Why is it that every time that a disaster happens in the Sicilian Channel or thereabouts, every time deaths occur, the Italian government, specifically Foreign Minister Frattini, seems determined to beat up small Malta?
I was present when Prime Minister Gonzi visited Prime Minister Berlusconi last July, when Berlusconi publicly humiliated Frattini - when the Prime Minister is present, the foreign minister must remain silent - were his first words, unreported both by us Maltese media and by the Italian media. Those who expected the former European Commissioner to stand up and perhaps break a chair over Berlusconi's head were disappointed. It was as if nothing had happened. That gives you a measure of the man.
Let's take the wide picture. Italy has become quite an isolated state inside the EU. Of course, what has been called 'the Silvio show' has a lot to account for. (Read The Sack of Rome: Media + Money + Celebrity - Power - Silvio Berlusconi by Alexander Stille, professor at Columbia University's Graduate School of Journalism).
I do not need to go into the details, as probably every reader knows them by now. It has become this summer's most entertaining political story, which tended to be seen simply as a confirmation that Italian politics is a kind of incomprehensible 'opera buffa'
All this, and more, has been said by quite reputable papers and periodicals, from the Financial Times to The Economist.
On one level, what we have in Italy today is the natural progression of the personalised form of government begun by Berlusconi when, 14 years ago, he transformed himself from the country's richest person into a politician.
On another level, like some notorious politicians before him, he expresses the Italian machismo. In the words of Stille, "He has personalised and sexualised politics in ways that are straight out of the reality shows that proliferate on his networks".
More, he has now changed Italian institutions to reinforce his personalised form of rule. Apart from his defence against prosecution and his stronger defence to keep ownership of all his media, three years ago his government passed an electoral law that removed voters' ability to express individual preferences for this or that candidate, and gave party secretaries almost total control over who would run. This meant that it hardly mattered who was on the party list, thus helping to create the phenomenon of inadequately qualified and scantily clad starlet politicians.
There is no doubt that, misgivings apart, Italy is a fully-functioning Western democracy. The Opposition is alive and kicking. And even though it is deeply fragmented and disorganised, it keeps up with its full-blown criticism of anything done by the government, including its treatment of illegal immigrants.
Internationally, too, Berlusconi's government is now also isolated with regard to its relations with Libya. Libya is the biggest provider of crude oil to Italy by far, and its sovereign wealth fund may yet prop up some large Italian companies.
But when Mr Berlusconi arrives in Tripoli today for the 40th anniversary of the world's longest-living dictatorship, he will be the only one from Western Europe to do so (apart from President George Abela). Berlusconi will also be the first Western head of government to greet the Libyan leader since the festive homecoming of the convicted Lockerbie bomber, whose release has sparked off a furore in the US and the UK.
Just before he leaves for Libya, Berlusconi had one other issue to tackle. A reconciliation meeting planned for last Friday with Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone, the Vatican's Secretary of State, was cancelled. The meeting, actually a shared participation in a l'Aquila celebration (Le Perdonanze) and a dinner, was intended to be a reconciliation with the Church in the wake of harsh attacks by senior clergymen and Catholic papers and magazines on the premier's lifestyle.
But there are more than just personal lifestyles at stake. The Church has repeatedly condemned Berlusconi's deal with Libya last year through which Italy agreed to pay €3.5 billion as reparation for 25 years of colonial rule (in return Libya would offer infrastructure contracts to Italian bidders) and through which also Italy would force repatriate African refugees to Libya.
The UN estimates that so far Italy has forcibly repatriated 1,000 African refugees to a country that does not have human rights guarantees. These refugees are those found in international waters and not screened, as we do here, for refugee status since many of them have fled wars and conflicts in the Horn of Africa.
Internally, Berlusconi's weak position is exploited by the right-wing Northern League, which is pushing for an ever-tougher line against immigration. A game designed by Renzo Bossi, son of the Northern League's leader, Umberto Bossi, called "Bounce back the clandestine migrant", was removed from his Facebook site. A failure to block enough boats led to a message: "Try again: next time you'll manage to show you're a true Leaguer!"
But while La Famiglia Cristiana, distributed outside churches all over Italy, and the daily paper L'Avvenire, have taken a tough stand on the immigrant issue, their coverage has been in sharp contrast to the silence of the Pope and most of the hierarchy, which has found a useful political ally in Berlusconi on issues such as artificial insemination and abortion.
Berlusconi and his allies point out that the Spanish church said nothing when Prime Minister Zapatero, with the help of the Moroccan army, shoots to kill illegal immigrants seen scaling the electric fence between the Spanish enclaves of Ceuta and Melilla and Morocco.
But their greatest complaint is against the European Union as a whole. Fortress Europe estimates that between 1998 and 2007, 10,000 asylum seekers died trying to enter Europe. One-third of them were never found. In the Sicilian Channel 2,260 died; the bodies of 1,365 were never found.
Not exactly a 'Shoah' as L'Avvenire entitled it (some saw in this an anti-Semitic trend, trying to relativise the Holocaust), but 100 times more than the dead of Gaza about which the EU made so many protests. On the immigrant issue in the Mediterranean, the Italians say, and they are right, the EU sees nothing, does nothing, says nothing except make empty promises.
