The World Health Organisation and the World Organisation of National Councils of Associations and Academies, in a joint publication, have agreed that the basis of any health care system should be primary care. While it is acknowledged that primary care systems vary from country to country, both according to need and of course due to diverse modes of implementation, it is now becoming more and more clear that any system which is not based in the community will find itself in financial difficulties, as much of the work that can be done by primary care physicians will result in being carried out by secondary care centres.
The presumed aim of the government is to provide an efficient system of primary care which is easily accessible by the population while at the same time reduce current costs related mostly to referrals, which can be dealt with in the primary care setting. This in turn should contain costs and at the same time improve access to patients by providing a more personalised system.
The objectives of any system should be the following:
1. Health expenditure and health status
2. Efficiency
3. Accessibility
4. Equity
5. Social responsibility
6. Relevance to health needs
The current health centres are a metamorphosis of the original polyclinics introduced by a Labour administration. The former were introduced in ex-communist countries, most of which have now eliminated them, seeing them as non-efficient entities. In our country, many still refer to health centres as polyclinics and indeed there has been no substantial change other than cosmetic to the day-to-day running of the services. Even an attempt to introduce filing systems has failed in the past.
Conversely, the Prime Minister has recently acknowledged the important role that private family physicians play in our society. They charge a very nominal fee and provide a service that is gnomic of what a primary care system should be – that of having a personal doctor who knows you from birth to death (potentially) and who sees everyone indiscriminately of gender, age, race and so on. Indeed, the knowledge of primary care physicians, family doctors, is so broad that they are now justly recognised as a speciality.
The biopsychosocial model
The biopsychosocial model has become the philosophical paradigm of primary care. Inherently, this means that the family physician (FP) knows the patient and the family well enough to be able to deal not only with the disease as a biological entity, but also with how it is related to the psychological and social circumstances of the patient. The latter changes according to regions. It is obvious that such a model cannot be provided by existing health centres, as the doctors there do not play a role of FPs, although privately they do, and do not see patients on a continuous basis.
Conversely, private FPs have always found it unfair that people can ‘shop around’ for doctors as there is no patient registration. This can be dangerous for the patient and leads to unhealthy competition. Indeed, competition may be a factor, which gives an impetus to provide a better service; but undue market forces within a health care system may be counterproductive.
Dual system and registration
This dual system of health centres and private FPs has led to considerable confusion. Many health centres are grossly overworked, while private FPs may be under-worked. The lack of stimulus to work in health centres has led to their being underserved by doctors, who are largely unmotivated, even owing to undue charges related to, for example, refusing right to see patients after 5pm that are not emergencies.
The above has also led to private FPs being unable to take vacation leave, sick leave and study leave, without considerable loss to income.
Registration within this dual system will present severe problems. If patients are given a choice, some may see the benefit of registering with a private FP; others will feel insecure and register only with health centres. The latter would defeat the purpose of improving the primary point of care and leave it as it is. It may simply have an effect, in some areas, in which health centres are simply burdened with more numbers, leaving private practices with less. Also, there are areas that are underserved – for example; people from Zurrieq must go to the Floriana health centre and people from Zejtun to Paola. This is of course disadvantageous to people living in these areas. Doctors in these areas therefore have more patients and can afford to charge lower fees. In fact, the introduction of health centres has been associated with higher fees and if it were not for the fact that some doctors, notably politicians, charge less (which is seen as unethical by local regulations), fees could have gone even further up, amplifying what is already a system that does not provide equity.
Opportunities for
primary care
The government must look at the potential opportunities afforded by primary care, in particular private FPs. Subsidising FPs can be advantageous in many ways – something that pilot studies would of course have to demonstrate. In the UK, for example, GPs even do procedures, following proper training, like hysteroscopies and endoscopies, reducing waiting times and costs considerably. Locally, this can be implemented over time, but certainly the following procedures can easily be done: cautery, cryosurgery, minor surgery, blood analysis (various office equipment is available), urinalyses, primary care ultrasound, pregnancy visits (antenatal care) and screening. FPs will vary in the services they offer but this can be addressed over time.
Problems with private FPs
Certainly one cannot paint a picture of bliss when it comes to private FPs. Not all are members of the Malta College of Family Doctors; not all see Continuing Medical Education (CME) as an obligation – indeed there is no coherent system that offers adequate and relevant CME other than that introduced by the MCFD. Also, FPs vary in their practice and in what they feel comfortable seeing. Some would not see babies; others would not tackle issues like drug addiction or domestic violence.
