When the PL changed its statute recently to my mind the most important change concerned our decision to turn the environment and sustainable development into one of our beliefs rather than mere policies. Technically anybody in the PL, from the leadership downwards will be in breach of the party statute if we take decisions that run counter to these two noble sectors.
This does not mean that we should take a fundamentalist approach on any issue, but when we talk of a balance between development and the environment we must ensure that it is a fine balance based on fairness and removed from vested interests. A balance that does not reduce either the environment or sustainable development to a buzz word!
I still need to be convinced that this statutory change has sank in amongst all strata of the party, but it would be mistaken of me to base myself on mere perceptions.
The litmus test for the Labour Party will be on its formal position and detailed technical reaction on the so called Mepa reform.
Although we shall be meeting shortly to finalise our position and to also discuss the detailed report that the Leader of the Opposition commissioned, I sincerely hope that rather than merely finding loopholes in government’s proposals the PL will be proactive and not reactive and come out with strong, bold and radical proposals that will genuinely show that we have sustainable development at heart.
We need to lead and not just follow. If there will be little to distinguish us and the PN then I do not blame disillusioned Nationalist voters for deciding to stick to the PN once again, come the next election time.
We need to have the courage to beef up watered down proposals by government, to come up with daring new suggestions, to be specific in our calls for enhanced and increased transparency and accountability and to show that rather than merely taming a monster we intend to give it the credibility that other institutions like the Ombudsman’s Office have always enjoyed.
Mepa must stop coming across like a more sophisticated Planning Area Permits Boards. Something we should keep our distance from rather than indulging in nostalgic reminiscences of it as some might be inclined to do.
Sometimes voters tend to wrongly feel at ease when we mix socially with MPs and officials from the other side. That is a petty appraisal to say the least. But if they see a few of us acting and behaving like strange bedfellows with Nationalists well known for speculation then I do not blame them for feeling let down by us.
Mepa’s Achilles Heel has always been enforcement and it will be now interesting to see how strong the political will to beef it up will be.
The same can be said for the Environment Directorate which hardly gets a mention in the report except for the flimsy proposal that it will get more resources. Labour must come out with bold proposals in this regard.
As you have noticed for political correctness sake I have stopped short of expressing myself on specifics at this stage, although I intend to speak up and write a series of detailed analyses in strict adherence to the environment and sustainable development brief I was given last year, when I consider it opportune to do so.
If we are to allow government to get away by extending further our environmental deficit it would be as sacrilegious as if we were to allow government to get away with its out of control fiscal deficits.
The people must be convinced that Mepa will be sincerely and genuinely overhauled rather than merely subjected to cosmetic surgery.
Mepa was always meant to be a custodian of the environment rather than a planners’ or an architects’ playground. Labour needs to show through its own actions that it sincerely thinks so too by submitting bold and radical counter proposals in this regard too.
When John Dalli had introduced his package of proposals on financial services although admittedly the major input came from his side and that of his technical experts, the financial services package would have been nothing compared to the beefed up version following the constructive and highly technical inputs, suggestions and amendments by Lino Spiteri and Karmenu Mifsud Bonnici. A national consensus can only be forged this way.
This is what the PL must do during the committee stage, way beyond the platitudes of the second reading in the House and the media statements issued by its communications department.
If the Mepa reform will succeed it must be a holistic exercise, ideally approved and suitably amended in the House which will only be subjected to minor adjustments and fine tuning as time goes by.
We need to be daring enough to tell the wheat from the chaff.
This was the sole reason why I accepted my environment and sustainable development portfolio.
[email protected]
www.leobrincat.com
Leo Brincat is the main opposition spokesperson for the environment, sustainable development and climate change