The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Iranian Blackout

Malta Independent Tuesday, 23 June 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 18 years ago

Iran is facing chaos after Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the hardline President, and Mir Hossein Mousavi, his moderate challenger, both claimed victory in a presidential election marked by an impressive turnout.

Scuffles broke out in the capital Tehran, just as Mr Mousavi claimed in a press conference that he had won by a “substantial margin”, despite irregularities. Only minutes later the state news agency declared that Mr Ahmadinejad had won, as the electoral chief went on to say that he had 69 per cent of the vote with 35 per cent of ballots counted.

There is no proof that Mr Ahmadinejad’s victory was fraudulent, but there is ample circumstantial evidence. The election authorities somehow counted about half the 39 million votes, by hand, within three hours of the polling stations closing. This is quite an astonishing feat, especially compared to the vote counting process of our European Parliament elections recently.

The claim that in 70 districts the number of votes counted exceeded the population, and that many polling stations shut while people were still queueing, is rather bizarre to say the least. The speed with which the regime flooded the streets with security forces and took down telephone and internet services after the result might also suggest that plans were laid well in advance.

The problem with this election, according to London-based Mideast analyst Amir Taheri, is that there is no independent monitoring at all in Iran with the interior ministry arguing that the Council of the Guardians of the Constitution, a “star chamber” of 12 mullahs, would have that role.

“Candidates are not allowed to be present at polling stations during voting or counting. Many voters are illiterate and officials help them fill in their ballot papers, so the possibilities for rigging are immense. And there are no booths in the polling stations so voting is done in public, not in private – a major obstacle for transparency,” Taheri said.

So the problem for opposition candidates in this election, said Taheri, the author of “The Persian Night,” is that there are no concrete examples of fraud because there was no monitoring. On this basis one could even say that all of Iran’s 10 presidential elections have been fraudulent or that all were fair. All have been held in the same way.

There is a possibility that there wouldn’t be the outcry there is now if Ahmadenijad hadn’t exaggerated the scale of the victory, unlike in previous presidential elections. “Many Iranians feel insulted by the results because they feel their vote didn’t count. Everybody knows, for instance that Ahmadinejad is unpopular in cities but he still won the vote there. That is why people are so angry.”

Another classic example is that opposition leader Moussavi who is an ethnic Azeri Turk, lost the province of Iranian Azerbaijan. Well, this is a bit like of Barack Obama losing the African American vote to John McCain in 2008.

The question hovering relentlessly is if the anger and protests on the streets will subside or spin out of control. In the 30-year history of the Islamic republic we have never really seen the revolutionary elite so divided. Both former centrist president Ayatollah Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani and Moussavi are now both opposition candidates. They feel the election was stolen from them and that the majority of public support is on their side.

Whether the election was rigged or not remains to be seen. What is sure is that the current hardline president presses the worst buttons in the context of the politics we are used to in serious democracies. Perfect examples are his denial of the Holocaust and belligerence towards Israel. Iran currently has one of the highest inflation rates in the world and high unemployment which does point at profound mismanagement. Whatever the result, we hope that it will lead to a more prosperous Iran.

David Casa is a Nationalist MEP

[email protected]

www.davidcasa.eu

  • don't miss