Well, that’s what I thought when I read about the latest tiresome controversy. Astrid Vella and her rag-tag band of freedom-fighters marched on Bahrija (“Oh my God, do you have a map? How do I get there? Isn’t that where Daphne lives? Oh, that’s Bidnija! Right! So I drive up to Rabat and then what?”) to claim that the Nationalist Party’s president had abused the system by getting permission to build a house in the valley there.
Or perhaps they claimed that the planning authority abused the system to accommodate him. I’m not quite sure which. Whatever it was, the overriding message was clear: the Nationalist Party president got that permit only because he is the Nationalist Party president. So some pigs are more equal than others. What Astrid and Jason Micallef – who was demonstrating with her – appear to be saying here is that if they were to apply for a permit to build on their land in Bahrija, they wouldn’t get one, because they are not the president of the Nationalist Party. I’d like to know on what basis they reached this conclusion, given that neither of them has tried.
You’re not going to get Astrid whining through a megaphone behind your front door unless you are the Nationalist Party president or some other Nationalist Party politician, so I would say that the opposite is true. Some pigs are actually less equal than others. If you’re involved with the Nationalist Party and Astrid decides she’s going to march down on you with a bunch of people who don’t know Bahrija from Bidnija, then you have a problem. Let’s put it this way, if you’re the president of the Labour Party with a building permit in Bahrija Valley, you’re not going to find Edward Scicluna demonstrating in the dust outside, as the president of the Nationalist Party did. No, he’ll be too busy totting up the cost of the power black-out last week and then speaking to The Times about it as ‘an economist’ rather than a Labour politician.
Unlike everyone else who can proceed in peace once they have that all-important permit, if you’re a prominent member of a political party you have to back down, submit yourself to police investigations and a zillion enquiries and risk having your project derailed. Nobody knows more than I do that this is what comes with the territory of being both in the public eye and politically active. But the point is that, precisely because of the democratic workings of the free press and demonstrations of concerned citizens, people in the public eye who are involved with politics are not more equal than others. They are less equal.
Unlike that housewife in Astrid’s band, who told the cameras that she has lived in Rabat for all 65 years of her life but had never been down to Bahrija before the demonstration (“I came to see it now before they ruin it.”), I have been there many times, mostly in a state of high dudgeon and surrounded by legions of wet boys liberally coated in rank mud. So I reserve judgement on whether that permit should or shouldn’t have been issued.
What I will say is that the president of the Nationalist Party – and, for that matter, of the Labour Party – has certain duties towards his public image and that of the political party he represents. There is no room for equivocation on that. Victor Scerri should have factored in the fall-out when he took a decision to apply for a permit to build there. He should have decided what he wanted more: the permit or his political position. In his place, I wouldn’t have done it, or I would have resigned my position first. Yes, there are some people in his sort of position who argue that they don’t see why they should behave correctly when so many others are doing far worse and getting away with it. I can’t bear that line of reasoning – “everybody’s doing it so why not me”. It can only end badly.
The president of the Nationalist Party has precisely the same right as you or I to apply for a permit to build in Bahrija Valley. But this is not about rights. It is about integrity, that annoying word that circumscribes the lives (or should do) of those in public life. Put simply, it’s like this: if you know that by your actions you are going to bring the political party you represent into disrepute and by extension cause harm to the government formed by that political party, then you avoid those actions. You might have a right to those actions, you might desperately long for whatever it is, the criticism and objections might be horribly unfair, but that’s sod’s law. There are always going to be rabble-rousers around ready to pounce on a house being built by a politician while ignoring the great swathes of hideousness built by Mr and Mrs Private Citizen.
If Victor Scerri is to be chastised for anything at all, it is for failing to resign his post before applying for a permit that he knew was bound to be highly controversial and to rebound on both party and government. I certainly wouldn’t chastise him for applying for that permit or for doing what he could to get it, as any other person would. I am quite sure that if all those people marching and demonstrating in the valley had a piece of land there with the possibility of a permit to build something, they would do exactly the same. The sight of Jason Micallef demonstrating against a potential house in Bahrija valley was particularly unconvincing.
So no, I don’t think Victor Scerri was wrong to apply for that permit or wrong to go ahead with the building once the permit came through. But I do think the president of the Nationalist Party was wrong to apply and wrong to go ahead.
I’m pleased to see that the architect on the project, Robert Musumeci, has sued Astrid Vella for libel. It’s about time somebody did. She doesn’t seem to understand that there’s a difference between speculating about people with friends over coffee and speculating about people through a megaphone in messages that she knows will be broadcast through the news media. It’s interesting to see that the lawyers fighting his case against Astrid are Labour MP Jose Herrera and former Super One journalist Veronique Dalli. This leads me to wonder whether the Labour Party will be staying off this one and letting Astrid Vella do its job by default instead.
Daphne Caruana Galizia’s blog is at www.daphnecaruanagalizia.com