As the Italians see it, the EU simply refuses to see the true dimensions of this enduring tragedy, which is mostly managed by crime organisations. As the Italians see it, the only time the EU moved was to condemn the Italian forced repatriation law (and the other new law that declares illegal immigration a crime).
Hence the latent anger and frustration that erupted against small Malta over the last boat incident. I make it clear here that my remit is not to defend the Armed Forces regardless of anything. I feel the AFM and the government could, and should, have reacted better to Frattini's outbursts. Coming up with a photo of a boat with five people a week after the event may not have been the enormous boomerang the Italian media made it out to be, but some small discrepancies could have been addressed and in a way the photo on its own does not explain everything.
At first, the Italian media hinted (and more than hinted, actually said) that the Maltese knew about the drifting boat and allowed the 75 to drown before approaching the boat and, by the Maltese's own admission, giving them fuel and food to enable them to get to Lampedusa. This was the main charge, until the SAR charge was brought up. But this charge was never proved, nor sustained.
The Maltese never, to my knowledge, replied properly to this charge except for Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici, who speaking in rather generic terms, told La Sicilia that asylum seekers just do not want to come to Malta. The Maltese claim that the five remaining immigrants on the boat, including Titi Tazrar, the only woman to be saved, who, to Fini's great anger, was visited by the Left's Franceschini in a vote-gathering mode, looked healthy, a claim belied by the very poor state in which they were landed at Lampedusa some hours later. Some things are better not said at all.
But anyway, what was the charge, the one now being investigated by Sicilian magistrates? It would seem omission of helping people in danger at sea. Let's see how the investigation progresses.
Which brings me to the SAR claim that Frattini keeps making. First of all, the issue here was the death at sea of 75 migrants, who, before they made it to the Italian area of influence, were in the Libyan sector. No issue of SAR there. Unfortunately, there will be deaths at sea, seeing that asylum seekers persist in using small open boats in such open seas. Of course, it is the duty of anyone to help save lives in danger. Even though, whatever Frattini says in a forthcoming interview on Panorama to be published this week (text of interview is available on the Italian Foreign Ministry website), according to the present new Italian law any Italian fisherman who dares help the migrants can be charged with helping illegal immigrants.
This is not the first time that Frattini mentioned the SAR, even getting his dimensions wrong. Anytime something happens near Malta, it's the SAR that gets the mention. Small Malta cannot police an area that extends from Crete to Tunisia.
There may be a reason for such Italian insistence: and this emerges from the very last sentence of the interview already mentioned with Carm. Mifsud Bonnici in La Sicilia. Journalist Salvatore Fuca wrote: Behind all this there may also be economic interests linked to the possibility of searching for oil in the area of competence.
Still, the Maltese argument to retain the SAR, if it really matters, and if we really can police it, must be beefed up in anticipation of what's coming at the October EU Council.
Let me make one thing clear: I do not think the SAR is vital to Malta's interests, as some say, but I am not ready to accept Malta becoming Italy's whipping boy whenever Italy finds itself in a corner, internally or internationally.
The October summit may be, if the Irish play ball, the last opportunity for Malta to use its veto power before the Lisbon Treaty comes into effect and decisions are taken by a qualified majority. Malta, not a small island the size of Elba, as the Italian media said, or even worse as Umberto Bossi said, must not allow Italy to wipe the floor with it. This would be back to the old days when Italy wanted to re-take Malta and reduce it to a backwater of Sicily.
Nor is it acceptable to have 'giornalismo di spazzatura' as evidenced by two articles by Rolla Scolari in Il Giornale last Monday and Tuesday. Grabbing a pair of stories from the day's Maltese papers, she came to the conclusion that in violence, corruption and scandals Malta resembles a Parisian suburb. The other article she entitled "A voyage in Europe's black hole that pushes immigrants to sea".
Of course, she laces her article with quotes and interviews with all the usual names, from Fr Joseph Cassar of the Jesuits Refugee Centre, to journalists (some of whom make quite extraordinary claims), to UNHCR.
She does not tell her readers what UNHCR and the Church say about Italy's ways of treating illegal immigrants. Nor does Malta forcefully repatriate immigrants found on the high seas. But her readers would normally be expected to know that her paper is managed by none other than Paolo Berlusconi, Silvio's brother.
As another journalist, Maurizio Stefanini, has said, 66 per cent of Maltese today understand Italian, a far cry from the 14 per cent of 1934 who wanted integration with Italy. People know all about Italy, even more than the Italians are allowed to get to know through the tightly controlled State or Mediaset media. And so does the rest of Europe, even if it doesn't understand Italian.
In the Panorama interview already mentioned, Frattini says he is afraid of the vetoes at the forthcoming council and he even mentions some possible candidates - Belgium, Denmark, Germany, Austria and Poland. These countries, he says, may not want to help share out the refugees who cross over from Africa. It will be difficult for Malta to make its reasons understood, and so will it be for Italy. Which is one other reason why the two neighbouring countries must have better relations, without Italy making a beeline for SAR anytime a tragedy happens. If SAR is too big for Malta, and if Italy keeps complaining the EU is not helping, why in heaven's sake does it want a slice of SAR?
[email protected]