two incidents is that in the last one Malta was handicapped by the fact that the immigrants were already on board the Maltese patrol boat when it arrived outside Lampedusa. The Italians are saying that Lampedusa is not a safe port of call because it has no hospital. This is the cream of illogic as Lampedusa never had a hospital but nevertheless it always accepted immigrants in distress on the high seas until lately. But in reality, where immigration is concerned, flags, jurisdictions and hospitals are of little substance. It is the law of convenience that prevails.
In this particular case the problem became a Maltese one as soon as the immigrants were allowed to board the Maltese patrol boat. The Italians know it, apparently our Government doesn’t or it’s too naïve to realise. SAR or safest port whatever, the problem could only be offloaded with the cooperation of Italy that accepts them. But as long as the doors remain shut the problem will remain on board the vessel and on the laps of the Maltese Government.
In the first incident Malta could challenge Italy as far as it wanted because the immigrants were on board a Turkish ship outside Maltese territorial waters. But with the immigrants already on board a Maltese patrol boat and with the Italians refusing entry to Lampedusa there was little that could be done – past, present and future.
After Malta’s first half lead the Italians scored a brilliant draw on their first counter-attack. We now have to be, operationally on the high seas, doubly vigilant and subtle to avoid the Italians from taking an unassailable lead – more so that it is becoming ridiculously obvious that the Italian Lega Nord party, to which minister Maroni is affiliated, is questioning its own relevance in Italian politics after the Berlusconi – Fini merger. The Leghisti may be in search of a populist trumpcard called immigration and will flash it at the expense of Malta to try to make inroads among xenophobic Italian voters.
The Maltese Government must make it clear to the Italians that if, after the last incident, responsability is going to lie squarely on the shoulders of the country whose vessels pick up immigrants first, then Malta might serve Italy with the same treatment more sooner than later. Concomitantly the Government should lend an ear to Labour’s proposals and strongly signal to the EU that unless it legislates quickly on compulsory burden sharing Malta will act to preserve its national interest in those fora where it is at a par with the rest.
This is the moment the Maltese Government is expected to show its true mettle.
Dr Gavin Gulia LL.D., M.P.
(Dr Gulia is the Opposition’s Main Spokesman on the Economy and the Self-Employed)