The Malta Environment and Planning Authority was set up to build distance between the politicians who run the country and those who decide on planning and development. This was a good step, and a reassuring one.
For decades, we had been subjected to the depredations of politicians who behaved like Father Christmas with their big bags of permits for the obedient people and their lumps of coal for those who were in the ruling party’s bad books.
It was not unknown for money to change hands. Politicians with the power to grant permits or withhold them were sitting on bags of gold. The scope for corruption was great.
An apolitical planning authority, hived off from the government and hedged around with barbed wire and an electric fence, was what Malta needed. And it was what Malta got.
Then things began to go askew. Controversial decisions were taken. Dubious steps were made. Procedures were not transparent. Doubts were raised. Rumours spread about backhanders and conflict of interest. Things became too bureaucratic, with applications bottle-necking and backing up in queues of four thousand.
When the planning permission system is inefficient or perceived to be corrupt, the inevitable happens: people try to circumvent it. Then there are cries of ‘Unfair!’ as those who beat the system get away with too much, while those who go through the system sometimes end up with nothing.
As resentment built up towards the real and perceived problems with the planning authority, the inevitable happened. Those whose thinking is on the muddied side began to agitate for a return to the system we had rejected already: political interference in the planning process.
The shouts and demands for politicians to interfere directly in planning became louder when Flimkien Ghal Ambjent Ahjar set itself up as the voice of the people and began to hit planning balls into the prime minister’s court, demanding that he intervenes personally to halt or direct planning procedures, thereby overriding the established regulatory system.
Those of us who are not quite so short-sighted, who believe in the rule of law and in the right of individuals not to be subjected to the whims of politicians where their property is concerned, were fully aware of the dangers inherent in the demands being made by FAA and its spokesman Astrid Vella. A prime minister who interrupts a building development on the basis that he doesn’t like it or that Astrid Vella and The People are objecting to it can do the same on any other whim. He can harass a developer because he doesn’t like him or wishes to pay him back. And the flipside is that he can aid and abet a friend in a controversial development.
It’s not as though we haven’t been there before, and it was most unpleasant.
The underlying and very silly assumption being made by certain people is that, because they trust this particular prime minister more than they trust the planning authority, they would much rather he made the decisions.
Ah, but Lawrence Gonzi is not going to be prime minister for ever – and even so, why we should be reduced to a situation in which our prime minister decides such matters? It is dangerous for us because we do not know who the prime minister will be 15 years down the line, and it is potentially ruinous for him.
When the prime minister wasn’t responsible for the decisions taken by the Mepa, he was held responsible and pilloried, so just imagine what lies in wait for a prime minister who actually is responsible for those decisions.
I find it curious that Flimkien Ghal Ambjent Ahjar and the other organisations with which it holds hands have adopted this schizoid approach to the nature of prime ministerial power. On the one hand, they say that the prime minister has too much power and takes decisions without consulting anyone. On the other hand, they wish him to take on the powers of a petty despot or absolute monarch and decide arbitrarily, or on the basis of what Astrid Vella’s people like or dislike, who may build what, when and how.
Their thinking is muddled and their reasoning is dishonest. But sadly, the prime minister has given in and it may yet prove to be his undoing. When I voted in approval of his electoral promise to take on responsibility for the planning authority, I believed that what he had in mind was reforming the existing system to make it more transparent, putting in place controls to make sure that conflicts of interest are done away with, that loopholes are closed and that there is as little scope for corruption as humanly possible.
I did not imagine that we would be seeing a return to the days when politicians made planning decisions based on who and what they liked and what would pay off in terms of electoral victory. I certainly did not vote for a return to the system in which a very loud, forceful and unelected small group of people twists the government’s arm into doing what they want. That’s what I voted against in 1987. I am not any happier with that situation because they come from my home parish of Stella Maris in Sliema, speak with smart accents and spend their Sundays at Tigne Beach. Nobody voted for those people and they have no right to run around trying to bully others into submission with their megaphones and their ‘you won’t get our vote’ performances on Super One.
The prime minister has released his proposals for reforms at the planning authority. These include shifting responsibility for planning policy from the authority back to the politicians. This is a serious business indeed, and only short-sighted fools can applaud it, along with those who are imagining already the opportunities for blackmail, pressure and exploitation to their own personal ends.
