The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

The Ryanair Base proposal – a route analysis (Part 2)

Malta Independent Sunday, 23 August 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 13 years ago

As our daily sister paper The Malta Independent reported recently, Ryan Air is in discussions with the Malta Tourism Authority over the setting up of a base in Malta and this could well become one of the topics during the parliamentary summer recess. The following analysis is based on the routes suggested by Ryanair.

Eastern EU/Krakow

The Krakow/Katowice area is a heavily populated region of Poland and a link with Ryanair or whoever (eg Wizzair, Air Malta) should be very welcome. Apart from Prague, Budapest, Sofia and, of course, the twin city Vienna/Bratislava, direct connections are basically non-existent and Warsaw only has a summer charter which, thankfully, was taken by legacy airlines LOT and Air Malta – at least for the high demand months – after LCC Centralwings failed.

But we should still ask why, during all the years when the Polish and other Eastern EU economies were doing much better than they are today, Ryanair never ran a service to any holiday destination from Krakow/Katowice, rightly concentrating on routes where there is ethnic and migrant worker demand or where people flew to Poland for a cheap evening in the pub or for an outdoor vacation, or whatever. The very few Poland-Spain/Italy routes have to be seen in conjunction with Polish workers in the agro or construction business. So – and now – do they genuinely want to start serving a purely holiday destination island with a long flying distance? Or is it maybe only just to gain support for the base idea from the “more routes from Eastern Europe” quarters, while actually not intending to fly?

It would be a pleasure to see Ryanair flying from all kinds of places around Poland and the Baltics, but are consumer markets strong enough? If Ryanair were a genuine low-cost leisure airline for the consumer it would, of course, be a nice innovation, but then there are Ryanair’s outrageous charges for luggage, and it has to be noted that direct booking hotel rates in Malta are often way more expensive than tour operator bulk bookings.

Again, we should welcome a Ryanair link with Krakow and, I might add, Wroclaw and Warsaw as well. It is just that the idea is not exactly likely or realistic, under present circumstances, so maybe it has more tactical value for negotiations.

TUNISIA

Do we seriously believe that this will bring (m)any tourists to Malta – when concurrently this is an economy from where one gets people arriving by flimsy boat and lodging at Hal Far?

Ryanair is not Maltese or Tunisian. Assuming that there is an EU-Tunisia open-skies agreement in place by the end of 2010, why on earth would people (tourists from the north, Tunisians living in the west of continental EU) want to first fly to Malta from, say, France, Belgium or Germany, disembark, do a new do-it-yourself check-in, then go to Tunisia, pay tons for Ryanair’s cycle-related charges, take little to zero luggage or pay a lot – when there is also the possibility of Ryanair non-stop flights? And even if they did, for many years Tunisian and European carriers have offered loads of non-stop flights from even second and third level airports – a good policy by Tunisair, in particular. And for a DIY-transit hub, Trapani is a far better location, saving several hundred kilometres and good money.

The route would be of little to zero value for incoming tourism and if Ryanair runs, then Air Malta and Sevenair should pull out.

TURKEY

Turkey has also been mentioned as a possibility. Air Malta introduced a code-share with THY in respect of Istanbul. THY is a strongly growing carrier, of high quality and at the same time reasonable fares, for connections to the Black Sea area, the Middle East and Asia – areas it is essential to be connected to, particularly in view of the Star Alliance.

However, there could indeed be more traffic: language learners/party kids coming to Malta, Maltese shoppers going out. Fares could be a bit lower, given a night flight with a stop, but if the Air Malta flight cease, there is no THY hub connection and, given that it is a triangle, no Sofia link, as this cannot stand alone. And with the current situation in Greece, a triangle with the addition of Thessaloniki as a genuinely new market is maybe not that likely, and the same goes for Bucharest in Romania. So, subtract all Sofia traffic from eventual Istanbul gains, because if Istanbul goes for Air Malta, it should cut Sofia.

So what about DIY transits á la hub Malta? With many very cheap non-stop flights from, for example, “little Turkey” Germany, including from second and third level airports, even to places in east Anatolia, with far better luggage rules than Ryanair’s, who on earth needs the lengthy diversion and DIY-transit hassle? And in any case, other places are more economically located, if one looks at the length of the trip: London-Istanbul via Malta: 3500km, via Hahn or direct: 2500km; Eindhoven-Istanbul via Malta: 3300km, via Bergamo: 2400km, direct: 2100km; Milan-Istanbul via Malta: 2600km, via Bari: 1800km, direct: 1700km. All these extra kilometres mean real costs, not just a few more euros.

So far, Ryanair is not operating to Turkey, so would Malta genuinely be a first, if there are more lucrative and logical routes – with no open-skies agreement even under consideration? It could, again, be another route to tickle the “hub Malta” idea for positive support when there is no case for hub traffic.

ISRAEL

For a long time I have been pointing out that this is a really neglected market. It brought good results when Air Malta ran but was stopped due to the sharp fall in demand caused by the new intifada following the Sharon Temple Mount visit and 9/11.