Moreover, some have adequately equipped clinics of their own. Others simply carry a bag and see patients in a pharmacy. Most would provide out of hours service, but this is often at their own discretion. At whatever time they switch off their mobile phone is up to them.
Some doctors have a special interest in an area and some of these may have found it opportune to practice only in that area. There are only one or two Group Practices.
Problems facing private FPs
These are considerable and one cannot exhaust them all. Yet an improved system would have to address these issues, among which one can list:
• Lack of adequate rest and leave, including sick leave;
• Lack of proper insurance to cover in case of prolonged absence from work;
• Lack of proper recognition by authorities;
• Lack of adequate facilities to offer patients; such as physiotherapy, OT, etc;
• Lack of prescription power;
• 24/7 coverage of patient time with no protected time;
• Lack of proper programme of CME, which in turn is not obligatory;
• Lack of government authority over colleges and groups uniting doctors, seeing that they are adequately democratic; this led some doctors to not being members of any group.
Vocational training and the specialist registration
One can rightly question the use of a vocational training (VT) programme if it is not obligatory; indeed what is the use of a specialist register if it is not recognised by the government that to work in the community one has to be on this register. The government has a due responsibility to the public not only in seeing that doctors working in health centres are on the specialist register (as provided by EU regulations), but is morally responsible also for the doctors it allows to work in the private sector, especially in Malta, where these take on a considerable amount of work.
There is a lot to be said in this regard, which is beyond the scope of this report. Yet, to be effective, a system must prevent doctors having simply a first degree (MD) to work in the community. If FP is a speciality, then it is NOT about the doctor, but it is about the right of the patient. Patients have a right to be seen by doctors specialised in family practice and community care; the government has an obligation to see that such provision is adhered to, and doctor have a duty not to practice unless they are adequately trained, as is the case for all other specialities. FP cannot remain the “Cinderella” of medicine. If it is a speciality in its own right, then VT must be made obligatory to all new doctors, and existing doctors working in the community who are not already on the specialist register must be prohibited from practicing, on pain of removal from the medical council register, until they complete an adequate training programme. In short, the MD cannot remain an ‘exit’ degree in the sense that anyone working as an SHO in surgery or ENT, can spend a couple of hours in a pharmacy in the evening to boost his or her income. This is outright immoral once it is recognised that an FP must be a specialist. This is the sine qua non in most developed EU states. Even where, as in Italy, the ‘speciality’ is not recognised by law, one still has to do post-graduate Vocational Training for three years in order to be given a licence to work in the primary care system.
The question of speciality, of course, has a lot to do with a needs assessment of the country, and may include needs particular to a specific area and other procedures, which the government deems necessary that FPs provide – such as the procedures mentioned above.
There could be a minimum requirement imposed for the setting up of clinics. Conversely, it would be ridiculous to have standards of clinics, and at the same time allow the ‘doctor with the bag’ (on its own) to practise, and to allow young doctors specialising in another field, to dip their fingers into the community without the prerequisite knowledge.
While it is acceptable that some doctors may not feel comfortable in all areas, (e.g. drug addiction or family counselling), there should be a minimum standard provision, and indeed still have everything included in the curriculum. Thus, for example, a doctor must be able to detect child abuse and be trained to do so and know the proper course of action. In turn, a proper course of action must be standardized and provided by the NHS.
If the government wants to reduce referrals, it must increase its trust in FPs. This in turn breeds an obligation to train FPs and hold them accountable for CME. Conversely one must move away from a system in which any mishap reported by a patient works only to lower morale among doctors. One must certainly see that reported incidents are justified.
Health centres
These centres can remain as a back-up service. Indeed one cannot envisage a situation without a transition period. One may have to introduce pilot studies, as is being done with drug distribution. There may be a need to provide out of hour service, for example, to allow for FPs to have adequate rest and sick leave or to attend courses. This would be required if there is patient registration – as patients would obviously complain if they do not find their doctor. Health centres can and should provide better community services for physiotherapy, occupational therapy and so on. It is indeed pitiful to see patients who have just had a stroke having to travel to hospital in the heat of summer in a van. The trips, waiting times and so on, can take up the whole morning from 7am to 1pm just to have a mere 15-minute contact with a professional. Many patients give up this service after some time only to get worse, and then, of course, taxing the system due to inadequate potential recovery.
