The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Sustainability In health care

Malta Independent Wednesday, 13 May 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Sustainability in health care has become an issue. Indeed it can be envisaged that our health care system needs an overhaul, especially when it comes to first patient contact – primary care. This area has been neglected for a considerable time. The present system served us well for a long time, but over the last few years, strains from different parts could be felt. If you do not have a good and sustainable primary care system, it is inevitable that many more patients are referred to hospital. This leads to longer waiting lists and more expenditure.

A hospital physician is not a primary care physician, and indeed is held to a different standard of care. Inevitably, once a patient is an out-patient, more tests are done. When one considers the number of extra tests, the time in man-hours, from physicians, to nursing assistance at out-patients, to paramedical services, and the number of “extra” patients, which run into the hundreds every week, and which could have been dealt with in the primary care setting, one begins to understand the nature of our problem.

Recently, the casualty services of Mater Dei issued another call for GPs to work as primary care physicians within this service. It is obvious therefore that many people turn up at casualty, presumably many of them with a letter of referral by another doctor, who do not need any kind of emergency service. Of course the primary care doctor who referred them would not have had the means to assess the patient fully. Sometimes a GP wants an X-ray rather quickly; the only place to send the patient to is casualty.

For a long time family medicine, the main player in primary care, was considered by many the Cinderella of the profession. This is certainly not the case any longer. Doctors are highly trained and the Malta College of Family Doctors has seen to it that formal post-graduate training is to be put into place. Moreover vocational training has been set up within the Department of Health for all doctors to work in health care. This was a direct result of EU requirements. But the government is responsible for all doctors given the warrant to work in the community and therefore vocational training should be a must for all. This is really about the right of a patient to be seen by someone whom the government has released into the community and on whom one can put one’s trust. Patients do not go around asking whether their doctors have had vocational training. It should therefore be in place for all.

Family medicine is now a speciality in its own right. The specialist register, which contains specialities like internal medicine, surgery, psychiatry, etc, has also family practice on its list. This is not only recognised by the European Union but is a requirement. Doctors with several years experience were, by right, put on the list. But new doctors have to have their vocational training in order to have the right to be listed. But what is the use of this list if it does not translate into upholding it in (family) practice. If family practice is truly a speciality, then presumably there is more to it then the first MD qualification, which is in fact the case. This begs the question why can some not specialise and yet still be allowed to do practice. Is an MD enough? Do patients have a right to be seen by someone who is a specialist, once the EU has stated that GPs must specialise?

There are many areas which are the sole realm of primary care medicine and family medicine and which a hospital-trained doctor cannot tackle appropriately. In the first instance there is more specialisation in preventive medicine and in the management of chronic diseases over long periods of time than is the case in hospital. Then there are areas which the family doctor deals with in the community, such as screening, vaccination advice, child surveillance, care of elderly in the community, well-woman, and well-man clinics, drug and other substance abuse, and domestic violence. There are also the psycho-social issues besides the biological which family doctors are trained to consider in the assessment of any malady. People often present one problem only to reveal a hidden manifestation. One has to be trained to tackle problems in the community rather than refer cases; this requires that FPs are equipped to do so. Not to mention then the more subtle issues of how the disease of one individual affects the family and indeed how the family affect the illness in turn. The FP builds over time a genogram of the family knowing intricate details of family dynamics which allow for better management of a condition. All this is more conducive if we have patients registered with their family doctor. But patient registration is not enough. For it to be a success one must re-think and revamp the system.

If we want to sustain our primary care system, so that in turn it can sustain and remove the extra burden from the secondary care setting, then it is our obligation to see that only those doctors on the specialist list are allowed to practise in the community. Only in this way would the health department have the confidence to allow GPs to do the work which at present has to be rubber stamped by a specialist. This ranges from prescriptions to other procedures which can be done within this community setting.

For example, patients who need statins (an anti-cholesterol drug), or an SSRI (the new class of anti-depressants), must go through a consultant to get approval if they are to receive it as a free medicine. Now GPs prescribe these drugs all the time; so why not allow them to give approval of the drug. Is it our culture which lacks this trust in GPs; and if so, why? GPs act as gatekeepers in many countries; most notably the UK. When taking vocational training into account, UK doctors will be no more qualified than Maltese ones. Once they are on the specialist register, they have acquired the necessary trust.

Indeed it should be the case that consultants within the primary care system come from primary care themselves, and not from the hospital setting as is presently the case. It is true that hospital doctors do a stringent exam of the Royal College of Physicians. But, as has been pointed out, this is oriented to hospital medicine, and not primary care. Perhaps the fear is that GPs will over-prescribe. If they are allowed to be gatekeepers, this will probably not be the case. The fact is not that GPs over-prescribe, but that the system is more stringent in handing out certain drugs. We are oblivious to the fact that these drugs do indeed decrease the incidence of hospitalisation, costing the government less money.

In the UK, primary care is far from perfect, but they have come to the stage of having GPs with a special interest (GpsWI). A GP can have an interest in any area, say gastroenterology. Even if he or she cannot be on the specialist list of gastroenterology, certain procedures and tests can then be done in primary care. Hospital doctors can then dedicate themselves more to the cases which require their expertise.

Family doctors have done their part. Their colleges and associations have been on the forefront to introduce continuing medical education, continuing professional development (tens of thousands were invested, some paid for personally, to train the trainers), the introduction of undergraduate training in family medicine in the MD curriculum and a post-graduate Masters. If it were not for family doctors, vocational training would not be in place. Diplomas, both local and foreign, and Masters degrees, have been offered through the Malta College of FPs. By right family doctors (FPs), do not call themselves GPs any longer. It is now the government’s turn.

If one wants to decrease the burden and expense of the hospital setting, then one must invest in the primary care setting. It is also a true (although unfortunate) reality, that just like in any other profession, remuneration has to be considered. One cannot expect primary care doctors to go through more intense training to become specialists, and then continue to pay them a scale seven salary. If becoming a family doctor will require up to 10 years training, then one must adjust one’s salary accordingly. If one wants primary care doctors to take on more responsibility there must be trust on one side and more formal qualifications on the other. This is what college memberships, vocational training, and specialist registers are about. And as other countries that boast good family medicine services have periodic re-validation, so must this be introduced and phased in locally. We are no more special or better than our colleagues. Indeed local doctors do organise their own continuing education programmes through their associations, but this must be formalised and made more systematic to keep one’s licence. This will give the authorities the confidence required to entrust more onto primary care; which, as observed repeatedly by the World Health Organisation, is the key to better health care systems.

Pierre Mallia is Associate Professor in Family Medicine, Patients’ Rights and Bioethics at the University of Malta; he is also Ethics Advisor to the Medical Council of Malta.

  • don't miss