In May of this year, the Commission adopted a proposal for a Directive on aviation security charges in Europe. At present, security costs at airports are regulated at national level, leading to lack of harmonisation between Member States. Users are not systematically consulted at all EU airports before charges are determined or before a charging system is modified. The already very challenging environment of the entire aviation sector, becomes even more challenging because of the lack of a fair playing field for airports and air carriers alike.
The aims of the Directive are to ensure transparency, non-discrimination and consultation of airlines when fixing the level of charges, as well as the cost-relatedness of security charges. The Directive applies to airports handling more than five million passengers per year – and, where that threshold is not met, the biggest airport in each Member State.
In a press statement made at the time, European Commissioner in charge of Transport, Antonio Tajani, said that the significant steps taken to ensure the protection of the public travelling by air has led to increased security costs for passengers. The implementation of this Directive ultimately aims to address this problem.
According to a Commission report issued last February, in order to ensure fair and undistorted competition between airlines and between airports, it is essential to ensure a non-discriminatory environment and to have strictly cost-related security charges. The Commission came up with a set of proposed measures built on these principles that should help create a fair competitive environment.
These are based on the following lines:
1. Non-discrimination: Security charges shall not discriminate between passengers or between airlines.
2. Consultation: The airport managing body and the air carriers serving the airport, or their representative organisations, must consult each other on the security charging system applicable at an airport both when such system is modified and also when the levels of the security charges are being established. This should facilitate the two parties’ exchange of views on a regular basis on charges. Before any decision is taken on the matter, Airports are obliged to take the airline’s views into account. In case no agreement is reached, the decision taken must be justified.
3. Transparency: Because of the broad range of airport regulation in the various Member States, the Directive states that a reasonable amount of information must nevertheless be provided by the operators to the air carriers to make the consultation process more meaningful. To this end, the Directive establishes which information should be provided on a regular basis by the airport managing body.
Despite this, the proposed Directive contains no provisions on the methods for calculating security charges that should be applied in each Member State. Air carriers should, in turn, give information as to their traffic forecasts, their intended fleet use and their present and future specific requirements at the airport, so as to allow the airport managing body to employ their capital and dedicate their capacity in an optimal manner.
4. Cost-relatedness: Security charges shall be exclusively used to meet security costs, and should take into account the grants and subsidies allocated by the authorities for security purposes, the cost of financing facilities and the costs of installations and security operations.
5. Independent authorities are proposed to be established in each Member State to ensure the correct application of the measures. These would also be entrusted with facilitating the resolution of disagreements between airports and users.
This Proposal for a Directive will be discussed during MEUSAC’s Transport, Telecommunications and Energy Sectoral Committee meeting in the coming days. Civil society organisations interested in enrolling in such sectoral committees are encouraged to make contact MEUSAC on [email protected].
Mr Abdilla is Administrative Secretary (Consultation) at the Malta-EU Steering and Action Committee