Like Astrid Vella, I trust Lawrence Gonzi’s judgment and it is beyond dispute that he is incorruptible. But unlike Astrid Vella, I understand that decisions like these cannot be taken on the basis of the here and now, but with an eye to what comes next: The long term. I also have the imagination and foresight to see that placing this kind of power in the hands of a prime minister is not just unacceptable, but extremely dangerous.
In this, I am at one with the national trust, Din L-Art Helwa, a serious organisation of long-standing repute, which takes a considered approach to such matters. Unfortunately, precisely because of this considered approach, which does not make for newspaper headlines or political controversy, Din L-Art Helwa’s voice has been drowned out by the screaming through megaphones of a couple of housewives who have found their calling as folk leaders. This is not unusual. Joan of Arc had nothing much to do, either, when she heard voices and put on a suit of armour to lead The People.
FAA’s views are the political equivalent of the pasta dishes served to long queues at a popular eatery in Ta’ Xbiex, and so they were always going to have citizen appeal, for the simple reason that rather a lot of people confuse emoting with thinking.
So while Mrs Vella and her FAA are all for political interference in planning, Din L-Art Helwa has issued a statement saying the opposite.
“While all policies must follow the environmental and development strategy set by the government,” the national trust said, “the details of planning policies should be drawn up and implemented at arm’s length from politicians and central government...While it is true that the Mepa has been subjected to a lot of pressure and many bad decisions have been taken, shifting the Mepa’s responsibility for policy back into the hands of ministers and politicians is a grave mistake. It is a step back into the past, when Din L-Art Helwa and many others campaigned in the 1980s for an independent authority to be entrusted with planning policy.”
For precisely this reason, Din L-Art Helwa refused to be a signatory to the press release issued jointly by other organisations, FAA among them, demanding that the prime minister intervene to stop the building of a house in Bahrija Valley.
As Martin Galea, Din L-Art Helwa’s president, explained to me in a telephone conversation about this matter, the solution to the problems with the Mepa is not a reversion to the 1980s system of planning-power in the hands of politicians, but fine-tuning the Mepa’s systems and overhauling others. Let’s put it this way: if your windows are giving you trouble, you fix the windows, not rip them out and return to the good old days of hanging empty sacks over the apertures.
But half-formed ideas and half-baked notions have taken root. Mrs Vella has sold to her people the theory that direct political interference in the planning process is a good and desirable thing, using to illustrate her purpose the example of what was achieved in scuppering plans for a cathedral museum beneath St John’s Square.
What Mrs Vella fails to explain properly to her people – perhaps because she hasn’t grasped the distinction herself – is that the prime minister’s calling of a halt to the application process for the museum was not political interference or an overriding of the regulatory process. The prime minister represents the government, and the government, along with the archbishop’s office, is responsible for St John’s Cathedral. The cathedral foundation is not composed of random people, but of representatives of the government and the archbishop’s curia. And so the prime minister, along with the archbishop, was not interfering in somebody else’s application in his role as the prime minister, which he cannot do as things stand at law, but simply withdrawing his own application made as the representative of the government.
Clearly, this was not understood by those who call themselves the people. Mrs Vella and her cohorts have done nothing to disabuse them of the notion that the prime minister can and should interfere in planning – which is why we have had demos and press releases calling upon him to do with the building of that place in Bahrija what he did with St John’s.
Political leaders must be careful always to isolate the voice of the mob and not give in to it. Mobs – even smart mobs calling themselves the people – rarely root their arguments in logic, reason and the common good. Their thinking is as poorly evolved as that of children: in the here and now, and hang what comes afterwards.
I am not one for biblical metaphors, but in a country which systematically indoctrinates its children and claims to be profoundly Catholic, it is astonishing that one of the greatest examples of the deeply distressing consequences of a leader giving in to the mob, against his better judgement, does not spring immediately to mind.
Pontius Pilate bent his will to that of The People, who today would be carrying placards lacking wit and be led by some misguided upstart with a megaphone. And just look what happened. The chocolate egg industry was born.
Daphne Caruana Galizia’s website is at www.daphnecaruanagalizia.com