Group practices
The government may also think of schemes to improve and encourage group practices. In this way a patient may be registered with a group and doctors can follow a roster. Those who do not have premises could lease government facilities. Conversely, it is difficult, if not impossible, in the short term, to expect doctors to suddenly metamorphose into group practices. A system whereby doctors network to cover each other is probably more plausible in the short term.
Funding
Of course any change must consider funding. One cannot implement change without investing; and neither can one think of quick fixes. One must consider investments as an opportunity for reducing long-term costs (as presumably any improvement will bring about improvements in morbidity) and waiting lists. This may also need implementing certain changes in the secondary and tertiary systems, which are beyond the scope of this report but which might need to be tied to any changes in primary care.
This has to be balanced against the wasteful resource of having high referral rates to hospital, which in and of itself leads to an increased amount of investigations as doctors in the secondary care setting are held to a different standard of care than those in primary care. That is to say, once they are in the secondary care setting, doctors attending these centres must ‘investigate fully’. Some form of incentive and trust in the primary care setting must allow doctors to investigate accordingly in order to decide and play the role of gate-keeper to the secondary setting, without causing him or her (the doctor) undue risk of not referring a patient without having performed basic tests.
There are various ways to fund the proposed system, two of which have received particular mention.
The first is to have fixed salaries. To cover a population of 400,000, giving a load of 1,000 patients per doctor, one would need 400 FPs. This is in tune with the current SAC register. A salary of e50,000-e65,000 per doctor would give the government a contained cost. The disadvantage is that a fixed salary might reduce the motivation of personalised care when one realises that market forces no longer play a role. One must consider abuse of house calls; some discretion must be left for the doctor. On one hand, countries like Italy, where the system is government funded, the GP receives an extra fee for a house call. One could, on the other hand, contain in some way the number of house calls per person; a compromise would be to give a limited number of coupons to every individual, which may be transferable within a family. This way the government has control over the amount it spends, will continue to provide a free service, and unless a person can be justified that he or she would require more visits, the patient will use the coupons wisely, knowing that after they finish, they will have to resort again to a fee-for-service. Coupons can also be issued for a limited amount of procedures and investigations.
The government must invest in more training of teachers, and of VT. Teachers must have proper premises where to instruct trainees. Also, CME must be given its due importance. If this is to be left to a college, it must be supervised by some form of authority to see that each doctor not only acquires a number of yearly credits, but also over a span of years gives refreshers courses in all areas.
To conclude, the main objectives of primary care are prevention, management of chronic diseases and management of acute and emergency cases, acting as a gatekeeper to secondary care. This is coupled with the provision of procedures, an increase in the scope of which should certainly be contemplated to remove monopolies and reduce referrals. This change must come about by giving FPs more power but at the same time obliging them to be on the specialist register and preventing other doctors from having access to patients. It is to be seen as a government obligation to provide adequately trained doctors in the community, otherwise calling themselves specialists would have no significance other than patient perception, which the government cannot afford.
If we are to reach targets of reduced referrals and improved outcomes, these must be monitored and abuses, even on the part of patients, reduced. There must be some form of gate keeping even when phoning a doctor, with practice assistants receiving calls and making appointments. Otherwise, considerable time can be taken by intruding, as happens, on the time of other patients while the doctor takes a call. Visiting can also be related to the time needed for the consultation. Naturally, there will be teething problems that would have to be adjusted with pilot studies, or as time goes by – such as those requiring more time for counselling; or dealing with the heart-sink patient or the patient who exerts undue pressure on his or her doctor. Some people may need repeated visits for the same condition, and this may require some further form of relief for payment, as well as a compromise on the part of the doctor to avoid unnecessary visits, as it has been shown that this can be an incentive to increase income.
Last but not least, one cannot revise primary care while allowing the secondary care system to remain untouched. If primary care doctors are tied down to a highly regulated system, when other specialties continue to earn a salary in hospital and at the same time command hundred of euros every day from private practice, this will lead to a situation of stress especially if GPs are to be gatekeepers. It may also have the negative effect, as has happened in other countries, whereby family medicine becomes less popular to work in. When one considers that even in this area, 10 years of undergraduate and postgraduate training are necessary, then one may simply invest this time in areas that are more secure.
Prof. Pierre Mallia is Associate Professor of Family Medicine, Patients’ Rights and Bioethics at the University of Malta; he is also Ethics Adviser to the Medical Council of Malta and former president of the Malta College of Family Doctors