Today the Israeli consumer market is stronger than when two weekly flights ran very well. Tel Aviv airport grew impressively, even in 2008, so it is hard to understand what exactly has been hindering Air Malta in taking up the route again, or the authorities in not getting here an Israeli leisure carrier such as Arkia, Israir or ElAl’s Sun d’Or brand – all of which are flying to all kinds of places in the Euro Med. Israelis have less choice of destinations than tourists from other countries, Malta is just half the distance of southern Spain and English is of more help than in other places. Marketing efforts can be concentrated on a small, densely populated area.

However, here also an EU-Israel open-skies agreement would be necessary. Whether the Netanyahu government will proceed with one has to be seen, because there are also reasons for Israel being against it. With the geopolitical situation, Israel really depends on air links and thus has to see that its own airlines – that also fly in times of crisis and link it effectively to its traditional partners, the USA and the RSA, as well as Asia, are not made kaput by destroying viability on the Euro markets. A point rightly made by some airlines from non-EU countries such as the Ukraine is that while open-skies agreements are good for enabling EU carriers to grow and alleviate the intra-EU market of overcapacities, the airlines from non-EU countries often do not get any extra slots at commercially interesting airports, since these are blocked by EU carriers.

Anyway, any airline that wants to run deserves support. If there is no open-skies, Ryanair’s assumed readiness is of no use. Assuming it was cleared, it needs no Malta base, since a plane coming, for example, on the regular Trapani flight could just swap loads in Malta and continue. In any event, the route could be very successful for both carrier and destination Malta.

General issues

It can be assumed that a good number of existing flights would just be shifted from planes based in the source countries to planes at a Malta base, so there would actually be no new traffic/routes.

It can also be observed that Ryanair has not suggested any routes from Scandinavia although, as I have pointed out previously, there is potential there.

Volume rebates are legally highly controversial, since it would mean that large operators (in this case Air Malta and Ryanair) would have an advantage over smaller ones. But the EU prohibits applying dissimilar conditions to commercial partners for equivalent transactions, and infrastructure providers in a position of dominance – ie airports – have to avoid the discriminatory treatment of airlines and other operators at the same airport.

Furthermore, it is very strange that Ryanair, posing as a herald of free enterprise, is always the number one airline that needs “negotiations”, “help”, or whatever, from the state, as it is otherwise unable to compete with the likes of Air Malta and Easyjet on a level playing field.

According to Ryanair, 80 per cent of their passengers already travel without hold luggage, which means they are only coming for extremely short stays. This means that, assuming the same incentives input per passenger, other carriers – where normal checked luggage is not punished with horrendous charges as with Ryanair – deliver far more bednights per passenger, thus a better return on such investment per arrival. What matters to hotels and restaurants is not the number of arrivals, but the number of bednights.

Many airports have already seen Ryanair come and go, and they are known for holding to ransom places depending on them.

Ryanair’s Michael O’Leary told German business paper Handelsblatt (8 May 2006, translated from German): “In five years’ time we want to offer all our seats free of charge. We will have to retrieve the money from our partners.” In 2004, in the German weekly Die Zeit, he envisaged all Ryanair passengers travelling free of charge in (then) 10 years time, with fares entirely financed by according partners. So if Ryanair keeps to this, will it mean that Malta might one day pay a very good proportion of the whole in respect of Malta flight operations?

A lot of stuff has always been said about MIA’s charges. They are, however, way more transparent than those of most other airports and a good look at their website shows the interested public how low their landing and parking charges actually are, contrary to the impression certain quarters try to give. On the whole, therefore, instead of trying to run after the idea of volume rebates – which are, in any case, legally not possible with Malta in the EU (Malta outside the EU would have been better for Ryanair fans, as one would have an open-skies but would not have to keep to EU laws otherwise), or trying to tell people that whether or not tourists come to Malta all depends on five or whatever euros at MIA (when one has hotels charging rates per person per night of €200 or more, not to mention Ryanair’s charges for normally loaded luggage), it is better to incentivise routes according to specific cases where one has genuinely under-served areas, and not parallel flights. The policy that I pointed out previously, of asking for not too high frequencies, has brought good results, as it is better to ask for a not too high frequency and get it, rather than offer lots of money but for a totally unrealistic frequency – also for Ryanair – which then helps nobody.

Nobody has ever hindered Ryanair in setting up a base or operating any route, provided that they compete on the same level as all other airlines. It cannot be that, in some way or another, one gives them money to maybe even deliberately bring about the demise of one’s own airline. Growth with them should be directed in such a way that the result is not replacements but the addition of genuinely new areas. I have, coincidence or not, given many possible examples in this paper, some of which have materialised.

A functioning Air Malta with a broad route network, a strong fleet and a manpower that is appreciated for its efforts for the development of the Republic of Malta and its social responsibility as an employer, with its local staff given a fair chance, is essential for Malta as a tourist destination, as an economy, and as an island nation in the heart of the Mediterranean.

  • don't miss