The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

It’s Not a general election, Joseph

Malta Independent Thursday, 14 May 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Joseph Muscat and his people are unable to distinguish between the election of MEPs to the European Parliament and the election of a party to government, so he is behaving as though the run-up to 6 June is a general election campaign, talking about national issues and telling us to choose our representatives in the European Parliament on the basis of how we feel about our water and electricity bills – as though an MEP deals with that kind of thing in Brussels and Strasbourg.

Now he’s dragged things up a notch, and so oh dear, here we go again, with some more false initiatives to avoid biting the divorce bullet. Just watch Muscat go, running the general election campaign of 2013 in the spring of 2009 when all he wants is three seats for his boys in the European Parliament.

It’s not so much that he and his people – those titans of political campaigning, Jason, Toni and Anglu – haven’t a clue as to the sort of issues a political party should be pressing home in an EP election campaign (the ability to press the right buttons, for example). It’s that when they go into the arena with their badly misplaced national issues which belong in a general election, even those make no sense and are wildly off the mark.

I keep getting the unpleasant sensation that Muscat can’t think things through, or that he’s being cynical like his predecessor was, and assuming that the people he’s addressing can’t reason things out so he might as well manipulate them. Either way, it’s worrying.

So this week, we had a headline: ‘Muscat calls for civil partnerships’. Oh goody, I thought – no problem with that. It would be nice for homosexual couples to have some kind of formal arrangement so that they don’t end up in the same kind of mess that so many heterosexual couples end up in when they can’t get married. But wouldn’t it make more sense to put the horse before the cart and legislate for divorce before legislating for civil partnerships for homosexual couples? Otherwise, all we’ll have is homosexual couples joining the ranks of the heterosexuals in agitating for divorce when their civil partnerships go belly up. That makes no sense at all.

Then I read further, and Muscat’s plans – which appear to have been scribbled on the back of a cereal packet while changing Soleil and Etoile’s nappies with one hand and eating a take-out with the other (“Jason, hu nota.”) are even more confused than I imagined at first.

He wants these civil partnerships to regulate the relationships of heterosexual couples as well. What? There is already a legal regime which regulates relationships between men and women. It’s been there for rather a long time, it’s fairly universal, and it’s called marriage. What Joseph Muscat is proposing here, with his civil partnerships for heterosexual couples, is either no different to a straightforward civil marriage, in which case it is redundant, or it is Civil Marriage II, a second-class partnership for second-class relationships.

If a man and a woman want their relationship regulated by the state, what they do is what the rest of us did: they get married. If they don’t get married, it’s because they don’t want their relationship regulated by the state. And if they want their relationship regulated by the state, but don’t get married, it’s because they can’t get married, because one of them is married already, to someone else, or both of them are.

So it stands to reason that the solution to this problem is not legislation for civil partnership. It is divorce, which would allow them to marry. A civil partnership would be conditional on divorce anyway, so it would be redundant immediately. If you are free to marry, you marry – you don’t go for a civil partnership. I can just imagine the reaction a man will get if, newly divorced and free to marry his woman, he gets down on one knee and says to her: “Will you partner civilly with me, my love?” He had better ensure there are no large and heavy objects nearby before he does this, because what he would be saying, in effect, and his beloved would understand this immediately, is that he feels obliged to regulate their relationship but he doesn’t want to take the full step of marriage, so he’s going for second best.

So why would a civil partnership be conditional on the civil partners having first been divorced from their spouses? I should think that would be obvious, even to a non-lawyer like Joseph Muscat, bookended as he is by the brilliant legal minds of Toni Abela and Anglu Farrugia. A person cannot be concurrently in a civil partnership with X and also married to Y. This would be little other than a form of bigamy, and unheard of anywhere in the world except where polygamy is permitted.

This is precisely why civil partnerships for heterosexual couples exist nowhere in Europe or elsewhere in the western world that I can think of: because if a heterosexual couple want to regulate their union, they get married, and the civil partnership they choose, if they don’t want a religious rite, is a civil marriage. There is no reason on earth why there should be something similar but of inferior status called partnership, though I do understand that perhaps the Malta Labour Party has a fixation on both the word and the concept.

The idea that there is something called a common-law marriage in Britain is entirely false, as many silly women have discovered after living with a man for years, bearing his children, helping him in his business, and then ending up thrown out of the house with nothing when he goes out one morning and doesn’t return, either because he’s run off or because he was killed in a road accident.

There is no secondary substitute for marriage, anywhere. It’s either marriage, or it’s nothing except a series of painful law suits in which you sue his ex-wife, his children by his ex-wife, his brother, sister, mother, and business partner for what you believe you are owed. Why do I assume that it’s the woman who ends up in trouble? That’s because it usually is. When her man can’t marry her because he’s married to somebody else, the solution isn’t a civil partnership so that he can have two ‘wives’ – a full wife and a half-wife. It’s divorce, so that he can stop using his pre-existing marriage as an excuse for avoiding marriage to the new woman in his life.

Because it’s always an excuse, isn’t it? The current situation of “Sorry, darling, I would love to marry you if only I could” is just so perfect for men, if they are the main provider and the one with the house, but far, far, far, from perfect for the woman who lives with them.

Muscat sees his initiative as a move towards the protection of the rights of cohabiting couples. But even here he hasn’t thought the situation through. Forcing legislation on people who might have consciously avoided the regulation of their union is completely unacceptable. It tramples on their rights, invades their privacy, and marks a return to the time many centuries ago when if two people of the lower social orders set up home together, they were regarded as being married (the same did not apply to people of wealth, who had to formalise their union).

How is Muscat’s law on cohabitation going to be applied? Is it going to be opt-in, opt-out, or mandatory? Let’s say Jimmy and Joan set up home together. Neither of them is married to anyone else. They just don’t want to be married, full stop – or one of them doesn’t. This means that they have consciously avoided regulating their relationship. They don’t want to formalise their union. They just want to live together, with no ties. It’s their decision and it’s nobody’s business, still less Prime Minister Muscat’s. Is he going to come along and tell them that he’s had their union formalised whether they like it or not, purely by virtue of their being cohabitees?

That’s what I mean about an invasion of privacy and a trampling on of rights. The same applies if only one half of the cohabiting couple doesn’t want the union formalised, but the other does. The state cannot impose on the other person, by default, participation in a formalised union when he or she hasn’t consented and, more so, has expressly ruled out willingness to formalise that union.

Participation in a formal, legal union requires conscious consent, expressly given before witnesses and recorded in the public registry. It is outrageous to suggest that a person can find himself or herself with the rights and obligations of a formal union purely through the act of setting up home with somebody with whom he or she has – or doesn’t have, as sometimes happens – a sexual relationship. And that is precisely why common-law partnerships are a fiction and not fact, despite the popular mythology. They violate a person’s rights.

Unfortunately, Joseph Muscat has joined in the same old game being played by politicians on both sides of the house for years: kicking divorce around the field and hoping that some deus ex machina will solve the problem or that it will somehow solve itself. Each political leader wants the other one to legislate for divorce so that he won’t have to do it himself. But it’s a safe bet that both political leaders are unsure how to react in the eventuality that the other one bites that bullet. Will they cooperate with each other or will they raise a ruckus about a free vote?

Muscat – what a surprise – is sitting on the fence already. He has said that he believes divorce to be a civil right. In the same breath, he has said that when he is prime minister he will bring a divorce bill before the house, but – and this is the big but on which the whole thing founders, raising doubts about his commitment to the matter – he will give his MPs a free vote, and that he hopes the Nationalists will do likewise.

This is such skewed thinking that I just don’t know where to begin tackling it. If he really believes that divorce is a civil right, then there should be no question of using the whip to ensure that all his MPs are present in the house and that they vote in favour. If it’s a civil right, then it’s a civil right, and not something to quibble about.

He knows, surely, that allowing a free vote will bring the most enormous pressure to bear on his MPs, especially the more righteous and churchy ones. Bereft of the excuse that the party whip has been brought to bear, they will be subject to the same sort of pressures that made them sign that ghastly petition calling for interference in the Constitution on matters of abortion. No matter how much Muscat tries to rebrand his conservative, xenophobic party as progressive, when it comes to the crunch they’re a bunch of chest-beating backwater bunnies.

For Muscat to claim that he hopes the future Nationalist Opposition will allow a free vote on his divorce bill, too, is doubly self-defeating. If he is going to give his people a free vote on that divorce bill, which means that a significant number of them will vote against it, then he is going to have to rely on the votes from the opposite side of the house to push his bill through. He should be hoping that the Nationalist leader brings out his whip and uses it for a mass vote in favour.

Joseph Muscat can’t make his mind up even about this. Interviewed by John Bundy taht it-tinda – because having given up on creating its own campaign, Labour has resorted to copying the Nationalist Party’s general election stratagems – he said that he might even have a referendum on divorce and “give the Maltese people a free vote”. That’s right, sir – go ahead and put a minority rights issue to the vote of the majority. Not to worry, though, because he can always ignore the result or claim that civil partnership won the referendum.

But of course, the really worrying thing is this: a divorce bill written on Labour’s malfunctioning computer and vetted by its legal beagles Anglu and Toni. Something tells me it’s going to be a polygamist’s nirvana, or the marital equivalent of CET.

Daphne Caruana Galizia’s blog is at ww.daphnecaruanagalizia.com

  • don't miss